Supreme Court Debates Aereo's Fate - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Cloud // Software as a Service
09:50 AM
Connect Directly

Supreme Court Debates Aereo's Fate

Justices seemed to be looking for a way ban Aereo without causing collateral damage to cloud computing.

8 Gadgets For The High-Tech Home
8 Gadgets For The High-Tech Home
(Click image for larger view and slideshow.)

The US Supreme Court on Tuesday heard arguments in American Broadcasting Companies v. Aereo, a case that has the potential to shape the contours of lawful innovation in digital content and cloud computing for years to come. The case pits online TV service Aereo against the television industry.

Aereo allows subscribers to view broadcast TV content through an Internet-connected device, or to store such content for later viewing. The service acts like a cloud-hosted digital video recorder, ruled lawful by an appellate court in the 2008 Cablevision decision, except that it acquires the broadcast TV signal via individual antennas, one for each subscriber.

If Aereo simply rebroadcast TV, it would create a "public performance," which is not allowed under the Copyright Act. But by capturing the broadcast TV signal on behalf of each subscriber through his or her own micro-antenna, the company claims that it is merely providing equipment for each subscriber to receive, record, and time-shift TV lawfully and privately, like other hosted DVR services.

Aereo in short argues that its technology allows massively parallel "private performances," which are allowed under Copyright Law. Broadcasters, who are obligated to provide content for free over public airwaves but collect retransmission fees from cable providers, see Aereo simply as an attempt to bypass copyright law and to avoid paying them.

[Learn why technology, not lawyers, may be your best defense against piracy. See Fight Software Piracy With SaaS.]

The Supreme Court justices who spoke during arguments sounded skeptical of Aereo's position.

"I'm just saying your technological model is based solely on circumventing legal prohibitions that you don't want to comply with, which is fine," said Chief Justice John Roberts to David Frederick, Aereo's attorney. "I mean, that's, you know, lawyers do that." Roberts was asking whether Frederick could provide a rationale for Aereo's decision to employ thousands of antennas other than to avoid liability under the Copyright Act.

Frederick's answer suggested that Aereo is doing what everyone in the cloud computing industry does: providing equipment to process data on behalf of customers. The plaintiff's contention, he said, "that we're somehow a content provider would mean that everybody who provides an antenna or a DVR is somehow a content provider. And if that's true, then the implications for the equipment industry are obviously quite massive and you can understand why that would frighten the cloud computing industry because that turns them into public performers whenever they are handling content."

US Supreme Court
 (Image: Duncan Lock via Wikipedia Commons)
US Supreme Court
(Image: Duncan Lock via Wikipedia Commons)

At the same time, several justices expressed concern that ruling against Aereo could doom the cloud computing industry. Justice Sonia Sotomayor worried that ruling against Aereo might outlaw services like Dropbox and iCloud. "How do I define [a public performance] so that someone who sells coaxial cable to a resident of a building is not swept up as a participant in this?" she asked.

When Justice Elena Kagan asked Malcolm Stewart, deputy solicitor general at the Justice Department, to explain how the argument from the broadcasters' attorney did not imperil cloud computing, Stewart at first suggested the distinction came down to a service that provided new content to users -- Aereo -- and a service that provided access to content the consumers already had. Yet upon further questioning, Stewart acknowledged the distinction isn't always obvious.

"I don't pretend that there is a bright line between providing a service and providing access to equipment," said Stewart.

The problem facing the Supreme Court is that it's not entirely clear what constitutes a public performance in an era when online services

Next Page

Thomas Claburn has been writing about business and technology since 1996, for publications such as New Architect, PC Computing, InformationWeek, Salon, Wired, and Ziff Davis Smart Business. Before that, he worked in film and television, having earned a not particularly useful ... View Full Bio

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
1 of 2
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Thomas Claburn
Thomas Claburn,
User Rank: Author
4/24/2014 | 5:37:04 PM
Re: A decade since the Music industry digital transition, and the television industry still doesn't get it?
>My advice to the television industry: strike now while the iron is still hot and go digital, full on, all the way. 


That's good advice. The media companies not doing this will probably end up being bought in fire sale by some YouTube production company a decade hence.
Thomas Claburn
Thomas Claburn,
User Rank: Author
4/23/2014 | 2:51:13 PM
Re: Content
But is Aereo really redistributing TV content? If it's leasing antennas to subscribers, the subscribers are pulling the content from the public airwaves and storing it in Aereo's cloud service. Would it be any different if Aereo's antennas were on customers' houses? 
InformationWeek Is Getting an Upgrade!

Find out more about our plans to improve the look, functionality, and performance of the InformationWeek site in the coming months.

Becoming a Self-Taught Cybersecurity Pro
Jessica Davis, Senior Editor, Enterprise Apps,  6/9/2021
Ancestry's DevOps Strategy to Control Its CI/CD Pipeline
Joao-Pierre S. Ruth, Senior Writer,  6/4/2021
IT Leadership: 10 Ways to Unleash Enterprise Innovation
Lisa Morgan, Freelance Writer,  6/8/2021
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
Current Issue
Planning Your Digital Transformation Roadmap
Download this report to learn about the latest technologies and best practices or ensuring a successful transition from outdated business transformation tactics.
Flash Poll