A noted anti-virus researcher takes the well-known anti-virus company to task for its changing adware definitions. Symantec, meanwhile, claims the high road.
Symantec's out-of-court settlement with an adware maker is a loss for users, an anti-spyware researcher said this week.
Friday, Feb. 24, the Cupertino, Calif. security company announced that it had dismissed its lawsuit against browser and e-mail toolbar maker Hotbar.com, Inc. Last June, Symantec filed a zero-dollar suit against the New York company, saying then that it was seeking a legal ruling that would affirm the position that Hotbar's programs "are indeed adware and can be treated as computer security risks."
Under the new arrangement struck with Hotbar, Symantec has agreed to dismiss the lawsuit but will still classify the company's software as "adware."
Symantec called it a victory.
"What we got out of this was peace from these guys," said Joy Cartun, Symantec's senior director of legal affairs. "We didn't change our detection, so in that way we won."
Hotbar, which had hounded Symantec with at least five litigation threats in the first half of 2005, is now blocked from any further action, said Cartun. "We get them to go away, but without having to make a change in our detection of them [as adware]."
Hotbar's chief executive, however, was convinced that he had won. "Both sides now recognize that our application is disclosing its behavior," said Oren Dobronsky. "We've gained that recognition, so that when users scan for spyware, they don't get some kind of alert and by default, then remove it."
Symantec acknowledged that although its security software will continue to detect Hotbar's products as adware, it has changed the recommendation it gives to customers. Previously, Symantec recommended that users delete Hotbar; now, says Symantec, it's reclassified Hotbar's toolbars as "low-risk" and recommends that users ignore the software and let it be.
"We're telling users what it is, and assisting them to make a choice [whether to keep or remove Hotbar]," argued Symantec's Cartun. She also claimed that Symantec had been thinking of making the change long before Hotbar started complaining.
"The change was driven not by Hotbar, but from what we learned what our customers wanted. They wanted guidance," she said. "The change was on a totally independent track [from the lawsuit]."
Noted anti-spyware researcher Ben Edelman isn't buying that. By backing down on its recommendation from delete to ignore, said Edelman, Symantec's not serving its customers.
"If I was an IT guy paying Symantec to defend my computers, I'd ask 'what are we paying them for, I still see Hotbar on a user's computer,'" said Edelman. "Something's gone wrong at Symantec."
5 Top Federal Initiatives For 2015As InformationWeek Government readers were busy firming up their fiscal year 2015 budgets, we asked them to rate more than 30 IT initiatives in terms of importance and current leadership focus. No surprise, among more than 30 options, security is No. 1. After that, things get less predictable.
InformationWeek Tech Digest, Nov. 10, 2014Just 30% of respondents to our new survey say their companies are very or extremely effective at identifying critical data and analyzing it to make decisions, down from 42% in 2013. What gives?