Guide to the TechWeb Network


The InformationWeek -- Blogs
Over The Air

Mobility Breifing Center -- Sponsored by Windows Mobile
Topics:   Mobile

  • Email this page E-mail this page
  • |  Print this page Print this page
  • |   Bookmark and Share

Will NTP Sue Every Wireless Company?


Posted by Stephen Wellman, Sep 12, 2007 12:25 PM

It seems holding company NTP just loves to sue wireless companies. After winning $612.5 million from BlackBerry maker RIM with its controversial patents on wireless e-mail technology, NTP went after smartphone maker Palm at the end of last year using the same contested patents. Not finished, NTP is now suing U.S. wireless carriers that offer mobile e-mail. Will NTP ever stop?

Here is a look at NTP's latest series of lawsuits:

The lawsuits, against Verizon Wireless, Sprint Nextel Corp, T-Mobile USA and the mobile unit of AT&T were filed September 7 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, according to court documents.

NTP, which is asserting patents related to products, processes and services used for wireless e-mail systems, said it was seeking a jury trial, injunctive relief and monetary damages.

So far the carriers have yet to comment on the lawsuit. Apparently the lawsuit does not involve BlackBerry e-mail service offered over these carriers' networks, but centers on other mobile e-mail services.

NTP has emerged as a famous example of so-called patent trolls, holding companies that patent technology that they never actually use. These holding companies go after innovators, like RIM, who build successful businesses using technology that the holding companies claim as their own.

NTP's status as a patent troll is also an issue of debate. NTP was founded by the late Tom Campana, an entrepreneur who founded the holding company to protect his patents after his business failed.

Most of NTP's critics, however, claim that while Campana may have had interesting ideas, his patents actually bare only a slight resemblance to the wireless messaging systems that RIM, Palm, and carriers like Verizon Wireless, AT&T, and Sprint use to deliver mobile e-mail. This is why the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office rejected NTP's patent claims in 2005 during the middle of the NTP, RIM lawsuit. While NTP is still appealing the office's decision, many technologists claim that the office made the right call. Critics also point out that Campana ultimately failed and that the patent system needs to reward innovators like RIM that build successful businesses.

NTP's lawsuit against RIM helped make patent reform one of the hot button issues for the tech industry. If proposed reforms ever make it into law, companies like NTP would find it much more difficult to patent technologies they never built. It would also require greater specificity in patents, making it much harder for lawyers to patent broad concepts.

It also looks like NTP may not be as successful with Palm as it was with RIM. A judge in the NTP, Palm lawsuit granted a stay of the suit in March and struck down one of NTP's complaints against Palm.

What do you think? Will NTP's lawsuit against Verizon Wireless, AT&T, and Sprint fail? Or will NTP cash out once again?

« A Focused Way To Search Discussions | Main | Palm Intros New Treo Hardware »



Tomorrow's CIO: Do you have what it takes?
Find out at the 2008 InformationWeek 500 Conference
Sept. 14-16, St. Regis Resort, Monarch Beach, Calif.


Sign up now for the weekly InformationWeek Blog Newsletter.


This is a public forum. United Business Media and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not control what is posted herein. United Business Media makes no warranties or guarantees concerning any advice dispensed by its staff members or readers.

Community standards in this comment area do not permit hate language, excessive profanity, or other patently offensive language. Please be aware that all information posted to this comment area becomes the property of United Business Media LLC and may be edited and republished in print or electronic format as outlined in United Business Media's Terms of Service.

Important Note: This comment area is NOT intended for commercial messages or solicitations of business.




Mobile Video



  1. Windows Vista: The OS About Nothing
  2. You Thought Vista Was Bad?
  3. Google Chrome: Browser Or Cloud Operating System?
  4. Apple Nixes 'Pull My Finger' App, Even Though It's A Gas
  5. Sarah Palin's Babygate And The Future Of Journalism


  1. Radical Desktops Deliver Power To The People. But What About IT?
  2. Need Disaster Recovery On The Cheap? Think Virtualization
  3. No Virtualizing Without A License
  4. Smart Stuff: The State Of Business Intelligence 2008
  5. Down To Business: Are Technology Leaders Focusing Too Much On The Small Stuff?
  6. Rolling Review Wrap-Up: Vendors' RFP Responses Make The Case For Switching

 
 

  Ars Technica
Boing Boing
Channel 9 Forums
CRN Blogs
Dr.Dobb's Portal: Blogs
Engadget
Gizmodo
GrokLaw
  Lifehacker
Schneier on Security
Slashdot
TechCrunch
Techdirt
Techmeme
Valleywag

  FEBRUARY 2008
JANUARY 2008
DECEMBER 2007
NOVEMBER 2007
OCTOBER 2007
SEPTEMBER 2007
AUGUST 2007
JULY 2007
  JUNE 2007
MAY 2007
APRIL 2007
MARCH 2007
FEBRUARY 2007
JANUARY 2007
DECEMBER 2006
NOVEMBER 2006