Doctors Push Back Against Health IT's Workflow Demands
Doctors are angry that accountable care organization workflows seem more like manufacturing, less like healthcare, say panelists at eHealth Initiative conference.
7 Portals Powering Patient Engagement
(click image for larger view and for slideshow)
There's a powerful force working against the spread of health IT: physician anger, as doctors resist adopting workflows that can feel to them more like manufacturing than traditional treatment.
This was one of several big ideas explored during a panel discussion at the eHealth Initiatives annual conference in Orlando, Fla. Anger within the physician community is creating "significant backlash" in furthering the use of health IT within an accountable care environment, said Simeon Schwartz, MD, president and CEO at Westmed Medical Group, one of the panelists.
Schwartz was joined by Keith Hepp, CEO at non-profit HealthBridge, and Matt Hoffman, medical informatics manager at Utah Health Information Network (UHIN), in a panel titled "Current Health IT Practices in Accountable Care." But the focus quickly shifted to challenges healthcare organizations face under federal accountable care organization (ACO) rules with regard to the implementation of IT to drive down costs and changing physicians' mindsets.
"We understand now that we have to change workflows," said Schwartz. "Physicians have to put in pathways of care that look more and more like manufacturing in terms of accountability." Schwartz said organizations need to transition from a guild-like mindset to that of a "manufacturing organization," where physicians can use their skills in combination with data at the point of care. When that happens, Schwartz said, "that change is going to be profound."
The resistance to changing workflows among physicians was echoed by Hoffman. ACOs move healthcare from a workflow model to where it's the physician's job to treat a disease as quickly as possible. "If they can get information from IT ... then they can intervene and get treatment as soon as possible," he said. This also enables physicians to prevent large-scale events, such as heart attacks, that cost money, Hoffman said.
Hoffman added that behavioral change is a key factor in the use of health information exchanges in meeting accountable care requirements. Physicians aren't quick to connect their electronic medical records to an HIE, he said, since "they don't get a lot after that." Instead, physicians and clinics need to have incentives to connect these tools and, at the same time, be shown how connected data can result in better and easier care for patients. "We're working with physicians to show them there is benefit," he said. "But there is resistance to changing workflows."
Patient engagement remains a prominent challenge facing organizations trying to meet accountable care standards as well. The process for caring for patients is broken, said Schwartz. When it comes to addressing workflow issues and patient involvement, "you can fix as many pieces as you want, but until you bring those pieces together into a new workflow, that won't change the patient experience ... Experience isn't synonymous with customer service, and it's not synonymous with IT or doctors or providers." Instead, he said, the patient experience should be centered on solving problems, which occurs when "we're direct with [patients], and that's where we're failing," Schwartz said.
Instead of presenting patients with clear, timely information in regard to diagnoses, for example, said Schwartz, physicians tend to sugar-coat. However, in a day and age when patients can turn to alternative means of gathering information, like the Internet, it's pertinent that a patient-physician exchange meet the new, more direct demands of the patient. "We're [still] not creating the experience they want," Schwartz said.
Can data analysis keep students on track and improve college retention rates? Also in the premiere all-digital Analytics' Big Test issue of InformationWeek Education: Higher education is just as prone to tech-based disruption as other industries. (Free with registration.)
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security EnterpriseTo learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
IT Strategies to Conquer the CloudChances are your organization is adopting cloud computing in one way or another -- or in multiple ways. Understanding the skills you need and how cloud affects IT operations and networking will help you adapt.