Book Review: IT's Transformational Effect: The Real Point - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

IoT
IoT
Business & Finance
Commentary
10/29/2004
03:36 PM
John Soat
John Soat
Commentary
50%
50%

Book Review: IT's Transformational Effect: The Real Point

By now, it's well-known what Nicholas Carr meant when he wrote "IT Doesn't Matter." He meant that business technology is rapidly becoming a lowest-cost commodity play that provides--or soon will--no strategic or competitive advantage.

Does IT Matter?: Information Technology And The Corrosion Of Competitive Advantage -- Nicholas CarrCarr set the business-technology world on its ear when he published an article in the Harvard Business Review in May 2003, with the above-mentioned headline. The fact that Carr, a business writer and consultant, has changed the equation from a statement to a question for his book, "Does IT Matter?: Information Technology And The Corrosion Of Competitive Advantage" (Harvard Business School Press, 2004) isn't insignificant, given his earlier unequivocalness. But it's certainly a question worth asking.

In both the article and the book, Carr compares business technology with earlier infrastructure technologies such as electricity or the telephone, arguing that business technology will have the same impact trajectory as those once-revolutionary developments--an earthquakelike shake-up of business processes that eventually settles into a collaborative, level playing field driven by topline, cost-of-doing-business thinking. Given the speed at which the world moves these days, the transformation of business technology into such an infrastructure commodity may happen even faster than previous changes.

Based on Carr's own comparisons, the answer to the question posed by the book's title has to be "yes," because anyone who suffered through last year's late-summer blackout is acutely aware of how much electricity matters. But that's a minor quibble. Carr has a compelling argument, and it deserves serious consideration.

Consider this: "As [IT] becomes cheaper and more standardized, as its power and capabilities begin to outstrip most companies' needs, the advantages it once provided are dissipating, and its great transformational power is starting to fade."

Business technology is indeed (finally) becoming cheap and standardized, which does lend it, or a great deal of it, commodity status, which does mean the competitive advantages it offered when it was expensive and proprietary are dissipating. That much is true and obvious and the reason Carr's original article was so compelling.

But does that necessarily mean business technology's transformational powers are fading? Or is it, instead, that the easy transformations imposed from the outside are almost complete, and that business technology may provide a longer-lasting transformational capability that can be the catalyst for major internal changes? Carr himself hints at that in a statement further on in the book. "Far from being static, the IT architecture continues to change and advance, particularly as vendors and users adapt their systems to the Internet. This fact distinguishes IT from earlier infrastructure technologies, which tended to arrive at a fairly stable architecture relatively early in their development."

In Search Of Business Value: Ensuring A Return On Your Technology Investment -- Robert McDowell and William L. SimonAt the end of the book, Carr says something that strikes me as both obvious and counterintuitive: "The key to success for the vast majority of firms is no longer to seek advantage aggressively [with IT] but to manage costs and risks meticulously." Fair enough. Managing costs and risks meticulously is always a major factor in success. But since when is no longer seeking advantage aggressively the key to success in anything? I don't mean to be disingenuous--I know Carr is saying not to seek business advantage through aggressive investment in IT--but the "follow-the-leader" strategy has proven to be self-destructive so often in the past that it doesn't cut it even as pragmatic advice.

Do you know the story about how, at the turn of the 20th century, the head of the U.S. Patent Office recommended that the office be closed, stating: "Everything that can be invented has already been invented." It's a mostly apocryphal story, points out Robert McDowell, a VP at Microsoft and 25-year IT veteran, in his book "In Search Of Business Value: Ensuring A Return On Your Technology Investment," with William L. Simon (SelectBooks Inc., 2004). But it has passed into collective memory because of its cautionary wisdom. And it serves as an example of McDowell's strongest criticism of the Carr book: dangerously short-sighted.

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
Previous
1 of 2
Next
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
State of the Cloud
State of the Cloud
Cloud has drastically changed how IT organizations consume and deploy services in the digital age. This research report will delve into public, private and hybrid cloud adoption trends, with a special focus on infrastructure as a service and its role in the enterprise. Find out the challenges organizations are experiencing, and the technologies and strategies they are using to manage and mitigate those challenges today.
Slideshows
What Digital Transformation Is (And Isn't)
Cynthia Harvey, Freelance Journalist, InformationWeek,  12/4/2019
Commentary
Watch Out for New Barriers to Faster Software Development
Lisa Morgan, Freelance Writer,  12/3/2019
Commentary
If DevOps Is So Awesome, Why Is Your Initiative Failing?
Guest Commentary, Guest Commentary,  12/2/2019
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
Video
Current Issue
The Cloud Gets Ready for the 20's
This IT Trend Report explores how cloud computing is being shaped for the next phase in its maturation. It will help enterprise IT decision makers and business leaders understand some of the key trends reflected emerging cloud concepts and technologies, and in enterprise cloud usage patterns. Get it today!
White Papers
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Sponsored Video
Flash Poll