Mobile // Mobile Devices
News
10/23/2013
10:20 AM
Connect Directly
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations

Microsoft's Surface 2 and Apple's iPad Air are poised for a head-to-head showdown. Here are nine ways to decide which is better for you.

 Microsoft Surface: 10 Best And Worst Changes
Microsoft Surface: 10 Best And Worst Changes
(click image for larger view)
Apple CEO Tim Cook said Tuesday that many companies were skeptical when the iPad debuted, but almost every tech player has since rushed to produce tablets of their own. Indeed, as Cook was introducing the company's new iPad Air, Microsoft had started selling its newest product intended to invade Apple's turf -- the Surface 2.

Microsoft's original Surface flopped notoriously, but the company has showed no signs of intimidation with the new and improved iteration. With a base cost of $449, the Surface 2 is priced to compete head-to-head with the $499 iPad Air.

Which device might be a better match for your needs? Here are nine factors to consider.

1. Both devices are thin and light.

The iPad Air is fractionally thicker at 7.5 mm than Sony's Xperia Tablet Z, currently the world's thinnest tablet. The Air is lighter than the Xperia, however, at just 1 pound. This gives Apple claim to the most portable full-size tablet.

[ Learn what the iPad Air doesn't have. See Apple's Reveal: What Was Missing. ]

The Surface 2 is a bit bigger but isn't a chore to carry around; it measures just under 9 mm thick and weighs 1.5 pounds, putting it in the same range as the iPad 4. Basically, if the iPad Air or Surface 2 is too heavy for your tastes, you probably need to spend more time lifting weights at the gym than deliberating tablet purchases.

2. The Surface 2 has a slightly bigger screen.

The Surface 2 has a 10.6-inch, 16:9 screen with 1080p resolution. The iPad Air has a slightly smaller 9.7-inch screen but more pixels. The screen is also surrounded by a slimmer frame, styled after the one in the iPad Mini, which makes the screen look bigger.

3. Both devices emphasize productivity but in different ways.

The Surface Pro 2 comes preloaded with Office Home and Student 2013 RT, which now includes Outlook RT. New iPad Air owners, meanwhile, are entitled to free downloads of Apple's productivity and creative apps iWork and iLife.

Office has the edge in familiarity, compatibility with collaborators, and depth of features. But iWork offers enough tools to satisfy most users' needs. It's also a cross-platform tool that supports real-time teamwork among remote collaborators, due to the introduction of iWork for iCloud.

The Surface was always geared more toward lap use than the iPad, thanks to its built-in kickstand and abundance of keyboard accessories. Now, with its new kickstand's two-position design, the Surface 2 is even easier to use on the lap than before, giving it a potential edge over the iPad Air. But many iPad users have already shown their willingness to embrace third-party keyboards, so it's unclear how this advantage will play out.

The Surface 2 also boasts true multitasking within the Modern UI. iOS 7 provides new ways to move between open apps, but Windows 8.1 and Windows RT 8.1 allow users to run several touch apps at once, no jumping required. The size of the Surface 2's screen limits heavy multitasking -- but if your workflow involves copying and pasting data between apps or other multitasking needs, it might serve you better than the iPad Air.

4. Both devices offer outstanding construction.

With the iPad Air, Apple is unlikely to relinquish its reputation as the industry's leader in industrial design. Even so, the Surface 2's high-quality construction is comparable. Despite being surprisingly light and easy to hold, the Surface 2 feels solid and luxurious thanks to its sturdy magnesium alloy case.

5. The Surface 2 is speedy but probably not as fast as the iPad Air.

Early benchmarking tests indicate that the Surface 2, which runs on Nvidia's Tegra 4 chip, is much more responsive than its predecessor. The iPad Air is probably faster, though. Apple's super-responsive new iPhone 5s is using a version of the iPad Air's desktop-class A7 processor, Apple promises that the Air will be its fastest, most powerful slate to date.

6. The Surface 2 is more convenient to use with peripherals.

As usual, Apple's pursuit of thinness has resulted in another iPad without built-in peripheral ports. With cloud storage becoming more common, ports might not be the necessity they once were. Still, for many, the iPad is a hassle because it can accept USB drives only via an accessory. The Surface 2, in contrast, includes both a USB 3.0 port and a micro SD slot.

Previous
1 of 2
Next
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Why...why...
50%
50%
Why...why...,
User Rank: Apprentice
10/28/2013 | 1:08:36 AM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Someone was obviously paid by microsoft....
mildmanneredjanitor
50%
50%
mildmanneredjanitor,
User Rank: Apprentice
10/26/2013 | 6:36:12 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Good answer friend.
Makes me feel I'm drinking flat white there in the coffee shop with you! Here in the uk, I think there is both less free income and peer pressure to subscribe into the Mac status symbols. I didn't see a single Macbook Air or pro on thr train. The legion of iPad folk though were typically all male, senior-professional types, and looked pretty bored/frustrated to be honest.
I
Michael Endler
50%
50%
Michael Endler,
User Rank: Author
10/26/2013 | 1:55:10 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Yeah, I've heard some gripes about the new iWork too. Haven't had a chance to check it out yet, since I've been spending time with a Surface 2 and Windows 8.1. But it sounds like not everyone is happy, even if it's free. Apple makes great hardware and operating systems, but some of their individual software applications can be hit and miss.

The train comment is interesting. I agree with some of the broad strokes you've observed-- if someone is using an iPad, they are probably reading/gaming/watching, and if someone is working on a spreadsheet, you can bet it's on a Windows machine. But at least in San Francisco, I see relatively few Windows machines being used for more than work--e.g. for games. I carry my Surface around because it's often easier than carrying a full laptop, and I certainly think Win 8.1 touch devices are fine for reading/gaming/watching-- but inside the city, I've only seen one other person with a Surface. I actually see a ton of people working (writing, coding, spreadsheets, graphics, etc) on MacBook Airs and MacBook Pros; if you're going by SF-area cafe patrons, the Apple laptops command about half the market. And based on my observations at conferences and events, tech journalists and analysts seem to carry around Apple devices about 4:1 versus Windows devices.

Just goes to show that the device market is hard to read, and that anecdotal experience is tricky to apply. I think the explosion of device types, workflows and use cases is why some people under-appreciate how productive iPads can be, and why others underestimate both how dominant a product like Office really is, and how important Windows will continue to be for years to come.
mildmanneredjanitor
50%
50%
mildmanneredjanitor,
User Rank: Apprentice
10/26/2013 | 5:22:13 AM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Apparently users are up in arms because the new iWorks has regressed/removed so much functionality.

Cant believe Apple have the cheek to try and spin the fact that they therefore had to make it free into a proposed selling point!

I took two long train journeys this week. Interesting that the iPad users were playing games, watching tv shows and reading.

The Windows users (almost exclusively laptops as cost/quality touch devices clearly are only just now coming through) were typically working in excel, word and outlook, coding, watching movies, and playing games.

This for me sums up a very scary change in the mobile competitive environment that Apple is facing in to.
Michael Endler
50%
50%
Michael Endler,
User Rank: Author
10/25/2013 | 8:48:38 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
It's true-- the device variety is staggering. This article focused on the Surface 2 and the iPad Air because they're similarly-priced, full-size tablets with luxury build quality. They differ in different ways, but with one going on sale the same day the other was announced, a direct comparison was interesting.

But we ran another article today that looks at the tablet market a bit more fully, including the Surface Pro 2, the newly discounted Surface Pro, and other new contenders, such as Dell's Venue 11 Pro.

Last year, one could blame slow Windows 8 device sales on lousy hardware, to an extent. But this year, the devices are much better, and Windows 8.1 makes everything much more cohesive. Some of these devices are going to be compelling packages-- but I'm not sure how many $500-ish non-Apple tablets the market will support, especially with some of them offering relatively minor differentiation.

Ultimately, it's a good problem for buyers-- lots of choices.
blowfish88
50%
50%
blowfish88,
User Rank: Apprentice
10/25/2013 | 7:14:18 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Cofmparing just these 2 devices doesn't do the tablet market justice. Of the 2 I prefer the Surface Pro 2, not the Surface or RT model. Before buying anything I will look at Samsung, Lenovo, and Dell devices recently announced.
mak63
50%
50%
mak63,
User Rank: Ninja
10/24/2013 | 7:44:07 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Hybrid laptops are already here. If you add some accessories to tablets, they will reach easily a hybrid price. For me is a no brainier. I'll choose a laptop hybrid every time.
I would really love to see some pics or videos in an article like this.
GAProgrammer
50%
50%
GAProgrammer,
User Rank: Ninja
10/24/2013 | 7:24:13 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
In response to:
"We are still not there yet to completely ditch our computers/laptops in favor of tablets. But we are on our way and I believe in next 2-3 years we will have another hybrid device which will fill the gap."
Reports show tablets are mostly used to augment laptops/desktops in the workplace, not replace them. I have all three and they each have their uses, but the tablet will never, ever replace my tablet for 3D CAD work or for software development. The reports of the "post-PC" era are highly exaggerated.

I think if anything, they are used to supplement/replace desktops in the home, where many users do little more than surf the web, use email, or Facebook. Anyone who does more than that has little use for a tablet (except apps, of course). The games on there are fun, but not very deep. Compare the spec for Battlefield 4 on a PC and there's no way that could ever be done on a tablet.

Overall, it's a pretty good article with some great comparison points. I am no Apple fan but prefer my iPad2 to the Surface for my apps and Facebook. I really wanted the Surface to take off, but they just didn't get it right. Sounds like they are moving in the right direction (for once).
Aden11
50%
50%
Aden11,
User Rank: Apprentice
10/23/2013 | 9:13:15 PM
re: iPad Air vs. Surface 2: 9 Considerations
Michael: Again good article. Microsoft is closing the gap in terms of quality of hardware and improvements in user experience. Keyboard cover is brilliant and it comes with huge advantages, On the other hand, Apple is more focusing on over all user experience and they are extremely successful in this.

In the end it is your personal choice. But I think there is no huge difference. The only area where Microsoft lags is App collection both in numbers and quality. Currently, Apple is offering far superior apps. I recently start my school and I am solely depending on my iPad. I am using it for my notes, e-books, writing papers, presentations, browsing etc. so far I am not missing my laptop.

We are still not there yet to completely ditch our computers/laptops in favor of tablets. But we are on our way and I believe in next 2-3 years we will have another hybrid device which will fill the gap.
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Among 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Must Reads Oct. 21, 2014
InformationWeek's new Must Reads is a compendium of our best recent coverage of digital strategy. Learn why you should learn to embrace DevOps, how to avoid roadblocks for digital projects, what the five steps to API management are, and more.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Archived InformationWeek Radio
A roundup of the top stories and trends on InformationWeek.com
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.