Put Your Test Lab In The Cloud - InformationWeek
Cloud // Software as a Service
04:50 PM
Connect Directly
How To Turn Your Data Into Dollars
Mar 29, 2017
Organizations are swamped with data in the form of web traffic, ERP systems, CRM systems, point of ...Read More>>

Put Your Test Lab In The Cloud

Your options for having a software development lab in the cloud are increasing. Here’s how to get your dev lab there.

Go Public

But if you want to get started quickly, the public cloud is your best option. Scale and automation are what have made public cloud service providers successful. These providers tap into a massive user community, unmatched in even the largest enterprise environments. They've invested millions of dollars automating data center processes--everything from service requests to provisioning to alert detection. It's relatively easy to take advantage of public cloud infrastructure services and host your development and testing tools inside these environments.

While the public cloud offers fast startup with no capital investment, the TCO over time may be higher compared with on-premises and private cloud lab environments. Fees from your cloud lab service provider can be difficult to monitor and control, and, as mentioned earlier, end-of-the-month surprises are a constant concern.

Software tools can help companies manage public cloud lab costs, but they can be expensive and don't make sense unless you're spending several thousands of dollars a month in lab fees. Uptime Software's UptimeCloud, for example, is an online service that monitors Amazon virtual server use, calculates existing charges, and projects them well before the end of the month. You can build in limits so that going over budget triggers an alert.

Portability also is a huge concern in the public cloud, particularly for a development lab. Vendors have a certain degree of lock-in with their SaaS applications in the public cloud lab, making it difficult to transfer workflows if you have to change providers. If you're tracking bugs and other issues, you may not be able to easily export and import that tracking into another system.

In addition, some public cloud providers charge for data coming into and out of their cloud offerings, and those costs can add up. When planning to move your lab into a public cloud environment, consider the total amount of data you'll be moving in and, more important, how much data you'll have to deal with if you ever want to get it out of the cloud relationship.If you're putting a lot of data into a cloud lab or are using valuable code there, you'll need a portability strategy.

Security is another big concern. Without formal processes to deal with data security, applications may be abandoned on virtual machines and live perpetually in a public cloud. This approach isn't wise, especially if you're dealing with sensitive, business-critical applications or data. You'll need to inventory the applications and data that must reside in a public cloud and ensure that your security team is OK with the approach.

Key Benefits
Of A Cloud Lab
Provides development and test templates compliant with IT policy
Centrally creates users, roles, access control lists, and permissions
Tracks usage by month, user, and project; can implement chargebacks if needed
Shifts lab from capital to operating expense
Avoids technology refresh expenses altogether (public cloud only)
Establishes hybrid cloud architecture to connect to in-house data centers
Assigns individual-, project-, and group-level quotas for machines, storage, and networks
Audits and ensures that compliance policies are followed

Stay Private

Cost control is easier in a private cloud lab. Your data and apps will be more secure there as well. A private cloud also centralizes shared resources for large environments. But the only way to achieve cost savings in a private cloud lab is to have large-scale adoption. You'll have to get most of your organization using your private cloud lab, and for that to happen, you'll need it to be automated, which is the key to any successful cloud lab deployment, especially if cost reduction is a priority.

Besides automation, you'll need other key technology elements, such as bug tracking, collaboration, and asset management (see chart below). As with any private cloud environment, you'll have to decide how far you want to take your lab. Are you just after platform service and infrastructure service capabilities, or do you want to offer software configuration management (SCM) and bug tracking as hosted solutions? How much control do you want users to have over provisioning resources? Once they're provisioned, how much management and monitoring of these resources will be required? Do you need chargeback or usage-based reporting? How quickly do you need to tear down and rebuild environments? Can you replicate the amount of data and traffic needed in the lab?

A private cloud lab may be costly and complex, but it has advantages over public cloud options. It gives you the flexibility to replicate your production environment, which may be necessary to test some applications.

Unfortunately, many tools designed for software development and testing, including SCM tools, aren't readily portable to a private cloud. This can be a problem, as having a full suite of development applications and the control mechanisms to manage them is key to getting value from a private cloud lab.

If you find you must mirror your production environment in the cloud, you'll need a multitier application with clustering and failover support--and that's expensive in the public cloud, especially for large environments. You might need multiple networks in various configurations, and you might need to add multiple network adapters to each virtual machine, connect them to different networks, configure routing policies, and ensure that you're getting an accurate depiction of the production environment. One tool that can help is centralized configuration management automation software, which works across different applications, networks, and servers.

Setting up a lab in a private cloud also lets you control security, as well as the code and other data in the lab, making it the best option for sensitive data and applications. Private clouds also keep you in control of high-risk functions such as disaster recovery and operational continuity.

The cost to scale also will dictate whether you locate your lab in the public or private cloud. But there's no fast and easy formula for figuring that out. The decision depends on your specific needs. Online gaming software developer Zynga found it could do the same amount of work in its private cloud as it had been doing on AWS but with one-third the number of servers. AWS's general-purpose servers are designed to run a wide variety of workloads and don't do one job supremely well. Zynga optimized its servers for specific roles--database access, Web server, and game logic execution--and ended up using fewer of them. Like Zynga, you'll want to do a TCO analysis, comparing public cloud services with a build-it-yourself private cloud.

diagram: Elements of a private cloud lab

2 of 3
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
4/9/2012 | 8:21:57 PM
re: Put Your Test Lab In The Cloud
I recently attended a CIO conference and had many discussions on this topic.

For those hosting their own infrastructure, there are some big technology advantages still not available on the cloud.
An example is a company like Kubisys who can mimic production environments (sets of servers) in minutes and use them for test labs.

You can even create labs for each developer on the fly with all your prod data, the current application configuration, with no IT infrastructure knowledge in minutes.

Pretty cool.

The solutions now seem to be able only to deploy standalone machines with minimal OS configurations.

User Rank: Apprentice
4/5/2012 | 8:40:45 AM
re: Put Your Test Lab In The Cloud
Very thorough article. Some great points on the benefits of hosting test environments in the cloud, weighed up against several potential pitfalls. We built and use a tool called CloudFlex to manage and provision our cloud environments in our testing and development projects, and have since made the tool available to the public as a "Test and Development Environments as a Service" offering; it's really simple to use, even for those less familiar with using cloud applications, and has built-in scheduling options to automatically shut down environments at the end of the working day (or whenever we need them to stop). You can actually see exactly what you're using from the dashboard view, so it simplifies managing the costs of your resources.

If the concept of "test labs in the cloud" interests you, I think a great way to build a business case would be to do a trial of CloudFlex (it's free for 30 days). http://www.cloudflex.co.uk
User Rank: Apprentice
4/4/2012 | 3:34:54 PM
re: Put Your Test Lab In The Cloud
Excellent article, Michael. In fact, I'd recommend it to some of our clients/partners, who are making these very decisions right now. You didn't touch on compliance requirements; for some, that may also be a factor in the decision-making process. - Laurie Head, VP, AIS Network Cloud Hosting, http://ww.aisn.net
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
To learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
IT Success = Storage & Data Center Performance
Balancing legacy infrastructure with emerging technologies requires laying a solid foundation that delivers flexibility, scalability, and efficiency. Learn what the most pressing issues are, how to incorporate advances like software-defined storage, and strategies for streamlining the data center.
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Archived InformationWeek Radio
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on InformationWeek.com for the week of November 6, 2016. We'll be talking with the InformationWeek.com editors and correspondents who brought you the top stories of the week to get the "story behind the story."
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll