Apple, Samsung Battle Over Damages In Patent Trial - InformationWeek
Mobile // Mobile Devices
02:26 AM
Connect Directly
[Cyberattacks] Using Data as Your First Line of Defense
Aug 10, 2017
Attend this webinar to learn how you can determine which threats pose the greatest danger to your ...Read More>>

Apple, Samsung Battle Over Damages In Patent Trial

Apple wants billions of dollars, but Samsung said any damage award should be much less as trial enters its closing days.

10 Tablets To Shake Up 2012
10 Tablets To Shake Up 2012
(click image for larger view and for slideshow)
If Samsung is found guilty of infringing Apple's patents, a prospect that seems to get a little closer each day, it will not be knocked out of the smartphone business. It will redesign its models to eliminate the offending parts and get back into the market, probably within a few weeks, said Michael Wagner, a damages expert in federal District Court testimony Thursday.

Wagner, called by Samsung to dispute Apple's $2.5 billion to $2.75 billion estimate of appropriate damages, ended up discussing a Price Waterhouse study that pointed out some major differences between the two companies. Apple brings out one new iPhone a year, while Samsung introduces a new phone "about once a week," he noted. Samsung officials say they average 50 new models a year, trying to meet expectations of different carriers for a unique model.

In the Price Waterhouse study, Apple ranked higher than Samsung on attractiveness of design, as one of the 25 smartphone features consumers were asked about. But the study identified previous Android smartphone purchasers who had considered an iPhone. Twenty-five percent of this group ended up getting an iPhone. But 75% remained loyal to Android manufacturers, especially Samsung, because design was not the deciding factor in their decision. Feature sets were, and the Galaxy gained ground on the iPhone when it offered features that were exclusive, such as GPS navigation.

[ Samsung has another mobile phone maker gunning for it. Read Nokia Taunts Samsung Ahead Of Windows Phone Launch. ]

"Android had an advantage during the period when it had GPS functionality and Apple didn't," Wagner said. Apple added GPS navigation to the iPhone in a model that followed the appearance of the feature on Android.

"Samsung is known for having the fastest processors, the brightest screens. Groups of features drive demand," Wagner said.

Samsung attorney Bill Price gingerly asked him what Samsung should pay Apple if it's found guilty of having infringed. He tried several times to tell the jury it was a subject he was loath to bring up. Wagner said Apple's expert witness, Terry Musika, had miscalculated by using Samsung's total smartphone revenue rather than its profits from smartphone sales. By deducting the expenses of producing and selling the Galaxy and related lines, Wagner got the damages down to $518.7 million.

He urged further reductions because during the disputed period, Apple had no additional smartphones to sell, by its own admission. He also said if sales of only the offending phones were used, the number becomes smaller; Musika used sales of all Samsung smartphones, but only certain models are claimed by Apple to have infringed.

Meanwhile, Judge Koh, who is a former patent attorney herself, indicated she understands how complex the combined case, Apple vs. Samsung and Samsung vs. Apple, is. She said she was holding out an admitted "pathological hope" that Apple CEO Tim Cook will meet with the top leadership of Samsung, vice chairman Choi Gee-sung and mobile chief Shin Jong-Kyun, to settle the case. News reports indicate they met July 16, two weeks before the trial started, but nothing came of it.

"I'm also hoping there's some horse-trading going on. Now is the time," she said. If there's no out-of-court settlement, the case will be handed over to the jury.

The company executives better meet soon. The two firms will exhaust the last of their 25 hours of time arguing in front of the jury on Friday. On Aug. 21, they will each have two additional hours to make their closing statements.

Judge Koh will then spend an hour and a half on her instructions to the jury in what is likely to be, given the intricacies of patent law, a mind-numbing exercise for all. Then the jury will move from its cramped quarters next to the courtroom--the table at which the jury sits during breaks occupies the whole room--to a larger jury room, close to Koh's office in the federal court building, to do its work. No one is sure how long that will take or what the result will be.

1 of 2
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
8/17/2012 | 2:03:10 PM
re: Apple, Samsung Battle Over Damages In Patent Trial
Samsung is investing in the US yesterday in an unprecedented move that told the Governor they are coining a new word "insourcing". Apple is jealous of this fact as the R&D that is about to come out of Samsung will be second to none. Apple should build their Torus shaped building and stop this losing battle wasting the courts time. Innovation from a bottom feeder (HTC) is happening as we speak. Apple does not watch out they will lose more than just this case, they could lose all forms of credibility in the investment circles. Insourcing from tech giants had a stake thrust into the ground yesterday, this is the model of our new society. I bet HTC is next. Apple had better get to work. Litigating was a stupid move.

What Samsung is doing is gold plated smart.
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
To learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
IT Strategies to Conquer the Cloud
Chances are your organization is adopting cloud computing in one way or another -- or in multiple ways. Understanding the skills you need and how cloud affects IT operations and networking will help you adapt.
Twitter Feed
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll