Oracle, Justice Department Spar Over Market Definition
The two sides at the antitrust trial of Oracle's bid to take over PeopleSoft sought to support their depictions of the enterprise application software market.
Day two of the antitrust trial in the Justice Department's effort to block Oracle's takeover bid for PeopleSoft saw attorneys for both sides question PeopleSoft chief technology officer Richard Bergquist, each seeking answers to support contrary depictions of the competitive landscape.
Fielding questions from government attorney Phillip Malone, Bergquist described the world of enterprise applications software as being populated principally by Oracle, PeopleSoft, and SAP. According to Bergquist, these three companies represent the only serious competitors when it comes to human-resource management and financial-management software for large companies with complex needs.
And PeopleSoft, by his estimation, has been competing with increasing effectiveness. In 1995, he testified, the revenue gap between SAP and PeopleSoft and between Oracle and PeopleSoft for such applications was 7-to1 and 15-to-1 respectively. Today, it has narrowed to 3.8-to-1 and 4.3-to-1. And this while Oracle has been spending $1 billion a year on R&D, compared with $420 million spent annually by PeopleSoft.
Bergquist dismissed other possible competitors by asserting that they belonged in a different category, the so-called middle market. He characterized enterprise software maker Lawson Software as lacking key features in its products, such as automation, Unicode support, and foreign accounting models. He similarly dismissed American Management Systems, his former employer, making it out as a niche player rather than a
Oracle attorney Daniel Wall sought to tear down the market silos Bergquist had described earlier. He brought up several companies in an effort to ascertain whether there was any clear way to determine whether these companies represented middle-market prospects or large, complex enterprises.
"Are there clear dividing lines of any kind?" Wall asked at one point. Bergquist conceded that he had not seen any.
Having suggested that there's more to the enterprise application software market than the big three, Wall introduced into evidence E-mail from PeopleSoft that described American Management Systems as "a very formidable competitor and a serious threat." The introduction of additional internal documents, such as a guide to PeopleSoft salespeople offering instruction in how to "beat Lawson," further undermined the government's position that competition in PeopleSoft's market is scarce.
Top IT Trends to Watch in Financial ServicesIT pros at banks, investment houses, insurance companies, and other financial services organizations are focused on a range of issues, from peer-to-peer lending to cybersecurity to performance, agility, and compliance. It all matters.
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on InformationWeek.com for the week of September 25, 2016. We'll be talking with the InformationWeek.com editors and correspondents who brought you the top stories of the week to get the "story behind the story."