Government // Enterprise Architecture
News
7/30/2014
11:45 AM
Connect Directly
LinkedIn
Google+
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
100%
0%

Passport Database Outage: 'We Regret The Inconvenience'

US State Department database used to process passports and visas still hasn't recovered from a crash last week -- leaving tens of thousands of people stranded overseas.

 Government Data + Maps: 10 Great Examples
Government Data + Maps: 10 Great Examples
(Click image for larger view and slideshow.)

Job interviews missed, work and wedding plans disrupted, children unable to fly home with their adoptive parents -- the consequences keep proliferating in the aftermath of a database outage that crippled the US State Department's process for issuing passports, visas, and other documents related to travel to the US.

As first reported last week, the Consolidated Consular Database (CCD) used by staff around the world to process applications for travel to the US has been experiencing severe performance problems, including outages, since Saturday, July 19. The performance of the system is apparently still impaired, making it difficult for consular staff to whittle down the backlog.

The State Department has published few updates since it originally acknowledged the issue -- except on its Facebook page.

[Ready for anything? Read Cyber Attacks Happen: Build Resilient Systems.]

The most recent post there, as of this writing, states:

The Department of State Bureau of Consular Affairs continues to make progress restoring our nonimmigrant visa system to full functionality. Over the weekend, the Department of State implemented system changes aimed at optimizing performance and addressing the challenges we have faced. We are now testing our system capacity to ensure stability. Processing of immigrant visas cases, including adoptions, remains a high priority. Some Embassies and Consulates may temporarily limit or reschedule nonimmigrant visa interview appointments until more system resources become available to process these new applications. We sincerely regret the inconvenience to travelers, and are committed to resolving the problem as soon as possible.

(Image: Consular Affairs Facebook page)
(Image: Consular Affairs Facebook page)

State Department staffers also made an effort to respond to the queries of frustrated travelers trying to understand whether the system was up or down ("We are still working to restore our systems to full functionality, so while the systems are working, they are not operating at full capacity") and why it was not possible to implement some manual workaround in the absence of a functioning computer system ("We cannot 'handwrite' visas because security measures prevent consular officers from printing a visa unless it is approved through our database system. Until the system is brought back to full capacity and we are able to work through the backlog, service to our customers will be below normal.")

A statement emailed to InformationWeek reiterated these points, adding that the system was not hacked but "crashed shortly after maintence was performed. We believe the root cause of the problem was a combination of software optimization and hardware compatibility issues." The statement also reiterates that the State Department expects the system to be fully operational again "soon."

How soon is soon? "That will depend on how quickly we can bring additional resources to bear on the backlog," according to the statement. "We are increasing system capacity and efficiency, and are looking for opportunities to reduce the backlog through administrative actions."

The technical crisis didn't turn into a public relations crisis right away because this is not a web application, directly accessible to the public, but an application used by consular staff. However, because it interrupted their ability to get work done, the effects soon showed up in canceled appointments for visa interviews and paperwork that couldn't be produced when expected.

Described as "one of the largest Oracle-based data warehouses in the world" in a 2010 privacy impact assessment, the CCD at that time tracked more than 100 million visa cases and 75 million photographs, utilizing billions of rows of data, and was growing at 35,000 visa cases a day. The data warehouse works with a series of data marts, so that not every query has to go back to the central repository, but still the scale is intimidating. The system also features interfaces to other immigration and Homeland Security systems, such as the terrorist watchlist.

ScaleArc CTO and Founder Varun Singh ventured a guess -- just based on how long it is taking for the agency to recover -- that the database was corrupted perhaps by having its operations interrupted "in the middle of a major operation" such as a schema change. Something as simple as adding a column to a table, if not completed on the entire table, could leave all the data in that table scrambled.

"If you don't shut the database down right, and bring it up right, you're going to have a problem with database consistency," Singh told us.

A scalability issue, like the system crashing because it is unable to handle the volume of queries being directed at it, is less likely as the origin of the crisis -- but could be an aggravating factor now that the visa processing workload is backed up and personnel are trying to catch up, he said. Enterprise systems are less subject to database overload than public web applications, which can be overwhelmed by a rush of visitors. However, it's not unheard of: One mortgage industry customer that Singh's firm assisted with better caching of data was suffering regular system failures at the time of the month when mortgages or refinancings tended to close or following events like an interest rate change.

Enterprise systems, whether in government or industry, are rarely tested for the full range of failure and overload they could encounter and often don't boast the level of system redundancy required to restore operations quickly.

Whatever the cause, the failure had wide-ranging impacts, affecting tens of thousands of people. In many cases, there seemed to be little doubt of the traveler's right to enter or reenter the US, except that consular officials were unable to complete the final paperwork requirements and print the necessary documents.

A Colorado couple traveling in China to adopt a child told Denver's CBS 4 TV station of being unable to return home because of the logjam. Having left the US on July 9, they were unsure when they would be able to get home in the absence of a visa for their adoptive son. Travelers' forums are full of stories about people who are on the verge of missing a job interview -- or already missing more work than they had planned -- because of their inability to book travel to the US.

Another person caught by surprise was Matt Kingham, director of sales for InformationWeek Financial Services, who had expected a routine renewal of his visa would allow him to return to the US after a trip home to the UK. As an employee of our parent company, London-based UBM, he is covered by a type of visa that allows multinational companies to transfer employees between offices. He normally works out of New York City. After attending a music festival, during which time he paid little attention to news or email, he found his visa renewal interview had been canceled and had to cancel a scheduled Tuesday flight to the US. "They tell you to never book travel until you have your passport and visa in hand," he says, but for a business traveler that's not always practical.

While Kingham can do most of his work just as well from the UK, he has been as frustrated as anyone with the lack of answers about how long the delay will last. Unable to find a phone number to call, he got only a generic form letter response on email and has been relying on Facebook and travelers' forums for most of his news.

"We have no idea whether we're in line behind 10 people or 10,000 people," agrees Caitlin Crum. A native Floridian who has been living in Australia for the past two years, she is back in Naples but now separated from her husband, whom she met and married there. They had traveled together from Western Australia to Sydney, an eight-hour flight, for their visa interview, and he was supposed to follow 12 days later to start a new job in the US. "He's going to be missing his flight Saturday, which means we're out like $2,000," she says.

They had been working through the frustrating paperwork process since their January wedding, but now everything seemed to be in order. "His visa was approved, his Green Card was approved -- but they're holding his passport hostage."

IT leaders who don’t embrace public cloud concepts will find their business partners looking elsewhere for computing capabilities. Get the new Frictionless IT issue of InformationWeek Tech Digest today.

David F. Carr oversees InformationWeek's coverage of government and healthcare IT. He previously led coverage of social business and education technologies and continues to contribute in those areas. He is the editor of Social Collaboration for Dummies (Wiley, Oct. 2013) and ... View Full Bio

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
tekedge
50%
50%
tekedge,
User Rank: Moderator
7/31/2014 | 10:24:07 PM
Re: The cloud cures all solution
Yeah I agree strike when the iron is hot
tekedge
50%
50%
tekedge,
User Rank: Moderator
7/31/2014 | 10:20:06 PM
Passport Database Outage
Surprising there was no back up plan.
anon9899091174
50%
50%
anon9899091174,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/31/2014 | 2:50:33 PM
Re: Another day, another glitch
Yes, wife's situation is directly a result of the database crash.  The ironic thing is that it is not about the paperwork, we submitted the extensive paperwork to the U.S. embassy, which included documentation like her Japan passport and a photocopy of the lost green card, and human beings at the embassy reviewed her paperwork, interviewed her, and agreed she was who she identified herself as, and indeed a U.S. resident (i.e. not a terrorist).  So they approved her for the transportation letter.

But the computer must do some mandatory security check, before a simple letter can be printed.  But my wife has already been vetted and approved by actual human Americans with brains.

I'm not sure why some comments are politicizing this, I'm sure these systems were in place before the current administration.  This is more about IT and automation and having logical backup procedures.  The hundreds of thousands of non-Americans visiting, they're waiting at home and they can  be inconvenienced.  The few hundred U.S. citizens and residents stranded abroad, it doesn't take much manual procedures to vet them and let them come home, all of them have been vetted at embassies, as opposed to making them struggle day-by-day to procure lodging, cash, basic communications while in a foreign country.

Funnily, any other Japan passport-holder can enter the U.S. just fine, without a visa.  But my wife who is a Japan passport-holder who actually lives in the U.S. cannot.  And weirdly the airlines actually check your passport AND green-card when you LEAVE the U.S., it's not like the same airline that denies you boarding to return hasn't already verified your docs just a few days earlier.
TerryB
50%
50%
TerryB,
User Rank: Ninja
7/31/2014 | 1:44:11 PM
Re: Watchlist
Having been thru something very similar to this, I definitely do not agree with you. About 10 years ago, after they started the watchlist system, I was returning to Chicago airport from Finland business trip. Got off plane, had 3 hours before my connecting flight. All I had to do was go thru customs and then wait.

Right when I got to the front of line, their system that checks watchlist failed at the NATIONAL level. Being IT, I wasn't initially concerned because everyone has some redundancy and backup processes in place, right? Not so fast. After standing in line for 3 hours, with now 1000 people in line behind me, I started getting irritated and asked them what backup plan they had in place in case system was not coming up. There was NONE, as far as they were concerned we could stand there with no food or water forever. To go to bathroom you lost your place in line. Since I had missed my flight already and had only 3 hours of sleep in last 24 hours, I left my place in line to get water and use bathroom, this was about 9pm at night. I laid down on bench in customs terminal and closed my eyes to rest. I woke up at 11pm to an empty terminal, sometime between 9-11 the system came up. So luckily I got a 1 way rental car and drove to Green Bay, arriving home at 2:30am, with no luggage of course. How I stayed awake during that drive I still don't know.

Now here is the good part: The system that crashed only dealt with domestic passengers, not people from other countries with Visa's. This really nice lady from Denmark I sat next to on plane went right thru customs with no issues, only people from USA were stuck.

Now don't tell me you needed the system for security purposes. I had my drivers license, my intinery showed I left a week ago for Finland and was returning home. A mental midget could figure out I was not a terrorist, along with everyone else in line. The government was just too damn incompetent to have ANY plan in place in case that system was offline. Were all these people supposed to starve to death (there is no food court in customs terminal where you get off) in the name of national security? The customs people sure didn't care. 
pdembry950
50%
50%
pdembry950,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/31/2014 | 1:17:23 PM
Easier way to get back
Fly to Mexico and just come across the border :-)
LESSGOV2014
100%
0%
LESSGOV2014,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/31/2014 | 1:00:29 PM
Re: Another day, another glitch
Billions spent annually with little or no IT project planning or testing until the USERS get it! Not a smidgen of waste, mismangement or incompetence here to look at!! Bet there are many more IT nightmares coming at other agencies too, and they want to control MORE aspects of our lives with Obamacare!
David F. Carr
50%
50%
David F. Carr,
User Rank: Author
7/31/2014 | 11:34:55 AM
Re: Another day, another glitch
Wow. Do attibute your wife's situation to the computer problem? Sounds like the paperwork issues can be tough to begin with.
wwu123
100%
0%
wwu123,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/30/2014 | 7:11:40 PM
Re: Another day, another glitch
My wife lost her green card while we were on vacation in Europe, and has not been able to return home for more than a week now.  Yes, we are just inconvenienced stranded travelers and can afford it, having already lost thousands with her purse contents and running around trying to replace travel documents.  However, my three-year-old will not have a mother for nearly a month, as now we expect it will be that long before my wife is finally able to come home to the U.S.
David F. Carr
50%
50%
David F. Carr,
User Rank: Author
7/30/2014 | 6:39:14 PM
Re: Lack of cloud understanding is the least of their problems
If not cloud per se, they should have had a backup system or replica, sure. Easy to say, not necessarily easy to fit into the budget.
Charlie Babcock
50%
50%
Charlie Babcock,
User Rank: Author
7/30/2014 | 6:17:05 PM
Lack of cloud understanding is the least of their problems
They should have had a disaster recovery system in the cloud, accessible by offices anywhere in the world. To explain that this application can't be easily moved to the cloud is a dodge, indicating they don't understand either recovery issues or cloud comuting very well. But that goes without saying, given the performance reliability we're witnessing here.
Page 1 / 2   >   >>
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Tech Digest - September 10, 2014
A high-scale relational database? NoSQL database? Hadoop? Event-processing technology? When it comes to big data, one size doesn't fit all. Here's how to decide.
Flash Poll
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.