We ran a story yesterday that said RIM has overtaken PalmOne as the number-one PDA vendor. Don't believe it.
Actually, the story itself is true -- Gartner did report that RIM overtook PalmOne in the PDA market. What's misleading is the Gartner report itself.
story yesterday that said RIM has overtaken PalmOne as the number-one PDA
vendor, according to a Gartner report. Don't believe it.
Actually, the story itself is true -- Gartner did report that RIM overtook
PalmOne in the PDA market. What's misleading is the
Gartner report itself.
Gartner is calling several lines of RIM smart phones "PDAs."
PalmOne's actual PDAs, in other words, have been overtaken by a combination of
RIM PDAs and seven lines of RIM smart phones.
the lineup of RIM's handheld products. At the top are three lines of RIM
business smart phones. Sales of those products were not counted in Gartner's
report. Fair enough. But everything below that line was included.
these eight products labeled "Blackberry Handhelds," seven of them have built-in
cell phone functionality -- yet were not excluded from Gartner's report.
To me, if a device has a built-in phone, PDA and Internet access, it's a "smart
phone," not a PDA. But to Gartner, the test is: What does the vendor call it?
Vendor labels for products are just so much marketing. I think Gartner should
define these categories for itself rather than letting the vendors do it. That
would result in an apples-to-apples comparison, rather than what we have it in
It doesn't really matter anyway. The stand-alone PDA market is on its way to
irrelevance. All kinds of changes in rank order will take place as the
forward-thinking companies de-emphasize or abandon it, and the backward
companies keep pushing products in that space.
What I would like to see is Gartner's rankings on smart phones -- with the RIM
devices featuring mobile phone functionality included.
Such a report would be not only interesting and relevant, but credible as well.
5 Top Federal Initiatives For 2015As InformationWeek Government readers were busy firming up their fiscal year 2015 budgets, we asked them to rate more than 30 IT initiatives in terms of importance and current leadership focus. No surprise, among more than 30 options, security is No. 1. After that, things get less predictable.