DOJ Urges Google Breakup, Targets Chrome, Android and Data Sharing

In what could be the biggest antitrust action since the 1980s telecom breakup, a judge will decide on Google’s future as the most dominant search player in the world.

Shane Snider, Senior Writer, InformationWeek

November 21, 2024

3 Min Read
Google logo artistic concept
GK Images via Alamy Stock

The US Department of Justice on Wednesday pushed for the breakup of Google, calling for the company to sell off its Chrome browser, Android, and other remedies to end its dominance in the online search market.

US prosecutors won their landmark antitrust case against Google in August, when a federal judge ruled that the company ran an illegal monopoly in search and text advertising. US District Court Judge Amit Mehta has scheduled a trial for the potential remedies in April.

Mehta will decide whether to enforce the DOJ’s suggestions, including a ban on Google re-entering the browser market for five years, selling its Android mobile operating system, forcing the company to share its user data with competitors, along with other remedies to restore competition in the sector.

Google says the potential moves are devastating not only to its business, but the broader tech market.

“DOJ’s approach would result in unprecedented government overreach that would harm American consumers, developers, and small businesses -- and jeopardize America’s global economic and technological leadership at precisely the moment it’s needed most,” Kent Walker, Google parent Alphabet’s chief legal officer, said in a statement.

The DOJ argues that Google’s 90% market share in the search engine market was unfairly gained through lucrative multi-billion-dollar deals with Apple and other vendors. Google paid Apple $20 billion in 2022 to be the preferred search engine on its mobile devices. According to its most recent financials, Google’s quarterly revenue, which mostly comes from advertising on its search engine, amounted to $305.6 billion in 2023.

Related:CFPB Presses Forward with Rule to Wrangle Data Brokers

“Google’s unlawful behavior has deprived rivals not only of critical distribution channels but also distribution partners who would otherwise enable entry into these markets by competitors in new and innovative ways,” the DOJ said in its court filing Wednesday.

Second Trump Administration Could Impact Case

The major unknown is how the incoming administration of President-elect Donald Trump will influence the final decision. While the case was first brought under the Trump administration, he has recently signaled that a Google breakup would be going too far.

“A lot of ink has been spilled about the incoming administration’s desire to take a lighter touch when it comes to regulation, but we shouldn’t forget that the investigation, which gave rise to this particular litigation arose under the Trump DOJ, and that big tech … has been a target of both Republican and Democratic politicians,” George Mastoris, co-chair of New York litigation practice at Winston & Strawn law firm, says in an e-mail interview.

Related:FTC to Ban Firms From Selling Sensitive Location Data

A breakup of Google could have far-reaching implications for the tech industry and beyond.

“If the court goes along with the DOJ’s recommendations and orders divestment, that would be a clear shot across corporate America’s bow and an indication that the entire remedial toolbox is in play -- even if the ultimate resolution of the case falls short of so drastic a remedy.” Mastoris says.

But the incoming administration could also take a lighter touch.

“This is likely to be a high variance administration,” Mastoris says. “I think we can likely expect an overall decrease in antitrust scrutiny … At the same time, I wouldn’t be surprised to see continued aggressive antitrust enforcement in the technology and media spheres, although I think the administration will be selective with respect to how they deploy their resources.”

Google stock slid 6.3% in trading by noon on Thursday following the news.

Read more about:

RegulationAntitrust

About the Author

Shane Snider

Senior Writer, InformationWeek

Shane Snider is a veteran journalist with more than 20 years of industry experience. He started his career as a general assignment reporter and has covered government, business, education, technology and much more. He was a reporter for the Triangle Business Journal, Raleigh News and Observer and most recently a tech reporter for CRN. He was also a top wedding photographer for many years, traveling across the country and around the world. He lives in Raleigh with his wife and two children.

Never Miss a Beat: Get a snapshot of the issues affecting the IT industry straight to your inbox.

You May Also Like


More Insights