Hadoop 2.0 will move beyond batch processing to support interactive, online and streaming applications. But don't let warnings about YARN tie you up in knots.
Hadoop 2.0 will be announced within a matter of days, and a new YARN framework component at its core promises to "take Hadoop beyond MapReduce," according to Arun Murthy, chairman of the Apache committee overseeing the release. Moving beyond slow, iterative MapReduce processing is obviously a good thing, but just what are the new possibilities?
Better SQL querying, graph analysis and stream processing are all on the short list, according to Murthy, a Yahoo veteran who co-founded Hortonworks. He describes YARN (a slightly-off acronym for Yet Another Resource Manager) as a kind of large-scale, distributed operating system for big data applications. As is typical with operating systems, there's some question about what will and what won't work with YARN, but more on that later.
Most Hadoop adopters are treating the platform as a data lake or ocean for all company information, says Murthy, but they want to be able to use the information in multiple ways roughly falling into four categories: batch, interactive, online and streaming.
"As you look through the entire life cycle of that data, and as data is coming in, you want to process it quickly and efficiently and tackle whatever application you have in mind," Murthy says.
SQL is an example where human-interactive queries come in, and that could be through Hive. HBase, the Hadoop NoSQL database, is an online processing option. Storm (developed by Twitter) is a stream-processing option. Apache Giraph is an option for graph analysis. Spark is an option for high-speed, in-memory analytics on top of Hadoop. MPI is a modeling framework used for assessing risk, optimizing pricing and other advanced analytic applications.
And then there are what Murthy calls the "great big honking batch jobs across six, nine or 12 months of data where you're processing hundreds of terabytes or even petabytes of data." That's where MapReduce comes in.
"All of these things have been refactored to work on top of YARN," says Murthy.
Of course Hive, HBase and other options have been available alongside MapReduce for some time, but before Hadoop 2.0, the system was designed to be a single-application system, setting up competition for resources. Run a complex Hive query or one of those great big honking MapReduce jobs and you're likely to lock up resources and prevent any other application from running with anything like predictable performance.
YARN's job is to allocate resources across all the applications running on top of Hadoop to enable them to run simultaneously and with consistent levels of service to end users. This extends to supporting internal or external service-level agreements, quality-of-service standards and administrative control, according to Murthy.
"Instead of having [simplistic] queues for each of your classes of applications, you can decide how much resource you want to give to which class of application," he explains.
The only caveat with YARN is that it's part of the Apache Hadoop framework and is, therefore, designed to allocate resources to Apache Hadoop components. Where does that leave Cloudera Impala, Pivotal HAWQ and the many other SQL-on-Hadoop developments that may or may not become part of Hadoop? In the case of Impala, for example, the core query engine is shipped under Apache license, but Cloudera's Enterprise Real-Time Query (RTQ) management console for Impala is commercial, subscription-based tool.
"It's absolutely conceivable that something like Impala or Pivotal HAWQ could come into the YARN resource-management framework," Murthy says promisingly, but then he adds the caveat.
Speaking as an executive of Hortonworks -- a company that adheres strictly to open-source code and that competes with Cloudera, Pivotal and others adding commercial components to Hadoop -- Murthy warns that "with a bolt-on system like an Impala or a HAWQ, you reinvent everything built into YARN."
With YARN inside Hadoop and a separate management system outside of the platform, the question becomes, which system will control the resources and will these services be duplicative?
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security EnterpriseTo learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
2017 State of IT ReportIn today's technology-driven world, "innovation" has become a basic expectation. IT leaders are tasked with making technical magic, improving customer experience, and boosting the bottom line -- yet often without any increase to the IT budget. How are organizations striking the balance between new initiatives and cost control? Download our report to learn about the biggest challenges and how savvy IT executives are overcoming them.