informa
/
Commentary

ICANN: Reforms Needed Before US Hands Over Control

US Senator Mark Warner (D-Va.) says we must still address questions about accountability and transparency to ensure an open, secure, stable Internet.

The FCC recently received more than 3.7 million comments on its proposed rules to govern how Internet providers will treat traffic on their networks. However, there's another pivotal discussion happening that could turn out to have an even bigger impact on how the Internet will be governed. Much of it boils down to how the international Internet community will oversee web addresses and domain names and how well it will protect the principles of a secure, stable, and open Internet.

ICANN (the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers) is at the heart of this question, as well as the Internet's architecture. ICANN is currently overseen by the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), which is part of the US Department of Commerce. ICANN's charge is to manage the domain name system (DNS) and make sure that, when you type in www.senate.gov, you're actually routed to www.senate.gov.

The NTIA administrator announced in March that it would begin moving control of this architecture to a global, multi-stakeholder community as soon as Sept. 15, 2015, when ICANN's contract with the Department of Commerce is up for renewal. This move would fulfill the NTIA's longtime commitment to making the Internet a truly global resource.

While the move toward governance of the Internet by its users is laudable, many have expressed concerns about the speed of this transition. My strong belief is that 2015 is too soon. This should be a deliberative and democratic process to guarantee that ICANN will remain a neutral body.

Basic questions must still be answered. For example, without the current oversight provided by the US, who will hold ICANN accountable for its decisions? How will the public be informed about how ICANN makes policy? How will its membership be vetted to ensure that nations are represented appropriately, and that technical experts are always present? Following the NTIA's announcement, I wrote a letter to the NTIA expressing some of those concerns. However, questions remain unanswered.

For nearly two decades, the DNS has been a model of reliability -- something all of us take for granted. But if it were to fail to function correctly, it would be a disaster. It's imperative that the NTIA use its oversight capabilities to see that ICANN adopts real reforms with clear enforcement and dispute-resolution mechanisms. ICANN needs to demonstrate that it is ready -- and that it will remain a capable, responsive, and independent guardian of the Internet's infrastructure long into the future -- before the NTIA turns over the keys.

To ensure that ICANN is able to fulfill its responsibilities, major expert and industry groups have endorsed common-sense reforms. The International Chamber of Commerce, the Center for Democracy and Technology, and the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, among others, advocate for placing ultimate authority over ICANN and the DNS in the hands of the global multi-stakeholder community. This broad coalition also supports enacting strong protections against foreign governments that may want to take control of the Internet, such as preventing government officials from serving on ICANN's boards or staff. We also should insist on enforcing transparency through independent audits and the publication of meeting transcripts. Taken together, these proposed reforms represent a thoughtful, comprehensive approach to transferring responsibility to ICANN.

As the transfer of authority moves forward, my Senate colleagues and I will be watching to see that the proposal sent to the NTIA implements strong reforms like these. Otherwise, we will urge that it go back to the drawing board.

It doesn't matter whether your e-commerce D-Day is Black Friday, tax day, or some random Thursday when a post goes viral. Your websites need to be ready. Get the new Battle-Tested Websites issue of InformationWeek Tech Digest today (free registration required).