Topics:
Wolfe's Den
Paging AIM: Why Does Software Always Get Worse?
As my three regular readers know, poorly designed software is one of my pet peeves. (See my post, More Than Coding Mistakes At Fault In Bad Software.) Today's two examples are inducted into my personal software hall of shame based on that fact that any below-the-surface bug fixes they accomplish are buried beneath an observably poorer user experience. With the AOL Instant Messenger update, the issue is admittedly minor, but reoccurs so often -- because that's how you use AIM -- that it's an annoying repeat offender. Personally, I didn't want to upgrade my version of AIM at all -- I was perfectly happy with 6.8.12.3, or was it 6.7.7.4? -- but the persistent "Active Update" box yipping its flashing blue message on the lower right-hand corner of my screen finally wore me down. So here's the nuisance: It's the box which often pops up when you're trying to close your IM window. The box reads "You have new or unread IMs." Unfortunately, it appears not only on those rare occasions when you actually have unread AIMs, but frequently when you have "new" AIMs that you have in fact read. It's just that you haven't performed a hard mouse click inside the IM window, which I supposed is what indicates to the program that you've "read" the IM. In the real world, you have in fact "seen" the IM, but you just didn't click that you've seen it. I could see where such a warning would, by design, pop up. Except that, in the previous version of AIM, it didn't in the identical case. Which makes me wonder whether the previous version's more user-friendly behavior was accidental, rather than by design. Hey, if I wanted this type of annoyance, I'd enable my User Account Controls on Windows Vista.
OK, on to my second example, which is the upgraded Electronic Programming Guide (aka TV listings) on Time Warner Cable. This one is so mind-boggling annoying in minor yet user-experience-affronting ways that I don't know where to begin. (It's almost like it was designed by the Post Office.) In the previous guide, the guide would only go off to reload program data -- during which time the TV program in the upper-right-hand picture-in-picture windows goes blank -- on rare occasions, such as when you scrolled 24 hours ahead. Now, it goes blank with every fourth or fifth click. Which says to me that the new software has a lot of calls in there telling it to suck down data, including times when the data is probably already on hand. As well, you can't scroll through the guide's channels list while a volume change is waiting to settle. (The volume bars take several seconds to go away; more seconds than the actual volume change, btw.) I don't even mind that the second-level screen, where you used to be able to find programs by category -- used only for "sports"; does anyone search "drama"? -- has been revamped to the point where it's unusable. I simply want my normal, couch-potato remote-control experience back. A decade ago, I'd have shaken my head at such amateurism. These days, I'm no longer surprised. I take it as a given that methodological software design is a skill that is rapidly being driven to extinction by today's time to market pressures. Though not as quickly as is common sense.
« Sell 'Good,' Not 'Open' | Main | IBM Adding 1,300 Iowa Jobs, But At What Cost? » |
Twitter: (
RSS feed: (
My videos on (
| Sign Up Now For InformationWeek News Alerts |
This is a public forum. United Business Media and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not control what is posted herein. United Business Media makes no warranties or guarantees concerning any advice dispensed by its staff members or readers.
Community standards in this comment area do not permit hate language, excessive profanity, or other patently offensive language. Please be aware that all information posted to this comment area becomes the property of United Business Media LLC and may be edited and republished in print or electronic format as outlined in United Business Media's Terms of Service.
Important Note: This comment area is NOT intended for commercial messages or solicitations of business.
