Computer scientists say that more than 60 sites certified as safe by McAfee's ScanAlert service have been vulnerable to cross-site scripting attacks.
In an e-mail, McRee countered that while that may be true, "this issue still indicates a shortcoming in the 'Hacker Safe' service." Pointing to ScanAlert's online explanation of its scanning procedure, which specifically identifies cross-site scripting among the flaws the service attempts to detect, he dismissed the company's "Hacker Safe" labeling as "a grandiose and inaccurate marketing claim."
"By [ScanAlert's] own claim, the Toastmasters site is scanned daily, yet this vulnerability has and continues to exist," said McRee. "This is really about ScanAlert accurately providing the service they claim to offer and aiding companies with online interests in following secure coding best practices."
The merits of the ScanAlert service came into question just over a week ago following the publication of a letter from the parent company of Geeks.com, a site also certified "Hacker Safe." The letter warned the site's customers of a data breach last December and said it was possible "that an unauthorized person may be in possession of your name, address, telephone number, e-mail address, credit card number, expiration date, and card verification number." In the letter, the company said it was still investigating the incident, "but it appears that an unauthorized individual may have accessed this information by hacking our eCommerce Web site."
ScanAlert spokesman Nigel Ravenhill subsequently asserted in an e-mail that "no one knows exactly what happened, or whether this breach occurred on the [Geeks.com] Web site or somewhere else." And he said, "There is no evidence that this Web site was hacked while it was certified 'Hacker Safe'."
To date, Genica, which runs Geeks.com, hasn't provided further details about last year's data breach. Peter Green, director of marketing at the company, said that the breach is still under investigation and that there is no further information beyond what has already been publicly disclosed. He said the company hopes to conclude its investigation in a week or two.
Someone posting under the name "kenleonard0" -- Ken Leonard is the name of the CEO of ScanAlert -- echoed Ravenhill's comments about the Geeks.com breach on the blog of Illinois-based IT consultant Rafal Los, who published an assessment of ScanAlert that's similar to McRee's. "There is no evidence that this Web site was hacked while it was certified 'Hacker Safe,' " the post says. "In fact, all of the information that ScanAlert has gathered so far indicates that this breach did not happen while Geeks.com was certified 'Hacker Safe.' "
Los contends that the issue isn't whether the Geeks.com site was breached while certified by ScanAlert. Rather, he sees the use of the label "Hacker Safe" as untenable given the realities of computer security. "I would argue that this service is obviously weak at best, and at worst puts a false sense of security into the minds of the unknowing end users who go to these sites," he said in a Jan. 8 blog post. "Making an outrageous claim like 'Hacker Safe' is akin to saying 'Yes, your system is secure' when we all know the only way that can happen is with all cables (network, power) cut and data destroyed with an atom-smasher."
Editor's Note: This story was modified Jan. 18 to clarify the extent to which sites were hackable while certified.
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security EnterpriseTo learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
IT Strategies to Conquer the CloudChances are your organization is adopting cloud computing in one way or another -- or in multiple ways. Understanding the skills you need and how cloud affects IT operations and networking will help you adapt.