It's time for U.S. businesses to stop taking the tech talent pipeline for granted.
No Safe Ground
Rockart doesn't hesitate to recommend the field: "I tell people to go into the field. The need for people who can do the job of being a business manager and technical manager is greater than it ever has been before."
Taking a stand for the IT career path isn't without big risk. The entire economy is moving into uncharted global competition. Globalization has brought dramatic change to what IT people do in the United States, and it isn't done reshaping the profession. The goal for young pros should be to find a good foundation from which to change, rather than hoping for safe ground. "In which industry are you going to go where you aren't going to have to compete?" asks Phil Zwieg, a VP of IS at Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Co. "You've got to stay on your game to be able to compete."
Blogger's Thoughts On Careers in IT
Right Choice For Hard Workers
It's clear that a degree in computer science is not the quick road to riches it once was. But what is? A degree in Sociology? How about History?
IT is still a very good career choice. Just because the get-rich-quick stock-option mania of the '90s is over does not make it a bad career field. But the competition is stiffer now.
Let's be realistic; during the '90s, almost any moron could get a job in IT with a minimal amount of skill. And anyone who was at least mediocre and signed with the right company at the right time made a lot of money.
So now, you have to be good at what you do, you have to be professional, and you have to work hard. Maybe that last part is what is scaring the kids away?
-- Charlie Harris
You Must Be Joking
How can someone even ask [about recommending IT as a career] at this point? The only people putting a positive spin on this are high-level managers and execs that stand to gain. All other tech people know the truth, the thought of IT as a career is long over. Why? Because a career is supposed to be long-term, not a job where you are worried about being laid off and knowing you most likely won't get another position. Well, I and others know that IT jobs feel like temp jobs these days--that is if you have one. Oh, and before someone starts saying things like higher education is needed, well, my friends and I have a lot of education, degrees and certifications and they don't help anymore. ... Why? We can't compete with a foreign resource getting paid on what is IMPOSSIBLE to live on here, never mind have a family.
That's not to diminish the changes hitting the IT industry. At its low in 2004, there were 25% fewer U.S. programming jobs than in 2000--that's more than 190,000 people who left the field or had to learn a new role, according to analysis of Bureau of Labor statistics by InformationWeek editor-at-large Eric Chabrow. Employment of IT managers, meanwhile, has risen 75% in the last four years, though it's still just 10% of the IT workforce. Total IT employment is around 3.35 million, after bottoming out last year at around 3.15 million. The totals hide the turmoil that individuals face when forced to change roles. But they suggest a still-strong sector overall.
The threat of global competition didn't drive Diane Zhang away from an IT career. She graduated from Penn State nine months ago in information sciences and technologies, and now she's a colleague of Huang's at Vanguard, rotating through a technology leadership program. She's doing Web-user interface development, using a component development approach that allows a consistent brand image and architecture across all Vanguard sites. Zhang predicts lots of opportunity in IT, as long as she takes a broad view of what an "IT person" is and keeps her work tied to business units and customers.
"I see myself as an IT professional, but it's all about solving problems of the business," says Zhang, who started a master's of IS in the spring and later plans to get an MBA. "IT is really exciting and unpredictable and always changing. And I think it's growing, and there's always something new to learn."
Demand for IT-educated graduates appears strong. The Bureau of Labor Statistics predicts computer scientists, computer-system analysts, and database administrators will be among the fastest-growing occupations through 2012. Admittedly, predicting job growth is tricky. But of the jobs the bureau predicts will grow most quickly through 2012, eight of 11 that require a bachelor's degree are computer-related.
The average computer-science grad started at $50,664, a 3.3% increase from last year, according to the fall quarterly survey by the National Association of Colleges and Employers. Information sciences and systems grads posted a 3.6% increase to an average offer of $43,902. Graduates in management information systems saw a bigger jump, rising 5% to an average starting salary of $43,653. Most business degrees rose at a healthy pace, such as accounting, up 4.6%, to $42,940.
Northwestern Mutual's Zwieg is part of a group of IT leaders who see all this as a case worth taking directly to students, in a program starting this fall by the Society of Information Management and Microsoft. They're planning to visit campuses in a dozen cities this year and next to lobby college kids to consider IT. Microsoft chairman Bill Gates himself will visit campuses to make the case for computer science and IT. To Zwieg, it's time for the industry to show why the smartest young minds should join its ranks. "There's enough hot and interesting things happening in this industry to help sell the story," Zwieg says. "And we'll compete."
One problem IT education faces is that today's students take technology for granted. But having tech-savvy users of technology isn't enough to keep the United States a leader; it needs business-smart people with deep technical understanding of what IT is capable of. Remember, it was engineering students tinkering with what's possible that brought us Google and Yahoo, not a marketing major with a business plan to organize the Internet. "Today's students are less likely to have taken their computer apart than my dad was to have taken apart his tractor," says George Corliss, a computer-engineering professor at Marquette University. "I worry about the builders and the architects of tomorrow."
For IT people who believe in the career, it's time to get vocal to keep the talent pipeline full. Some of the most passionate advocates are women IT pros, stung by research such as CRA's finding that the portion of women considering computer science is at 1970s levels. Their struggle shows it's not an easy sell in the face of global competition and fading excitement for the field. "Coming out of the dot-com bubble in 2000, there's a belief that IT jobs are highly technical, pocket-protector kinds of jobs and not the exciting jobs we really know they are," said Wal-Mart Stores Inc. CIO Linda Dillman at a recent InformationWeek conference; she's involved in efforts to encourage women to participate in IT.
It's easy to see how students come away with that impression. Stephanie Lee, who has known since she was in high school that she wanted to work in IT, is now a sophomore majoring in IT and finance at Marquette University. One of the first IT courses is a beginning programming class, which involves hours on end alone at the computer. "It's a turn-off because people think that's all there is to IT, and there's a lot more than programming," Lee says. "I'd rather be in a team diagnosing problems, not in front of a computer all day."
Dally at Stanford says the IT industry needs to spotlight where the opportunities lie. He doesn't expect a prime-time TV series like CSI or Boston Legal on the IT profession, but he says companies and researchers could do more to show how change-the-world computer apps still await. As an example, he points to the rebirth of artificial intelligence as machines are taught to learn from statistical patterns.
And the industry needs to tackle head-on the question of global competition for IT jobs, acknowledging that young people likely will be collaborating and competing with people around the world. "The future of our students is to work in that global environment," says Corliss, of Marquette, where one professor is teaching an IT class in partnership with an Indian university and another is helping develop a project for a local software company.
The shifting business model with more global development and outsourcing will add complexity to the pace of change and risk. Employment stats paint a picture of fewer programmers and more people who can bridge the gap between business and technology with industry-specific knowledge and project management. Yet even advocates admit there's no way to tell for sure what will drive the industry's future. "Nobody foresaw the change that the Internet would bring," Rockart says. "So I have every reason to suspect we're going to see more of this innovation."
It's a leap of faith, and many smart, experienced IT pros advise against making it. For the believers, it's time to become evangelists.
5 Top Federal Initiatives For 2015As InformationWeek Government readers were busy firming up their fiscal year 2015 budgets, we asked them to rate more than 30 IT initiatives in terms of importance and current leadership focus. No surprise, among more than 30 options, security is No. 1. After that, things get less predictable.
Join us for a roundup of the top stories on InformationWeek.com for the week of December 14, 2014. Be here for the show and for the incredible Friday Afternoon Conversation that runs beside the program.