Mobile // Mobile Applications
11:23 AM

Patent Trolls Pursue Midsize Companies

Non-practicing entities, also known as patent trolls, find midsize companies make ideal targets for infringement claims. Online retailer is fighting back.

Barnes said that some patents are too broad or otherwise lack merit. "The courts hold patents invalid regularly," he said. "I definitely agree that some patents [are] issued that shouldn't [be]."

While the threat of litigation is an ordinary NPE strategy, the conventional wisdom says that NPEs want to avoid the courtroom. "The troll is usually seeking to avoid litigation costs as that reduces its return on investment," attorney Olender said. "Thus, they seek a quick resolution and payment." That has been Zelman's experience at Ashford, too: "Their game is to get in and get out," he said.

In 2012, though, Cronos Technologies sued the likes of J. Crew, Abercrombie & Fitch, Nutrisystem and GNC -- in all four cases claiming infringement of the '110 patent. Barnes said lawsuits are often the only effective method of patent enforcement. Polite letters, like the aforementioned one Barnes sent on behalf of Cronos Technologies, usually go unanswered. "They'll just ignore you," he said, adding that some businesses receive dozens of such letters every month. "The only way you can get their attention is to sue them." One Capital Legal Group client, for example, has around eight different patent-related lawsuits pending, according to Barnes. (Capital Legal Group is not a litigation firm. It hires other law firms to handle litigation work on behalf of its clients.) While Barnes said more patent holders are now securing licensing deals without litigation, that usually doesn't occur until they've shown a willingness to go to court. "Until you have a credible threat of litigation -- such as a having a big name like an IBM or a Microsoft, or until you have already sued somebody -- people won't take you seriously," Barnes said.

Barnes also pointed out that some large companies use NPEs, also called non-operating companies or non-operating units, to manage patents as well. "Some of the big companies will decide that they don't want to be party to a suit, so they'll assign their patents to a newly formed LLC and use that LLC to monetize those patents," he said.

Finding potential patent infringers is a matter of putting in the hours, according to Barnes.

"It's just brute force. We look at companies that have similar patents to the one that we're looking at for infringement or have products in that industry, and we just have to hardcore do the analysis to see whether they infringe or not," Barnes said. "There's no shortcut. It's just tedious, time-consuming effort to look at products that might infringe and conclude one way or the other."

Zelman, Ashford's CFO, declined to state how much patent-infringement claims have cost his bottom line. Ultimately, he thinks of them as "a nuisance." Zelman doesn't expect NPEs to stop pursuing claims against businesses like Ashford any time soon, though he's reasonably optimistic about his and his peers' chances for better defending against them. Among other reasons why, Zelman thinks companies will begin to put more pressure on their software vendors and other technology suppliers for legal support in the event of patent-infringement claims, something he said has been assumed in the past but rarely actually exists.

"Executives -- people who are responsible for making decisions of acquiring, purchasing, licensing -- I think as we become more sophisticated in documenting what it is that we're agreeing to license and the fees in these documents, we're getting smarter," Zelman said. "People are starting to realize that there's a requirement that we need to build in some kind of defense mechanism."

In the bigger picture, Zelman also expects more companies like Ashford -- successful, but far from household names -- will simply decide to no longer support the NPE business model.

"There are more and more folks that are taking a stand," Zelman said. "It's going to be a little more painful, but we're going to take the stand and we're going to fight. We're going to push and continue to push and potentially expose fraudulent litigation, because most of the time this is what it is."

3 of 3
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Drew Conry-Murray
Drew Conry-Murray,
User Rank: Ninja
2/6/2013 | 12:26:59 AM
re: Patent Trolls Pursue Midsize Companies
It's unfortunate that patent trolling has been going on for years. It's clearly a misuse of the patent system and does nothing to foster innovation. I can understand a company's reluctance to fight, but I hope they do fight, and win. And I hope the U.S. can get some legitimate patent reform, both to quash trolls and to ensure that only really novel ideas get a patent.

Drew Conry-Murray
Editor, Network Computing
Michael Endler
Michael Endler,
User Rank: Author
2/5/2013 | 11:00:02 PM
re: Patent Trolls Pursue Midsize Companies
So dispiriting: it's usually better business to pay off a troll than to fight one. Dealing with this stuff has to feel like living in a neighborhood where everyone's forced to pay off the local mob. Such a baffling loophole in the system, and such an impediment to innovation.

Michael Endler, InformationWeek Associate Editor
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Among 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps – and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Top IT Trends to Watch in Financial Services
IT pros at banks, investment houses, insurance companies, and other financial services organizations are focused on a range of issues, from peer-to-peer lending to cybersecurity to performance, agility, and compliance. It all matters.
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Archived InformationWeek Radio
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on for the week of July 17, 2016. We'll be talking with the editors and correspondents who brought you the top stories of the week to get the "story behind the story."
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.