On The Horizon: Let's Talk Jump-Starts, Not Caution
There's been a lot of discussion in the technology sector about an article by Nicholas G. Carr titled "IT Doesn't Matter" that appeared recently in the Harvard Business Review. In it, Carr argues that IT has become commoditized, and therefore no longer has strategic value. We can only hope, Carr suggests, that the analogy doesn't carry too far; the "mid-nineteenth century boom in railroads (and the closely related technologies of the steam engine and the telegraph) helped produce not only widespread industrial capacity but a surge in productivity," a combination that "set the stage for two solid decades of deflation." Carr's advice: "Delay IT investments to significantly cut costs" and "focus on risks, not opportunities." He sounds like a basketball coach with a two-point lead who tells his team to play the "four corners." It's a message of caution.
Alan Greenspan has a message of caution, too, warning Congress recently that "with price inflation at a low level, substantial further disinflation would be an unwelcome development, especially to the extent it puts pressure on profit margins and impedes revival of business spending." When Greenspan gets cautious, investors and markets get nervous.
Caution, though, can be self-fulfilling. State of mind has a lot to do with how people and markets react. To the extent we all agree that caution is called for, caution is called for, and the cycle is difficult to break.
The easiest way for the president to win the election in 2004 is to talk more about security. Talking about security, however, is a double-edged sword; it may scare the voters to the Republican side, but it also may continue to scare away investors and delay capital spending. As Greenspan also said: "... we need to remain mindful of the possibility that lingering business caution could be an impediment to improved economic performance."
And maybe it is. Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., a candidate for president, recently spoke to technology executives in northern Virginia. The Washington Post headlined its story about the speech "Edwards Brings Revival Message to N. Va.; Presidential Hopeful Pledges New Opportunities For Dot-Com Industry." What was important wasn't so much what Edwards said but the fact that he recognized there's an opportunity in the tech sector for a candidate who wants to try and take the dialogue in another direction. That's what the sector needs--fervor to return to the hunt for the next "New New Thing." Edwards gets it.
The administration is banking on the tax cut to get the "soggy" economy moving faster. We think the president needs to start talking about how we jump-start investment and get companies buying capital goods and creating more jobs. If he continues to create an environment of caution because of political effectiveness, he may just talk the economy out of a bold recovery, with or without a tax cut.
David Post is a Temple University law professor and senior fellow at the National Center for Technology and Law at the George Mason University School of Law. Reach him at email@example.com. Bradford C. Brown is chairman of the National Center for Technology and Law at the George Mason University School of Law. Reach him at firstname.lastname@example.org.
To discuss this column with other readers, please visit the Talk Shop.
5 Top Federal Initiatives For 2015As InformationWeek Government readers were busy firming up their fiscal year 2015 budgets, we asked them to rate more than 30 IT initiatives in terms of importance and current leadership focus. No surprise, among more than 30 options, security is No. 1. After that, things get less predictable.