Government // Mobile & Wireless
Commentary
1/19/2012
04:16 PM
Eric Zeman
Eric Zeman
Commentary
Connect Directly
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

$500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?

Apple says it wants to put textbooks on a pricey tablet to deliver a richer learning experience. But critics say the device cost is what's rich.

Apple on Thursday revealed its razor-sharp focus on the education market with the launch of iBooks 2 with Textbooks, iBooks Author, and iTunes U. It believes these three tools, working together, can provide both educators and students with a richer learning experience. iBooks 2 is a revised version of its e-book application and now supports full text books, with immersive graphics, images, videos, and so on. iBooks Author can be used by anyone to create iBooks. iTunes U can be used by college students and professors to access college-level material and course work.

We're a long way from seeing whether this new direction for Apple is successful. That didn't stop the Web from reacting strongly to the news, with plenty of tech pundits on Twitter fired up about how Apple will affect the education system.

The biggest item that ruffled feathers is the cost of the iPad itself. At a starting price of $499, it's not cheap. Although it won't be too difficult for upper- and middle-class families to afford it, there are plenty of American families that cannot. Where does that leave the children of those families in the classroom? Apple didn't announce plans to bring the iPad to schools or school children at a reduced price.

[ A few of our favorite pre-classroom iPad apps: 10 Hot iPad Apps For Summer. ]

The Verge's Chris Ziegler was particularly peeved:

"I don't think this has any practical implication on public education whatsoever," said Ziegler. "The system is broken. First things first. Books get dropped, abused, handed from student to student and from older sibling to younger sibling. iPads? Not so much. Show me a program for getting iPads into schools en masse, Apple. THAT'S the wow factor in education, not an animated book."

Ziegler got into a conversation with Philip Berne (a former teacher and--*disclaimer*--friend and former colleague of mine), who works for Apple competitor Samsung.

"Sure I work for a competitor," said Berne, "but I had high hopes that Apple might introduce a useful, open standard, not an ecosystem grab. It's one thing to grab for media, apps, accessories, etc. But when you mess with education, makes me furious. So, middle class kids with highly-educated parents who have no trouble getting into college will now be able to study better. Hoorah. How about making textbooks an open Web standard, so kids who can't afford iPads can use them? You know, the ones who actually need them?"

Gartner analyst Michael Gartenberg disagrees with the positions taken by Ziegler and Berne, however.

"Think about the total cost of education for primary, secondary and university, the cost of a media tablet is negligible," wrote Gartenberg on Twitter. The "value of the app is directly proportional to students having iPads. But this will lead to more schools adopting as a requirement. Lots of interesting pilots and experiments will come out of today's news. Others will build on what Apple has done today. Today's news was the foundation for what feels like a major push for education from Apple. I'd expect more followups."

My mother was a public educator for over 20 years. When she retired last year, my siblings and I chipped in and bought her an iPad as a gift. In the months she's been using the iPad, she's decided it would have been an excellent tool for her classroom. Personally, I think Apple's ideas here have a lot of transformational potential in the education market, though there are still practical issues to iron out.

What are your thoughts on this? Beyond the logistics of the applications themselves and their impact in and out of the classroom, do you like or loath the idea of a tablet as a learning tool? Can schools and, more importantly, teachers get from it what they need to push students, to encourage learning, and to be more effective in the classroom?

Or is it all just a skeevy way for Apple to sell $499 devices--which will end up becoming distractions in the classroom--to as many people as possible?

Meet top cloud computing technology companies in Cloud Connect's ever-growing Expo Hall, and learn about the latest cloud services, applications, and platforms. It happens in Santa Clara, Calif., Feb. 13-16. Sign up now with Priority Code CPMWCC18 for a free Expo Pass or $100 off our conference passes.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
<<   <   Page 2 / 3   >   >>
jfutral303
50%
50%
jfutral303,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 1:56:27 PM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
I think Berne is wrong. From what I've read elsewhere the digital textbooks are just zipped XHTML pages. Plus there is an export function in the authoring tool to export to some other format. I haven't dug deep enough to say I know for a fact, but that is the buzz I've been hearing.

Joe
burgee
50%
50%
burgee,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 5:14:31 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Reply to Konqueror:
Valid point---"The history of a culture is its written word." Literally interpreted is the reason why my students are also required to do half their work in cursive with pen and paper. (Grades 7 & 8)
burgee
50%
50%
burgee,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 1:55:53 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Our elementary school has purchased a lab of iPads which are currently in use. As a high school eacher, I have had a few students access books for my English classes. Some of the books may be obtained at no cost, others cost to download. However, many public libraries now offer books which may be downloaed at no cost for a certain loan period-- just like checking out a paper book. Our school policy is that the iPads do not leave the labs or a teacher's room.

It seems to me that textbook companies must offer textbooks for iPads. The problem this presents is that, of course, schools must, in turn, purchase an iPad for each student; IPads which may be taken home to complete homework assignments. In a school district that does not have the funds to provide a lap top for each student, I do not see this happening. Surely in the long run, wouldn't the iPads save money over the cost of the textbook budget over a ten year span- a fifteen year span? Who has studied this? How long can an IPad be estimated to last in the hands of students?.

I've been looking for something for my grandchildren, and since I was recently told that public liblaries are on board, I THINK I'm going to buy them iPads, unless something better comes along next week . . .or next month . . .

ANON1237825497586
50%
50%
ANON1237825497586,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 12:49:46 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
True, but you will not get the rich features that Apple is proposing with "any" Kindle. With having a Kindle in my household and an iPad, the iPad is the way to go. Kindle is way to limited.
ANON1237825497586
50%
50%
ANON1237825497586,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 12:48:17 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
I don't see why not, some text books cost that much :\
Bob E
50%
50%
Bob E,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 12:10:39 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Since the days long ago that I set my first TeX document (just google it), I have wondered why it wasn't possible to provide people with interest in a topic the best info we can give them. Sorry neophyte, but you don't have access to a college library or even a real public library. Anything that improves this, even if for commercial gain makes our world better. There are so many bright minds out there.
Kongqueror
50%
50%
Kongqueror,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/20/2012 | 12:03:43 AM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Although I believe this as a positive approach to learning, I am alarmed by the tablet's, specifically the iPad, emphasis on touch-typing vs. hand-written notes. I feel that the art/skill/personality of handwriting may be lost with our push towards displacing analog media with digital. In the end, we are analog beings in an analog world.
Bob E
50%
50%
Bob E,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/19/2012 | 11:44:27 PM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Can this work? Will publishers change their business models or just offer non-core fluff. For the college crowd, can you get Thomas calculus or whatever? A few $150+ textbooks, throw in a few Verlag titles at a 75% discount over paper..could be sweet.
Mazzy
50%
50%
Mazzy,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/19/2012 | 11:33:04 PM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
Well first of all an iPad will probably be around $300. for the entry level very soon. Secondly for now, this is for college where most students are already paying $1000 or more for textbooks so there will be a bigger savings down the line. Also some students get subsidies as needed, I am sure this will happen in the digital world too. One friggen text book can cost over $100 now.
Tagent
50%
50%
Tagent,
User Rank: Apprentice
1/19/2012 | 11:17:20 PM
re: $500 iPads In The Classroom: Good Idea?
I think that everyone is missing the real value here.

Think of how much schools will save if all students have an Ipad?

No more need for schoolbooks!!! Massive, massive savings for the schools! Apple already has Ipad education discounts, combine that with schools subsidizing the Ipads because of the lower costs, and you have an incredible way to teach kids how to safely use the technology that they will use for the rest of their lives!
<<   <   Page 2 / 3   >   >>
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Tech Digest September 24, 2014
Start improving branch office support by tapping public and private cloud resources to boost performance, increase worker productivity, and cut costs.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.