InformationWeek: The Business Value of Technology

InformationWeek: The Business Value of Technology
InformationWeek Big Data Coverage
= Member Content
Facebook Twitter Share

E-mail | Print | Permalink | LinkedIn | RSS

Microsoft, Google Struggle With New Face Of Collaboration


Microsoft's Office 365 is not the future and neither is Google's Gdocs. But it just might be Facebook or Chatter.




It struck me while getting a demo of Salesforce.com's Chatter app: Facebook's three-panel page layout, dominated by a stream-of-consciousness jumping-off point for comment and discussion, is now the de facto standard for virtually every online collaboration site. As I wrote a couple of months ago when describing business-oriented collaboration services like Podio and Yammer, the next frontier in business communication looks a lot more like Facebook than it does SharePoint. So why does Microsoft, via Office 365, seem more focused on augmenting the traditional Office document and file-sharing paradigm with a cloud back end than on collaborating in the way that's become second nature to hundreds of millions of people?

IT seems to be registering its disapproval: As part of our forthcoming InformationWeek Social Networking in the Enterprise Survey, we asked 394 respondents at organizations using one or more internal social networking systems about vendors in use, then trended results from our August 2010 poll. While Microsoft and Google were No. 1 and No. 2, respectively, in both polls, Microsoft lost eight points year over year, while Google was essentially flat. IBM, in third place, also ticked down a few notches.

Fact is, despite the button-down business crowd's initial, and wholly predictable, dismissiveness that it amounted to little more than MySpace 2.0, Facebook has become the "face" of the Web, with 800 million users and counting. Everyone from corporate CEOs to local coffee shop owners seeking an online presence use it as an alternative to traditional Web sites. And it's changing the nature of collaboration.

By escalating their competitive battle into online productivity apps and recasting old-school productivity software suites as "collaboration tools," Microsoft and Google are violating the maxim to avoid fighting the last war. The notion of building browser-based tools to create elaborately formatted documents that users then share, by email or online document link, with a distinct group of people is completely out of step with today's ethos of wall posts littered with URLs; comment threads; and dynamic, self-organizing groups that often have little in common besides a shared friend--a sort of Kevin Bacon model of group identity with two or three degrees of separation instead of six.

Because technology, like nature, abhors a vacuum, and as my earlier column noted, there's no shortage of companies striving to fill the void as Google and Microsoft persist in shoehorning a '90s client-server collaboration model into the cloud-based social networking era. Which made me wonder: What if Facebook actually embraced the enterprise? And not just by positioning itself as another ad platform (as it's already done), but by enabling people to easily create private or business- or project-based networks and associated work personalities and making it convenient to toggle between two personas and selectively invite other Facebook users (or entire businesses for that matter) into your enterprise social space? This is much bigger than Facebook for Business, which is little more than a storefront using Facebook instead of a traditional website as a marketing platform. Conceptually, it's what Salesforce has done with Chatter, but instead of building on a platform with a couple million users, you're starting with one that's rapidly encompassing everyone in the developed world.

Salesforce gets that. "Facebook has trained 800 million users in how to collaborate, so we wanted to make it [Chatter] as much like Facebook as possible," says Scott Holden, senior director of product marketing for Chatter--which, incidentally, came in at No. 4 on our Social Networking in the Enterprise Survey vendor list in its first outing, with 11% share.

Kurt Marko is an IT pro with broad experience, from chip design to IT systems.


Federal agencies must eliminate 800 data centers over the next five years. Find how they plan to do it in the new all-digital issue of InformationWeek Government. Download it now (registration required).


 1 | 2  | Next Page » 




InformationWeek encourages readers to engage in spirited, healthy debate, including taking us to task. However, InformationWeek moderates all comments posted to our site, and reserves the right to modify or remove any content that it determines to be derogatory, offensive, inflammatory, vulgar, irrelevant/off-topic, racist or obvious marketing/SPAM. InformationWeek further reserves the right to disable the profile of any commenter participating in said activities.

Disqus Tips To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy.
Subscribe to RSS


Advertisement


UC Collaboration Technology Reports

report Beyond Dial Tone: 6 Steps to Wring ROI Out of UC
Unified communications and collaboration represents a significant investment in money and IT resources. It's critical to determine whether your company will benefit from unified communications. Not every organization will. The key is to tackle complexity head on and ensure all stakeholders are fully engaged from the beginning. Our report provides in-depth detail on building an ROI picture for a UC deployment.

report Desktop Videoconferencing: Ready for Its Closeup
The advent of Scalable Video Coding (SVC), which enables the use of the Internet for high-quality desktop videoconferencing, means enterprises can deploy videoconferencing to a majority of workers. Companies that value face-to-face communications can make it happen without breaking the bank. The report also includes exclusive research on IT’s adoption plans for videoconferencing.

report 2012 State of Unified Communications
The good news: The percentage of users who've deployed and are using UC jumped six points, to 36%, since our 2010 survey, and the number of "fence sitters" is down, too. The not-so-good news: For 65%of those who have deployed or plan to do so, UC currently reaches 50% or less of the employee base. What's the holdup?

report Best Practices: Reliable Unified Communications
If your UC infrastructure is erratic or the communications quality poor, you're sunk, because end users today don't have the patience to give IT three or four chances to get it right. And that just adds up to wasted money. In this InformationWeek Best Practices report, we describe strategies to ensure quality communications between end users, whether they're on the LAN, WAN or a mobile device.

report Into the Fold: Mobile Unified Communications Within Reach
IT’s been pushing UC and mobility initiatives on separate tracks. But if either technology is to realize its full potential, CIOs must make integration a priority. In this Strategy Session report, we discuss ways to bring smartphones and tablets into your overall unified communications plan.