Homeland Security Tries To Get Its Cybersecurity House In Order
Washington has so far fallen short of its goals for safeguarding the Internet, and if it's going to succeed, it will need more cooperation from private industry.
The idea of terrorists bringing down the Internet is as unfathomable today as the collapse of the Twin Towers was on Sept. 10, 2001. But the threat cyberattacks pose to the Net is real.
Government policy-makers, corporate leaders, and cyberwonks agree that it's ultimately the federal government's responsibility to coordinate protection of the Internet. But Washington has so far fallen short of its goals for safeguarding the Net, and if it's going to succeed, it will need more cooperation from private industry.
The Internet has come under attack before. In October 2002, a coordinated denial-of-service attack disrupted 13 domain-name root servers, making numerous Web sites unavailable. Early this year, a hacker brought down 1,500 Web sites by hijacking PCs and sending traffic to servers with a DNS query and forged source address. A larger-scale attack, one that effectively shuts down the Internet, is a genuine danger, experts say.
"It's not science fiction; it's not theoretical," says Larry Clinton, chief operating officer of the Internet Security Alliance, which works with CERT. "It's happening today, and in all likelihood will get worse."
Most eyes focus on the federal government, and particularly the Department of Homeland Security, to take the lead in developing the mechanisms to prevent large-scale attacks and a process for reconstituting the Net if a colossal disaster occurs. In fact, it's the law. The Homeland Security Act of 2002 and a presidential directive put the department in charge of orchestrating activities to support the IT systems that safeguard the nation's critical infrastructures. "Our job isn't necessarily to do it all, but to make sure we get all the players to the table and to make sure it all gets done," says George Foresman, the Department of Homeland Security's undersecretary for preparedness.
Expectations of Homeland Security have grown in recent weeks. The agency named Gregory Garcia as its first assistant secretary for cybersecurity and telecommunications, a post that had sat idle for 14 months.
Even without its top cybercop, Homeland Security has made strides in meeting its mandate but has yet to fully succeed. The Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, identified 13 key cybersecurity responsibilities for the department (see box for highlights), but none has been completely addressed, and some of the agency's efforts seem halfhearted. GAO, for instance, cited working groups Homeland Security established with industry to practice responding to cyberevents, but judged those efforts as lacking synergy with other initiatives. A report from the Business Roundtable, an association of corporate CEOs, says the nation lacks the sort of coordinated response needed to fix Internet infrastructure in the event of a massive disruption.
Business' Role Insofar as the government succeeds, business is going to play a big role. No single entity owns the Internet. Often, the companies that do own the Internet's infrastructure won't share information about their networks with the government. Some businesses gripe that the information the government wants is proprietary, and they believe that lax controls could result in that data being leaked to competitors. David Powner, GAO's director of IT management issues, says Homeland Security needs to better inform businesses about how sensitive information will be used and protected. "Right now, with the folks we talk to in the private sector, they don't see a lot of return from the Department of Homeland Security," Powner says. "There are real leadership issues there."
Foresman says his biggest challenge is getting cooperation from industry leaders, many of whom don't trust the government. But he says the department is taking steps to coordinate its efforts with the private sector. Homeland Security is working with the Business Roundtable to develop specific actions regarding Internet recovery and reconstitution, Foresman says. The Internet Disruption Working Group, which includes public- and private-sector members, was formed to augment information-sharing among various levels of government and business.
The Department of Homeland Security's cyberresponsibilities
Create a comprehensive national plan for critical infrastructure protection, including cybersecurity
Establish partnerships and coordinate with other federal agencies, state and local governments, and the private sector
Improve and enhance public and private information-sharing involving cyberattacks, threats, and vulnerabilities
Develop and enhance national cyberanalysis and warning capabilities
Provide and coordinate incident response and recovery-planning efforts
Data: Government Accountability Office
See You And Raise You The stakes of getting it right are high. Not only Americans have become highly dependent on the Internet, but the entire world. Since the beginning of the millennium, the number of Internet users has quadrupled to about 1 billion, according to Internet world usage statistics. And it's not just the number of users that's relevant but how they're using the Net for business and pleasure, employing Internet-enabled devices and apps such as VoIP, wireless PDAs, and text messaging. Consider your own business' dependence on the Net.
Internet users are more vulnerable to attacks than ever. According to the Internet Security Alliance, a quarter of America's economic value--$3 trillion a day--moves across network connections protected by a 30-year-old protocol that contains many known security flaws. American businesses already are taking a hit from online attacks. As recently as 2004, the economic impact of cyberattacks on business reached $226 billion, the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service reports. The SANS Institute claims that financial losses for banks from cyberattacks have soared 450% in the last year, and data-breach notifications reached record levels this summer.
An attack on the Net needn't be massive to be overwhelmingly disruptive. Imagine terrorists tampering with a minute portion of the Internet to corrupt key data, such as financial or medical records, so as to compromise the integrity of other sets of data. "It doesn't have to be all the data corrupted to lead to a loss of confidence of all information we look at on the Internet," says Paul Kurtz, executive director of the Cyber Security Industry Alliance.
Before the Garcia appointment, critics freely attacked the federal government for not giving cybersecurity its proper due. Now, with that position finally filled, we'll see how committed the government is to getting the job done.
5 Top Federal Initiatives For 2015As InformationWeek Government readers were busy firming up their fiscal year 2015 budgets, we asked them to rate more than 30 IT initiatives in terms of importance and current leadership focus. No surprise, among more than 30 options, security is No. 1. After that, things get less predictable.
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on InformationWeek.com for the week of December 14, 2014. Be here for the show and for the incredible Friday Afternoon Conversation that runs beside the program.