Mobile // Mobile Devices
Commentary
3/1/2013
12:08 PM
Fritz Nelson
Fritz Nelson
Commentary
Connect Directly
LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
Google+
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

EBay, PayPal Fuel Future Of Mobile Commerce

Hungry, time-pressed Mobile World Congress reporters prove mobile payments may, in fact, be as exciting as advertised.

On Monday, the first day of Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, Spain, I waited in line for lunch with our TV team for well over an hour. We all got a simple ham sandwich, a Catalonian staple. And then we ran behind the rest of the day.

This annual conference attracts some 70,000 people. Moving around Fira Gran Via, the brand new venue for the event, is a bit like making your way through the crowd at a One Direction concert, minus the screaming girls. And for as long as the GSM Association has been hosting the Congress, it hasn't been able to feed its attendees in a reasonable timeframe.

Or so I thought. PayPal, thanks to a fortuitously scheduled meeting Monday afternoon, came to my rescue, and I won't ever think about mobile commerce the same way again.

Discussions around mobile commerce (and mobile payments) usually devolve into debates about the best technology for consumers to buy goods online or at the point of sale -- digital wallets, the NFC, the QR code, secure authentication mechanisms like chip and pin, etc. Or the discussion centers on who's in the best position to drive payment standards or run the payment rails.

I'm no longer convinced that any of those things will matter. Or rather, I think they will all matter. After all, mobile commerce involves an ecosystem that begins with a click, or an app on a device, and ends, as any commerce does, at a bank. In between lie payment processors, merchants, evolving point-of-sale equipment manufacturers, mobile operators, credit card companies and more. The alliances are forming quickly.

[ Considering Google Wallet for your bodega? See 5 Things SMBs Should Know About Google Wallet. ]

At Mobile World Congress, for example, Visa and Samsung announced a partnership whereby Visa account information can be loaded onto Samsung's NFC devices, and Samsung will load Visa's PayWave app onto its smartphones. It's an ideal marriage of smartphone leader and payment leader so that consumers can gobble up goods more quickly. Visa senior business leader Brad Greene says the company's PayWave technology is integrated with 70 NFC devices, "with another 70 in the queue."

Each part of the ecosystem wants to accelerate a frictionless "customer experience," a gaggable buzz phrase thrust into every vendor PowerPoint presentation and speech these days. But here the phrase fits.

Back to my team's stomachs. For the rest of the week at Mobile World Congress, each day I went into the "local" tab of the PayPal app on my smartphone; found one of two restaurants using an application called Beat The Q, created by Nick Cloete, the founder and CEO of Australia-based Kounta; ordered lunch for six of our TV crew; paid (using PayPal); and received a confirmation text, followed quickly by a text saying our food was ready. I would then pass by a long line of distressed attendees and pick up my to-go order. All of this happened within five minutes.

Suddenly, all was well with the world. Problem solved. But more came to mind. Imagine, I thought, if my local coffee shop were to let me do this, offer me discounts, suggest new brews, tempt me with new sweets or even use my location to automatically know how far away I am so it could make my coffee just in time and keep it piping hot. Toss Google Now into the mix with Kounta and PayPal, and it's entirely possible. Forget friction; this is the greasy-good stuff. For better or worse, Kounta's Cloete says merchants report that customers using this technology spend 20% more than those who don't.

It's exciting to think about, but it's not really here just yet. As David Strom points out in Why eWallets Still Are Bad News, there's still a lack of consumer confidence to overcome. Merchant confidence is hardly any better. Two merchants were operating Beat The Q at Mobile World Congress, and while Kounta has signed up 500 merchants worldwide, including the Australian Sonoma Bakery, none of them is a global household name and there's no one in the U.S. yet. (I offered the names of my favorite watering holes, though.)

I liked that PayPal generated and emailed me a receipt, but sometimes the app showed me being eight miles away, even when I was within 100 feet. Also, the merchant is supposed to use the PayPal profile picture to identify customers (and, ostensibly, to greet them), but anyone could have grabbed my food before I arrived. It's also probable that if even a fraction of Mobile World Congress attendees used the app, they would have had to rename it "Chaos At The Q." I selfishly held off writing about it until the show was over.

But these are, as they say, first-world problems. There's plenty more innovation grease on its way. EBay executives told me that the mobile divisions of both eBay and PayPal are now gone, that mobile is just baked into their companies. At its stand at Mobile World Congress, eBay was showing off all kinds of applications, like a Toys "R" Us kiosk where the shopper enters buying criteria and gets suggestions based in part on data eBay has in its database of shopping habits.

An eBay spokesman talked about customers using a mobile device to announce they're in a store, either actively (by checking in) or passively (discovery). Or a customer's smartphone turning on a camera view of his store surroundings and showing him only places where his clothing size or shopping desires would suggest he has interest.

For now, I'll be happy enough with a cafe con leche, extra caliente, extra grande. I'll be there in cinco minutos, but I'll skip the jamon sandwich. No mas.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
LindaJoyAdams
50%
50%
LindaJoyAdams,
User Rank: Guru
3/5/2013 | 12:03:47 AM
re: EBay, PayPal Fuel Future Of Mobile Commerce
As an older, disabled person, i do much of my shopping online. Using pay pal mean my confidential info is being known to only them as they make the payment for the purchase. Plus the convenience of not having to check if there is a security icon somewhere and the seller;s site and having to type in that humongous long number we have on our plastic money.Linda Joy Adams
Andrew Hornback
50%
50%
Andrew Hornback,
User Rank: Apprentice
3/2/2013 | 4:22:08 AM
re: EBay, PayPal Fuel Future Of Mobile Commerce
I think the big hurdles to widespread acceptance of these technologies has to do with compliance (PCI, KYC), risk management and infrastructure cost. Until you can prove that effectively turning a mobile phone (or other device) into the equivalent of a payment card is safe, it won't gain widespread adoption.

And from the sound of it, it looks like eBay may be trying to go head to head with Amazon regarding its mobile technology regarding the kiosk idea - but from the sound of the in-store app, I'm not sure that retailers are really going to buy into that with the idea being that the longer that a shopper is in their retail location, the more likely they are to increase their purchases as opposed to being very tightly directed to where there interests may lie.

Andrew Hornback
InformationWeek Contributor
gilly05
50%
50%
gilly05,
User Rank: Apprentice
3/1/2013 | 11:52:29 PM
re: EBay, PayPal Fuel Future Of Mobile Commerce
I am really excited for this to actually move out of development and into the wild. I have downloaded the PayPal app, Dwolla, and Square... but I have nowhere to use the technology! I now have the PayPal Here app and it works well. But, it's silly that I can pay for eBay items, accept credit card payments for my business, and transfer funds to/from bank accounts all from my phone, but God forbid I pay for dinner with the same device.

Come on people... let's get smart about this and get moving. The technology is there and has been there for years. What we need now are merchants getting into the mix and getting behind a provider. Let's make a selection of the standards and start spending/receiving money electronically.
ChrisMurphy
50%
50%
ChrisMurphy,
User Rank: Author
3/1/2013 | 9:22:49 PM
re: EBay, PayPal Fuel Future Of Mobile Commerce
I would flip to mobile payments in a heartbeat if it was easy and practical. I'd even trade in my dashing vintage BlackBerry Curve to do so. OK, so i'd trade that in for a pack of gum. But I'm still bullish on mobile payments, and impatient for mainstream use.
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Among 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Tech Digest, Nov. 10, 2014
Just 30% of respondents to our new survey say their companies are very or extremely effective at identifying critical data and analyzing it to make decisions, down from 42% in 2013. What gives?
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.