Google Fights Facebook's 'Data Dead End'
By changing the terms of service for its Contacts API, Google aims to assure reciprocal data flows.Google has changed the terms of service for users of its Contacts API to ensure that if data goes out, it can also come back in.
The change is aimed squarely at Facebook, which doesn't allow the automated export of social graph data, specifically contacts or friends.
More Security Insights
Webcasts
- Why Bad Guys Write Malware– And What You Can Do About It
- Securing the Cloud: Extend the Benefits of Traditional IT Environments to Cloud
White Papers
- How Security Features in Windows Server 2008 Can Save you Money
- Everything You Need to Know About Cloud Security but Were Afraid to Ask
Reports
More >>"Many other sites allow users to import and export their information, including contacts, quickly and easily," said a Google spokesperson in an e-mailed statement. "But sites that do not, such as Facebook, leave users in a data dead end."
Google says that it decided to change its approach because users often are unaware that once they import their contacts into sites like Facebook they don't have an automated export mechanism to get their data out.
Facebook did not respond to a request for comment. The company last month announced limited (manual) information export capabilities, but stopped short of giving users programmatic access to their data or providing a way to remove their data from Facebook's servers.
This new stance may seem like a step backwards for Google, which has gone to great lengths to make most user-owned data portable. But the company insists that it's not limiting user access to data; rather it's preventing automated access through its APIs when services that use its APIs don't offer the same access in return. The idea is to prevent Facebook from implementing a mechanism to automatically copy Google Contacts to Facebook without allowing Google to create a similar mechanism to automatically copy Facebook Friends to Google.
"It's important that when we automate the transfer of contacts to another service, users have some certainty that the new service meets a baseline standard of data portability," Google's spokesperson said. "We hope that reciprocity will be an important step towards creating a world of true data liberation--and that this move will encourage other Web sites to allow users to automate the export of their contacts as well."
Data portability has become a critical weapon against customer lock-in and customer inertia. That's why Google created tools to allow users to move data from Microsoft Exchange and Lotus Notes to Gmail and Google Apps.
But Google is not fully committed to automated export in all circumstances. As Harvard assistant professor Benjamin Edelman pointed out in 2008, Google's AdWords API prohibits automated export of AdWords data. Programmatic access to that data would make it easier for Microsoft, for example, to compete for Google's advertising customers. The contractual language has changed since 2008, but Edelman says the terms say the same thing in a more convoluted form.
"It's hard to see why Google should be allowed to lock up its crown jewels, but Facebook should not allowed to lock up its crown jewels," said Edelman in a phone interview.
See the latest collaboration tools and technologies at Enterprise 2.0 Santa Clara's comprehensive conference and expo. It happens Nov. 8-11, 2010, in Santa Clara, Calif. Find out more.
Related Reading
| To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy. |
Subscribe to RSSResource Links
Related Webcasts
This Week's Issue
Free Print Subscription
SubscribeCurrent Healthcare Issue
- InformationWeek Healthcare CIO 25: Our second annual honor roll of the health IT leaders driving healthcare's transformation.
- EHR Unreadiness: Only a small percentage of physicians planning to apply for Meaningful Use funds have e-health record systems capable of achieving most of the requirements. .
- And much more!
- Read the Current Issue
Related Whitepapers
Featured Resource
Download this paper to learn how Dell computers running Microsoft Windows 7 can help you make your operations more secure and meet compliance requirements.
Learn More












