Commentary
A Little Heresy Now And Then ...
" ... is relished by even the wisest men." (I'm paraphrasing.) Meaning it helps from time to time to dissent, albeit thoughtfully and with eyes wide open, from the status quo. In today's example, it's Eric S. Raymond -- one of the key figures in the open source / free software world -- talking about why the GPL might have outlived its usefulness. You heard right.
" ... is relished by even the wisest men." (I'm paraphrasing.) Meaning it helps from time to time to dissent, albeit thoughtfully and with eyes wide open, from the status quo. In today's example, it's Eric S. Raymond -- one of the key figures in the open source / free software world -- talking about why the GPL might have outlived its usefulness. You heard right.
More Software Insights
White Papers
- Red Alert: Why Tablet Security Matters - by BlackBerry
- New Visual and Wizard-Driven Paradigms for Exploring Data and Developing Analytic Workflows
Reports
More >>Webcasts
- Maximize ROI with Database Consolidation onto Private Clouds
- Outsourcing Security: What Every Potential Cloud Security Customer Should Know
The Long Island Linux Users Group (LILUG) recently invited Raymond to speak there, wherein he delivered a talk that embodied two premises. Premise one:
What is the point of being famous and respected if you can't speak heresy about your own movement. What is the point?
In other words, dissent and skepticism about the very substance of what you're doing is vital. Especially now that the open source software movement has given rise to the business of open source software, where the development methodology went from being something done for idealistic reasons to something done for eminently practical and sensible ones. Not changing your line of thinking to match that seems foolish. But if there's one thing I've learned about anything labeled a "movement", it's that they seem particularly resistant to, well, moving -- especially when they have to do the moving.
Premise two:
... if the market punished people for taking open source closed, then why do our licenses need to punish people for taking open source closed? That is why I don't think you really need GPL or a reciprocal licenses anymore. It is attempting to prevent the behavior that the market punishes anyway.
Eric's premise is pretty sound on the face of it: in a world where open source programming is growing by leaps and bounds (sounds like the start of a movie trailer, doesn't it? "In a world where..."), proprietary software creators are getting the short end of the stick. Therefore, why make things difficult for ourselves as well?
What tipped me off, I confess, were the words "behavior the market punishes anyway". After the last year or so, I have little faith in the power of markets to punish, reward or "correct" themselves with Adam Smith-ian detachment. This includes marketplaces that aren't financial, too -- in fact, the situation may be worse in such cases, because there's that much less incentive to create any kind of oversight.
But does that mean the whole idea of ditching the GPL (or any other particular license) is unsound? No -- for all we know, someone else may come up with another arrangement that's even better, or develop an argument that no one else has foreseen. Just because Eric may not be on the mark here doesn't mean that his dissent has no value. In fact, it may be one of the most valuable things he has to give the open source community -- apart from lots of lines of code.
InformationWeek Analytics has published an independent analysis what IT and corporate professionals are looking for in business optimization. Download the report here (registration required).
Follow me and the rest of InformationWeek on Twitter.
Related Reading
| To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy. | |
|
|
T-Shirt Giveaway: Each week we're selecting one great comment from our readers. The author of the comment will receive an InformaitonWeek Community t-shirt. So get posting! |
Subscribe to RSSResource Links
This Week's Issue
Technology Whitepapers
- Mobile BI: Actionable Intelligence for the Agile Enterprise
- Creating the Enterprise-Class Tablet Environment - by Yankee Group
- How To Regain IT Control In An Increasingly Mobile World - by BlackBerry
- The BlackBerry PlayBook tablet's Good Bones - by BlackBerry
- Red Alert: Why Tablet Security Matters - by BlackBerry
Featured Broadcast
This white paper explains how to create a manageable, scalable environment suited to answer real-time business needs by building out a data center on a standards-based, virtualization-aware, energy-efficient and affordable platform. Plus, learn how virtualization is making the jump from the server realm into the application, mobile and database worlds in the additional resources section.
Learn More












