Yesterday, for example, Bill Snyder in PC World's BizFeed said a small business would be "wasting money and brain cells" on a iSlate because "itï¿¼s going to be too expensive, it does things you donï¿¼t need to do, and it will add a messy layer of complication to your company's computing infrastructure."
First, I'm not sure how Bill knows what the price of the iSlate will be. He mentions "$1,000 or so," which has indeed been mentioned in some speculation and which, I agree, would be kind of steep. But most speculation has centered around a price point of $600-800, somewhere between an iPhone and a MacBook Pro. Picking the highest rumored price and labeling the tablet too expensive on that basis is stacking the deck.
As for what it does, Bill seems to be comparing it to a desktop computer, saying, for example, that "Itï¿¼s quite likely that the iSlate will use an on-screen keyboard. Thatï¿¼s fine for a quick text message or a short e-mail, but what a crummy way to do any real data entry." Yes, it is. I agree that if Apple positions the tablet as a tool for high-volume data entry, they're making a mistake.
Apple will not position the tablet as a tool for data entry.
He goes on to say that "Itï¿¼s no accident that business people who rely on a phone for heavy email access still tend to use a Blackberry or other smartphone with a physical keyboard." Could that change, though? Bill's been writing about technology as long as I have, and I doubt that either of us would have predicted how comfortable people would get with entering text using eight keys on a phone, pressing keys multiple times to get one letter. I watch my teenage son switch effortlessly from texting on his phone to IMing on his iPod Touch, and I'm not sure the next generation of businesspeople is going to share Bill's and my need for a physical QWERTY keyboard. And for those of us who do still have that need, one of the latest rumors is that the iSlate will have a dock to support peripherals -- an idea I've brought up before -- and/or will support a BlueTooth keyboard.
So if you're not going to do data entry or heavy text editing on the iSlate, what will it be good for? In my opinion, there are at least three business uses for which an iSlate would be superior to the current choices for a business computer: