Mobile // Mobile Devices
Commentary
6/7/2012
03:37 PM
Eric Zeman
Eric Zeman
Commentary
Connect Directly
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math

Apple iPhones soon will be available from at least two prepaid providers, so we crunch the numbers to find the least expensive option.

Virgin Mobile USA, which is owned and run by Sprint, threw its hat in the iPhone prepaid ring Thursday. The company will begin selling the iPhone 4 and iPhone 4S to its customers starting June 29 with plans that cost as little as $30 per month. Virgin will offer the 8-GB iPhone 4 for $549 and the 16-GB iPhone 4S for $649.

Virgin's announcement followed the lead set by Cricket Wireless, which last week announced similar plans for the Apple iPhone. Cricket will sell the Apple iPhone 4 and iPhone 4S starting June 22. The devices will cost $399 and $499, respectively, and can be matched to a voice and data plan that costs only $55 per month. No contract is required, and you can cancel the service any time you want.

Both offers are fairly enticing, but will you really save any money compared to the iPhone prices and plans offered by the major wireless network operators in the U.S.? Let's take a look.

[ Are you ready for the new iPhone? Read iPhone 5, iPad Mini: September Debut Eyed. ]

For the basis of this comparison, let's assume we're purchasing the 16-GB iPhone 4S and going with the absolute cheapest service plan options available from any given carrier. Even though Cricket and Virgin don't require contracts, let's use the 24-month period to provide a perspective on costs. Also, let's forget about taxes and just go with the raw figures we have, as wireless taxes vary by state. Last, since iPhones can use iMessage, which sends text/picture messages over the network rather than via traditional SMS/MMS pipes, we'll avoid adding extra messaging plans. Purely looking at the lowest possible choices from the providers below.

Cricket:

Cricket's 16-GB iPhone 4S costs $499 and must be matched with a $55 monthly plan. Cricket's plan offers unlimited voice minutes, messaging, and data. Spending $55 per month for 24 months totals $1,320. Toss in $499 for the iPhone and your base cost is $1,819.

Virgin Mobile USA:

Virgin Mobile USA's 16-GB iPhone 4S costs $649 and must be matched with a minimum $30 monthly plan. This minimum plan includes 300 voice minutes, unlimited messaging, and 2.5 GB of 3G data (before throttling). This plan also reflects a $5 discount if customers sign up for automatic payments. Spending $30 per month for 24 months totals $720. Toss in $649 for the iPhone and your base is $1,369. That's $450 cheaper than Cricket's plan.

AT&T:

If you go with Apple's long-time iPhone partner AT&T, you'll spend $199 on the 16-GB iPhone 4S. The minimum voice plan allowed costs $39.99 for 450 minutes. You can skip a messaging plan if you don't mind paying per message, but you must include a $20 monthly 300-MB data plan. As long as you don't send a single text, picture, or video message, you're looking at $59.99 times 24 months for a total of $1,440. Add the $199 for the iPhone itself and you're at $1,639. Updated with correct data allotment.

Sprint:

Sprint makes things fairly easy. The 16-GB iPhone 4S costs $199. Sprint offers an unlimited everything (including messaging) plan for $69.99 per month. So spending $70 per month for 24 months and you're looking at damage of $1,680. Include the $199 device cost, and you're looking at $1,879 over two years.

Verizon Wireless:

If you choose to go with Big Red instead of Cricket or Virgin, the 16-GB iPhone 4S costs only $199, but it requires a two-year contract. The absolute cheapest options available include a 450-minute voice plan at $39.99 per month and $30 2-GB data plan. If you want messaging, too, you'll either have to choose to pay by the message or fork over $10 for 1,000 messages or $20 for unlimited messages. If we go with the pay-by-use model, the absolute least you can spend with Verizon per month is $69.99. Spending $70 per month for 24 months and you're looking at damage of $1,680. Include the $199 device cost, and you're looking at $1,879 over two years.

Bottom Line:

Looking at the above options, the Virgin Mobile USA plan is the least expensive over the course of two years compared to the others. Granted, the comparisons here aren't equal in that they don't include equivalent minutes, messaging, and data--but they are the lowest rates available from each carrier discussed.

If you don't mind being limited to 300 voice minutes and just 2.5 GB of data, Virgin's deal is the one to pick.

Black Hat USA Las Vegas, the premiere conference on information security, features four days of deep technical training followed by two days of presentations from speakers discussing their latest research around a broad range of security topics. At Caesars Palace in Las Vegas, July 21-26. Register today.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Page 1 / 3   >   >>
elai980
50%
50%
elai980,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/15/2012 | 4:31:19 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
You do need to jailbreak if you want MMS (picture texts) and group texts. Otherwise, my experience with Straight Talk has been good, and price, using a trick from my corporate plan that you can probably use, is less than Virgin or Cricket:
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/syba...
moarsauce123
50%
50%
moarsauce123,
User Rank: Ninja
6/9/2012 | 11:15:40 AM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
Why would anyone even pay over 1300$ for the iPhone and contract over two years? This is just insanely expensive. I rather invest that money in pizza and beer.
DavidB
50%
50%
DavidB,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/9/2012 | 1:11:28 AM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
The real question is: Why would you want the phone with the most dropped calls of any phone on a prepaid network? Its the perfect storm.
DavidB
50%
50%
DavidB,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/9/2012 | 1:10:02 AM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
>> Further, accepting the two year minimum plays right into the hands of the carriers. What happens when a new phone comes out in a year and you've just got to have it? Pay the $350+ cancellation fee?

You could pay the ETF (Early termination fee) which STARTS at $350 and gets lower every month till it is zero at the end of the two year term; then you pay $200 for a new Iphone. With prepaid there is no ETF but you pay $600 for a new iphone,. So its a pretty similar cost situation except you have exponentially lower customer service with prepaid.
ANON1237925156805
50%
50%
ANON1237925156805,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 10:28:03 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
That's a tad persnickety no? Thanks for pointing out what was missed but this is a hornet's next so no one can really bat 1.000.

For me, good basis of comparison. AT&T fares surprisingly well. I'll stay put for now. My phone works in Europe where a CDMA wouldn't. . .
Skidmore
50%
50%
Skidmore,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 7:00:15 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
I'm sorry, but you are COMPLETELY wrong on one huge fact:

"Sprint offers an unlimited everything (including messaging) plan for $69.99 per month."

The plan at the price you are referencing is the Everything Data 450. It gives you unlimited data, text/pictures/videos and unlimited Any Mobile, Anytime. You are however limited to 450 minutes a month for calls to and from landlines.

For the UNLIMITED plan, you want the Simply Everything. This is the plan that gives you unlimited minutes. The issue here is that it cost $99.99 a month.

Another thing that you did not account for on the Sprint side is the need for Premium Data on a smart phone. (Which the iPhone is.) Premium Data is another $10 a month. This now makes the Everything Data 450 $79.99 and the Simply Everything $109.99.

Please, if you are going to write an article about cell phones carriers and their prices, do a little bit of research first. People read this and make purchasing decisions on what they read as they believe you are an authority on the subject.
beerman76
50%
50%
beerman76,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 4:42:57 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
My wife has AT&T
beerman76
50%
50%
beerman76,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 4:42:34 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
This is slightly flawed, For virgin mobile I pay $1.50 in taxes and my wife pays a lot more in taxes and fees and a bunch of other costs....so he shouldn't of compared just the plan rate
dlapham374
50%
50%
dlapham374,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 3:39:41 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
She doesn't use voice often, so this doesn't help us. If/When we switch to straight talk, we will get unlimited voice and text, so it will still be a better deal than AT&T.
dlapham374
50%
50%
dlapham374,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/8/2012 | 3:35:33 PM
re: Virgin Prepaid iPhones: Do The Math
The iPhone micro-SIM uses AT&T and does not require an unlocked phone, as long as it is AT&T.
Page 1 / 3   >   >>
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Building A Mobile Business Mindset
Among 688 respondents, 46% have deployed mobile apps, with an additional 24% planning to in the next year. Soon all apps will look like mobile apps – and it's past time for those with no plans to get cracking.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
InformationWeek Tech Digest September 18, 2014
Enterprise social network success starts and ends with integration. Here's how to finally make collaboration click.
Flash Poll
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
InformationWeek Radio
Archived InformationWeek Radio
The weekly wrap-up of the top stories from InformationWeek.com this week.
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.