Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together - InformationWeek

InformationWeek is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Healthcare // Electronic Health Records
09:51 AM

Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together

Doctors who dictate their clinical notes before they're entered into an EHR have lower quality of care scores than those who type or enter structured data directly into the EHR, according to Partners Healthcare researchers.

12 EHR Vendors That Stand Out
12 EHR Vendors That Stand Out
(click image for larger view and for slideshow)
Switching to an electronic health record (EHR) doesn't always improve quality of care. To understand why, researchers at Partners Healthcare in Boston analyzed the different ways that doctors, using the same EHR, document their care. They found that physicians who predominantly dictated their notes had lower quality scores than those who typed their notes or used drop-down check boxes to enter their findings in a structured format.

In their study, published in the Journal of the Medical Informatics Association (JAMIA), the researchers examined records of 7,000 visits to 234 primary care doctors in the Partners system over a nine-month period. All of the patients who made these visits had coronary artery disease (CAD), diabetes mellitus (DM), or both. The study looked at how well their physicians did on 15 measures of quality in treating these conditions and then correlated that with their method of documentation.

Of the physicians in the study, 9% mainly dictated their notes, 29% predominantly used structured documentation, and 62% typed their notes as free text in the EHR. While there were mixtures of these styles, a physician was classified as a user of dictation or a user of structured data entry if he or she utilized that method more than 25% of the time.

[ Is it time to re-engineer your clinical decision support system? See 10 Innovative Clinical Decision Support Programs. ]

Overall, quality of care was worse for physicians who used dictation than for those who used the other two approaches. The dictating doctors came out below the other groups on three of the 15 measures, while structured-entry doctors surpassed the other cohorts on three measures. On none of the metrics did dictation users get better scores than the other physicians did.

The researchers offered two explanations for these results. First, they said, physicians who used structured EHR templates to document their findings were less likely to miss necessary steps in patient care than were doctors who dictated. Second, physicians who interacted with the EHR--rather than simply dictating notes that would be placed in it later--had the benefit of clinical decision support tools imbedded in the EHR.

One of the most striking findings in the study was that less than a third of the EHR users entered structured data. Such a result might be expected in a physician group that had only recently switched from paper to electronic records. But Partners Healthcare has been using its homegrown EHR, known as the Longitudinal Medical Record (LMR), for many years. So what the research found was not the result of inexperience with the EHR, but of physicians' longstanding, ingrained resistance to clinical data entry.

Indeed the JAMIA study discovered that, of the three groups, the physicians who used structured documentation methods were the least satisfied with their note-taking method.

The main reason why so many of the physicians didn't enter structured data in EHRs is that "it slows them down," said Mark Anderson, a health IT consultant based in Montgomery, Texas. His own research among clients indicates that it takes physicians nine times longer to document visits in EHR templates than it takes them to dictate the same notes.

Consequently, he said, dictation remains a major data-entry method in many practices that use EHRs. In fact, medical transcription services have seen no downturn in their business due to the growth of EHR adoption, he noted.

In most cases, physicians "don't need the data [in their documentation]," Anderson said. "They just want to get the note done. Physicians need lab results, pharmacy, nursing notes, social history, and so on. The doctors don't put any of that in. The results come from the lab. They may do electronic prescribing--but that's not notes, it's orders. Compared to the amount of time required to enter structured data, it's much quicker to dictate, and it's probably two or three times as quick to type it in."

Get the new, all-digital Healthcare CIO 25 issue of InformationWeek Healthcare. It's our second annual honor roll of the health IT leaders driving healthcare's transformation. (Free registration required.)

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
12/9/2014 | 1:41:08 PM
re: Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together
It still seems like having sophisticated NLP and Data Mining to characterize clinical documentation (post dictation and typing) remains a priority. This study is not surprising because it makes sense that physicians want to be able to provide good care and not be focused on selecting from drop down lists or try to keep correcting their dictation mistakes (speech to text mistakes are superbly annoying!). Computer algorithms when developed for this specific task are capable of auto populating those structured fields from all that unstructured data. 

Kavita Ganesan

User Rank: Strategist
5/29/2012 | 3:21:13 AM
re: Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together
I've watched doctors use EHR systems. One actually walked me through everything he entered. Ignoring the mediocrity of the system (in that it asked a hand surgeon questions about his male patient's 'female parts'), he went through piles of checklists - carefully, and entered in notes by hand, and confirmed that the attached xrays were appropriate and properly interpreted. The system had issues, but I was quite satisfied as to his use of the system, including the level of detail and the accuracy. I've listened to other doctors do dictation and watched it being transcribed - end result is a complete lack of precision and lots of errors, and nothing that a diagnostic support system could use.
User Rank: Apprentice
5/25/2012 | 8:39:07 PM
re: Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together
Check out this blog post: "Missing Link: Is it Scribe or Usability?" http://bit.ly/no8yew
User Rank: Apprentice
5/25/2012 | 1:48:08 AM
re: Dictation And EHRs Don't Play Well Together
Many practices I work with do a hybrid of dictation and click through. Often times the MA (or a scribe) will do the structured data clicking and then the physician will review and add his personal 2 cents via Dragon Medical within the EHR free text fields. It's the best of both worlds for the physician who doesn't want a "computer sounding" note -- and the compliance report people, who need that structured data to comply with the ever growing requirements.

Whenever I train a physician, one of the first things I say is "it'll never be as easy as straight dictation..." -- right after I say "don't shoot the messenger. " :)

InformationWeek contributor
Will AI and Machine Learning Break Cloud Architectures?
Lisa Morgan, Freelance Writer,  6/10/2019
9 Steps Toward Ethical AI
Cynthia Harvey, Freelance Journalist, InformationWeek,  5/15/2019
Humans' Fascination with Artificial General Intelligence
Guest Commentary, Guest Commentary,  6/6/2019
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
Current Issue
A New World of IT Management in 2019
This IT Trend Report highlights how several years of developments in technology and business strategies have led to a subsequent wave of changes in the role of an IT organization, how CIOs and other IT leaders approach management, in addition to the jobs of many IT professionals up and down the org chart.
Flash Poll