There's one important point that's been lost amid all the chatter surrounding Google's non-announcement the other day of its vaporous GPhone, and its actual disclosure that it'll soon be releasing a phone-software development platform. It's this: mobile apps aren't the issue. It's the (slow) networks, stupid.

Despite the fact that Steve Jobs is tightly controlling all the apps which run on the iPhone, apps aren't hard to get. Not for the tightly wound iPhone, nor for open platforms like Nokia's Symbian-based phones. (Indeed, Nokia is openly touting its openness as an antidote to Apple's closed (figuratively and literally) approach.

Sure, in some cases there are apps which aren't as widely available, or for which options aren't as broad, as users would like (As a happy Blackberry user, I'm thinking here of instant messaging on these devices, which in some cases is available for the phone but not supported by the mobile service provider.)

Think about it: if you're a smartphone user, the biggest problem isn't you model's feature set, it's the fact that you probably avoid opening your browser unless it's absolutely necessary because mobile browsing is not a fun experience.

Moreover, the reason mobile browsing isn't because you can't search Google properly. (Indeed, Google is one of the few sites which works nicely when accessed from a smartphone.) It's that the browser is so crushingly slow to load. This lag stems from the puny data speeds supported by most service providers.

Consider the widely used EDGE network. It can support a theoretical maximum of 473.6 kbit/s, when it's running full-tilt on eight timeslots. More common is a max of 236.8 kbit/s (in four time-slot mode).

EDGE is considered "2.75 G"; that is, it's faster than a "2.5 G" data-rate technical such as GPRS, but not as fast as 3G. (Interestingly, EDGE's maximum is faster than the 3G's specification's data rate of 384 kbps, so I'm guessing that, in practice, 3G tends to run faster than EDGE. That is, most EDGE communications occur via four or fewer timeslots.)

Since all the domestic carriers are building out or have built 3G networks, the salient question seems to be: Will browsing on 3G be a better experience than today's experiences on EDGE. (I know there are other options, like EV-DO, but I've already gotten more technical than I intended to in this post.)

More likely, faster networks aren't the answer (since mobile service will never be fast enough to support deskbound-like browsing.

Instead, someone will have to come up with a lighter, smarter mobile browser, and every site of consequence will have to field mobile-optimized pages, which users will actually have to use. Then maybe surfing the Web from one's smartphone won't, er, suck.

What do you think? Is the mobile Internet ready for Web browsing? Leave a message on the InformationWeek Blog and let us know.

Alexander Wolfe
awolfe@cmp.com
www.informationweek.com

Qualcomm's Take On Android: We're Anxious To Watch It Unfold
Over The Air took a few moments to ask Qualcomm's Vicki Mealer, senior director of product management, QIS, a few questions about Google's Android mobile platform. On the whole, Qualcomm is positive about Android's potential.

Open Handset Alliance: Google Gets Serious About Mobile
You really have to admire Andy Rubin, Director of Mobile Platforms at Google. He's worked at Apple then General Magic then WebTV and most recently founded Danger.

What's In A Name: Does CIO Still Resonate?
Companies continue to see value in the title of CIO, at least to judge from a news announcement earlier this week.

'Dilbert' Creator Scott Adams Comes To Second Life To Get Kicked In The 'Nads
"Dilbert" creator Scott Adams made the trek to Second Life recently, where he encouraged audience members to step up and kick him in a sensitive private place. "This is what you call being customer focused. I think Nordstrom could learn a thing or two from my example," Adams said on his blog.

Is Recreating The Desktop Browsing Experience On A Mobile Phone Plausible?
Fellow InformationWeek blogger Alex Wolfe contends that slow wireless network speeds and shoddy browsers are to blame for the less-than-thrilling experience of browsing the Web from a smartphone. That got me thinking. Is recreating the desktop experience on a mobile phone the right way to tackle mobile browsing? Or does the whole issue need to be re-thought?

Phoenix's Hyperspace: Linux-Based Instant-On For Laptops
Not long after I covered Splashtop, the instant-on Linux-based boot environment that runs from flash memory, it looks like other hardware makers are getting into the same game.  Meet Phoenix's Linux-based HyperSpace.

Radiohead Fans: Ears Open, Wallets Closed
So now we know what most of the devoted fans of Radiohead thought the art-rock band's new album was worth, given the option of choosing how much to pay for it: Nothing, as in zip, zero, zilch.

The H-1B Visas That Could Save Lives
Regardless of whether you think the cap on H-1B visas should be raised or not, there are some very specific -- and scarce -- types of talent and brainpower that could help save lives but are possibly being shut out of coming into the United States.

Microsoft (Almost) Mum On CIO Departure
Stuart Scott was let go for "violation of company policies;" two executives tapped to assume his responsibilities in the interim.

Nokia To Embrace Android After All?
Of the seamingly few companies not included in yesterday's Android invasion was the world's largest maker of cell phones, Nokia. Yesterday, the company said it didn't think the new open mobile platform from Google was a threat. Today it changed its tune a bit.

Get Better Results from your IT investments
In today’s environment, you need to get the most out of your assets and people … all the while serving the strategic needs of your business and dealing with growth and acquisition issues. In addition, it is critically important to quantify results of those investments for leadership and accurately track service level agreements.

Featured Jobs:

Harry and David Operations seeking Manager, IT Warehousing Systems in Medford, OR

Openlink Financial, Inc. seeking Quality Assurance Analyst in Uniondale, NY

Union Telephone seeking Programmer Analyst in Mountain View, WY

ITT Corporation seeking Sr. System Analyst in Fort Wayne, IN

Xilinx seeking Senior Staff Circuit Designer in San Jose, CA

For more great jobs, career-related news, features and services, please visit our "Career Center.

Try InformationWeek's RSS Feed

Discover all InformationWeek's sites and newsletters

More than 20,000 IT terms, more than 20,000 definitions:
All at your fingertips, all in TechEncyclopedia

Saw a TechWeb feature you want to see again?