Mobile // Mobile Devices
Commentary
5/4/2012
09:18 AM
Eric Zeman
Eric Zeman
Commentary
50%
50%

Samsung Galaxy S III: Pros And Cons

Samsung's Galaxy S III smartphone will compete in the U.S. with the Apple iPhone, HTC One X, and Nokia Lumia 900. How does it stack up?

When the Samsung Galaxy S III goes on sale in the U.S. in June, it will face some heavy competition. HTC and Nokia have delivered some excellent handsets to AT&T's network in the last month, and there's always the iPhone 4S, which is about halfway through its yearly update cycle. That makes the Galaxy S III the most important handset of the year for Samsung, which is jousting with Apple for the worldwide smartphone crown.

Did Samsung do enough with this device? Let's take a look at what Samsung got right and what it didn't.

The Good

Thin and light. At 133 grams (4.7oz), the S III is incredibly light. It measures 8.6mm thick, which isn't the thinnest dimension in the smartphone market, but it's still really thin. Thin and light smartphones are easy to carry around and easier on the hand with extended use.

Awesome radios. The S III includes all the radios that matter: LTE, HSPA+, Wi-Fi, a GPS, GLONASS, Bluetooth 4.0, and NFC. The 4G support is vital for this class of device, and by upping to Bluetooth 4.0, the S III will be able to work with an incredible array of accessories without affecting battery life. The NFC radio means the S III can be used for mobile payments and other tap-and-go actions.

Killer software. Android 4.0 with a toned-down version of TouchWiz? Yes, please. Based on Samsung's demonstrations during the launch event, the S III has a finely tuned user experience that is meant to make the phone as natural to use as possible. Since it is based on Android 4.0 we already know that it has a solid base. Samsung flexed its software chops with the S III in a way that sets the phone apart from its competitors.

[ For more on the features of Samsung's new smartphone, see Samsung Galaxy S III: Key Features. ]

Solid cameras. Samsung did some really interesting things with the camera. Never mind the specs, the S III's advanced facial recognition features for keeping the display awake or tagging photos is really neat stuff. The fact that it shoots 8- and 2-megapixels and 1080p/720p HD video with the back and front cameras, respectively, is an added bonus. Toss in zero shutter lag, and you have a winner.

Massive storage. The S III will come with three different built-in storage capacities: 16GB, 32GB, and 64GB. This mirrors what's available with the Apple iPhone. However, Samsung went one step further and stuck a microSDXC slot in as well. This means users can choose to add another 64GB of storage, bumping the S III up to a total of 128GB. That's the same amount of storage as my laptop has.

As great as these features may be, though, there are some significant drawbacks that are worth pointing out.

The Bad

Questionable display design. The Galaxy S and S II and Super AMOLED displays were simply incredible. With the Galaxy Nexus and now the S III, Samsung uses HD Super AMOLED but has switched to a PenTile pixel matrix. I've used PenTile devices, and I find the arrangement distracting. It essentially clouds up what would otherwise be a crystal-clear display. It offers some benefits, and many people probably don't notice the shortcomings, but smartphone aficionados will be put off by this spec.

Also, the S and S II had displays between 4.3 and 4.5 inches. Even with these display sizes, Samsung managed to keep the overall footprint of the devices small. By increasing the S III's display size to 4.8 inches, Samsung risks losing customers with small hands. Many people find even 4.3-inch displays to be too large.

Untested processor. Samsung is using its own quad-core Exynos processor for the S III. Each core is clocked at 1.4GHz and the device has 1GB of RAM. Early benchmarks suggest it's a data-crunching monster. The drawback, however, is that it uses Samsung's 32nm processes. Samsung said the battery will last all day long, but the Exynos doesn't appear to be as efficient as alternate chips, such as Qualcomm's Snapdragon S4.

Materials and design. One of the problems faced by Samsung's earlier Galaxy devices is that they felt cheap and "plastic-y." I've also never really warmed to the design, which I find to be a bit pedestrian. Samsung didn't fix these issues with the S III.

For some reason, polycarbonate is the smartphone chassis material of the year. Both HTC and Nokia have delivered excellent quality designs using this fancy-pants plastic.

Early hands-on reports said the S III feels a bit chintzy. This worries me a lot. Though cheap-feeling plastics haven't prevented Samsung from selling tens of millions of smartphones in the last few years, its competitors have upped the ante a bit. With the iPhone 5 rumored to be using a material called liquidmetal, Samsung needs to make sure the build and feel of its phones are of the best quality possible. HTC and Nokia have done much better with their polycarbonate devices, and that will make side-by-side comparisons at retail shops tough on Samsung.

The bottom line: Despite the flaws I've pointed out here, Samsung is primed to sell this device in what will probably be record numbers--at least until October.

At this interactive Enterprise Mobility Virtual Event, experts and solution providers will offer detailed insight into how to bring some order to the mobile industry innovation chaos. When you register, you will gain access to live webcast presentations and virtual booths packed with free resources. It happens May 17.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
TH3ORY
50%
50%
TH3ORY,
User Rank: Apprentice
5/23/2012 | 10:12:18 PM
re: Samsung Galaxy S III: Pros And Cons
Dear Eric Zeman you find the pentile display arrangement distracting?? Thats the most utter garbage, i have heard in my entire life.. Can you please elaborate?? How is it distracting do you use a microscope to view your content ?? im serious here i would like a answer... Please
artsom
50%
50%
artsom,
User Rank: Apprentice
5/5/2012 | 2:28:18 PM
re: Samsung Galaxy S III: Pros And Cons
@svmtoo, if you're so frustrated with the absence of .pst syncing, why don't you just spend a couple of bucks on third party software out there? I use one and it works. I do agree with you regarding the sizes of new smartphones. I wish they would also come up with a 4" or below version of S III.
Mimic
50%
50%
Mimic,
User Rank: Apprentice
5/4/2012 | 11:01:54 PM
re: Samsung Galaxy S III: Pros And Cons
@svmtoo

The second you spoke about your Bold you lost all credibility about whats "in" and whats not. You sir are not the target market any more and will never be again so get used to your out dated black berry and you "iFollow" the cool crowed phone.
svmtoo
50%
50%
svmtoo,
User Rank: Apprentice
5/4/2012 | 7:23:37 PM
re: Samsung Galaxy S III: Pros And Cons
Dear Eric,

I am happy to see that someone is taking a good hard look at these devices.

I have had so many devices from an old Nokia 610, to 660, to Blackberry Pearl, Bold, Curve, Torch, and several Samsung.

I just don't see what the the surveys are saying. Big Screens are In? No.

I am a consultant who travels very often. I have a Bold 9700 and an iPhone. The Bold has a great set of features but is very limited apps. iPhone has a great UI but is limited PIM capabilities. Both of which are crucial.

When I switched to the iPhone, it took a lot getting used to for it's size. Now, phones are nearing 5" screen size? Imagine me sitting in a meeting, the phone rings, and I hold up a tablet to my ear and start speaking?

Another very frustrating idea is that none of the Android devices natively Sync with Outlook's PST file. The only two software bundles which have succeeded in doing so, and correctly, are Microsoft's ActiveSync and the Blackberry Desktop.
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Among 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Tech Digest, Dec. 9, 2014
Apps will make or break the tablet as a work device, but don't shortchange critical factors related to hardware, security, peripherals, and integration.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Archived InformationWeek Radio
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on InformationWeek.com for the week of December 14, 2014. Be here for the show and for the incredible Friday Afternoon Conversation that runs beside the program.
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.