Apple Dealt Courtroom Losses In Australia, Germany
Samsung wins right to sell Galaxy Tab in Land Down Under, while Motorola wins an injunction against Apple in Germany.Samsung and Apple have been battling over the Galaxy Tab in Australia since the summer months, when Apple was able to block sales of the device while Australian courts decided whether or not Samsung violated Apple's design patents. The courts have ruled in Samsung's favor. The court there also ruled that it wouldn't block sales of certain Samsung Android smartphones.
More Mobility Insights
Webcasts
- Wealth Management Goes Mobile: Providing Financial Advisors with Seamless Access to Documents, Systems and Processes
- Mobile Gaming Gold Rush: The Best Ways to Migrate and Make Money
White Papers
- Manufacturing Customers Get a Mobile Catalog of Gaskets Thanks to a New BlackBerry Smartphone App
- Tour Operator Uses BlackBerry Smartphone to Help Drive Sales, Improve Efficiency and Build Competitive Advantage
Reports
More >>Samsung's victory in Australia is perhaps bittersweet, though. Apple successfully prevented the company from selling the tablet there for nearly five months, giving its iPad a healthy lead heading into the holiday shopping season. The Galaxy Tab itself is already a six-month-old tablet, and surely Samsung has nearly finished preparing its eventual successor.
At the same time, Samsung itself was dealt a blow in France, where its attempt to ban sales of the iPhone 4S were thwarted by French courts. In the French ruling, Samsung's request was called "out of proportion" and the company was ordered to pay Apple approximately $134,000 in legal fees.
[ Samsung isn't letting lawsuits slow it down. Read Galaxy Nexus Smartphone To Launch Dec. 9? . ]
Samsung won a round in the U.S. this week, however. Apple failed to convince a judge to issue a preliminary injunction banning the sales of Samsung smartphones in the U.S. Apple has appealed that decision while awaiting the start of the trial.
Though these losses surely vex Apple, they aren't nearly as catastrophic as what happened in German courts this week.
The Mannheim Regional Court has ruled that Apple is indeed infringing on a Motorola patent described as a "method for performing countdown function during a mobile-originated transfer for a packet radio system."
What's significant about the ruling is that it includes a "preliminarily enforceable" injunction against Apple Sales International, the company's wholesale subsidiary located in Ireland. Since the patent is wide-ranging, the courts can prevent Apple from selling all versions of the iPhone and the 3G versions of the iPad across large segments of Europe.
Apple has yet to appeal this decision, but it convinced the court to attach a $134 million bond to the decision. This bond is Motorola's responsibility, and will be paid to Apple in the event that appeals later overturn the injunction awarded to Motorola. Apple had asked for a bond of $2.7 billion, citing the potential for massive sales losses, but the courts denied Apple's request.
Apple, Samsung, Motorola, HTC, and others are all embroiled in dozens of patent-related legal entanglements that are in various stages around the world. The courtroom dramas will continue to unfold over the coming months.
The Enterprise Connect conference program covers the full range of platforms, services, and applications that comprise modern communications and collaboration systems. It happens March 25-29 in Orlando, Fla. Find out more.
Related Reading
| To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy. |
Subscribe to RSSResource Links
Related Webcasts
- Wealth Management Goes Mobile: Providing Financial Advisors with Seamless Access to Documents, Systems and Processes
- Mobile Gaming Gold Rush: The Best Ways to Migrate and Make Money
- Unlock the Value of Your Business Data: IBM's Integration Solution for .NET Environments
- The Dell Difference: Lessons from Dell’s Own IT Transformation
- Collaborative DevOps: Bridging the gap between development and operations with automation
This Week's Issue
Free Print Subscription
SubscribeCurrent Healthcare Issue
- InformationWeek Healthcare CIO 25: Our second annual honor roll of the health IT leaders driving healthcare's transformation.
- EHR Unreadiness: Only a small percentage of physicians planning to apply for Meaningful Use funds have e-health record systems capable of achieving most of the requirements. .
- And much more!
- Read the Current Issue
Related Whitepapers
- Advocacy Group for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Gives High Marks to BlackBerry Accessibility Features
- Manufacturing Customers Get a Mobile Catalog of Gaskets Thanks to a New BlackBerry Smartphone App
- Tour Operator Uses BlackBerry Smartphone to Help Drive Sales, Improve Efficiency and Build Competitive Advantage
- How to Secure Mobility in an Increasingly Remote Workforce
- Gartner Report: Media Tablets and Beyond: The Impact of Mobile Devices on Enterprise Management
Featured Resource
Find out how to empower your mobile worker with the full capabilities of headquarters by allowing access anywhere at any time. Read More













