The products tested ran the gamut, from free apps made by companies you've never heard of to pricey products from big-time security vendors. The only objective of the testing was to measure detection rates. Although detection might be the most important characteristic of an anti-malware product, it isn't the only one--so the report doesn't endorse or condemn any of the products tested.
Growth of Android malware threats identified by AV-Test since January 2011.
Malware finds a welcome mat in Android because of certain decisions Google made to ease the process of developing and distributing apps. The cost and qualifications for distributing apps through Google's Android Market are lower than those for Apple's App Store. Android also lets users allow software to be installed from other stores, whereas iOS users must "jailbreak" their phones to do so. Many of the third-party Android markets are not very picky about checking the apps they accept and often offer malware, but malware has been found in Google's market, too. As a result, Google has, in recent months, ratcheted up its automated scanning of submissions to the Market. The malware that AV-Test tested for included phishing and banking trojans, spyware, bots, root exploits, SMS fraud, premium dialers, and fake installers.
AV-Test doesn't provide exact detection rates--perhaps to discourage unjustified comparisons. Instead it split the products into five detection groups: >90%, >65%, >40%, >0% and 0%. Most of the products detected more than 40% but less than 65% of the malware threats. Six found none. Seven found more than 90%. They are:
avast! Mobile Security
Dr. Web anti-virus Light
F-Secure Mobile Security
IKARUS mobile Security LITE
Kaspersky Mobile Security (Lite)
Lookout Security & Antivirus
Zoner AntiVirus Free
The second-tier products might well be good choices, too--the failure to detect one type of malware might not matter in certain areas.
As for the packages that found nothing, it's not clear whether they weren't functioning properly or are just bad products. None detected the Eicar test file, which is a specific non-malicious file that all products are supposed to detect and thereby prove that they are running.
AV-Test made some trade-off decisions for the testing that one has to take into account when considering the test results. For instance, in order to make it possible to run a large number of tests, AV-Test chose to use the Android emulator that comes with Google's Android SDK, set for Gingerbread (Android 2.3, API level 10). The advantage of the emulator is that it lets testing scale much more easily than on a phone. On the other hand, because the emulator is not a phone--for instance, it doesn't have a phone number--it might cause malware to fail or behave differently. Some apps would not run it at all. For those apps, AV-Test used a Samsung Galaxy Tab running Android 2.2 (Froyo) and a Samsung Galaxy Nexus running Android 4.0 (Ice Cream Sandwich).
Another possible problem is that some Android malware still falls into a gray area that is not strictly defined as malware. If an app throws up annoying ads is it malware? Some products might not think so.
AV-Test did not consider the other features a product might have, such as backup or anti-theft protection.
You can make a case that by avoiding shady stores and using common sense, you can avoid Android malware without installing anti-malware software. However, AV-Test concludes that you should at least consider running one of them. There are attacks which could get past Google, at least for a while, and some of the products work well enough that some day you might be happy you took the trouble to install them.
Building A Mobile Business MindsetAmong 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps – and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
InformationWeek Must Reads Oct. 21, 2014InformationWeek's new Must Reads is a compendium of our best recent coverage of digital strategy. Learn why you should learn to embrace DevOps, how to avoid roadblocks for digital projects, what the five steps to API management are, and more.