Feds Test Patient E-Consent For HIEs - InformationWeek
Healthcare // Analytics
08:32 PM

Feds Test Patient E-Consent For HIEs

For health information exchanges to gain a foothold in the U.S., patients need to get on board. A recent pilot project spearheaded by the Office of the National Coordinator of Health IT leads the way.

8 Health Information Exchanges Lead The Way
8 Health Information Exchanges Lead The Way
(click image for larger for slideshow)
With the advent of new healthcare delivery models, electronic health information exchanges (HIEs) have suddenly taken on a heightened importance in the aggregation of patient data for care coordination and population health management. Yet there are no uniform standards for obtaining patient consent for HIEs to share their individually identifiable health information (IIHI) outside of direct patient care.

Over the past 18 months, the Office of the National Coordinator of Health IT (ONC) has tried to fill this gap by developing educational materials and forms to give patients a "meaningful choice" on HIE use of their personal health information. On Oct. 22, ONC launched a month-long field test of these materials and the use of computer tablets to obtain electronic consent from patients. ONC officials described details of the pilot in an exclusive interview with InformationWeek Healthcare.

The test is taking place in the Buffalo, N.Y., area. Participating in the pilot are the HealtheLink HIE and four physician offices, including two primary care and two specialty care sites in urban, suburban and rural areas. Among the practices involved are Trinity Medical, Buffalo Cardiology and Pulmonary Associates, Family Health Medical Services, and Rheumatology Consultants of Western New York.

The tablets in the practice sites are loaded with an ONC video and educational materials tailored to HealtheLink and each practice's participation in the HIE. After viewing the content, patients are asked whether they want to "opt in" to allow the HIE to use their data for purposes other than direct exchanges between treating providers, which are permitted under HIPAA regulations.

[ Is it time to re-engineer your Clinical Decision Support system? See 10 Innovative Clinical Decision Support Programs. ]

"Patients will use the tablet to review interactive educational material, and they can electronically choose whether to allow their information to be used in health information exchange," said Kathryn Marchesini, a senior analyst and advisor to ONC's chief privacy officer.

The patients' choices are stored remotely on HealtheLink's server, so no personal health information resides on the tablet in the physician office, she explained. Providers who are seeking information on the patient can see what the patient's preference is through the HIE, which also notifies the patient's own physician about whether the patient has opted in or not.

The purposes of the test are to see how well patients understand the educational content and how well the technology enables the e-consent process. ONC expects to have the results by next spring. After that, Marchesini said, ONC plans to disseminate the materials to providers and HIEs, including the statewide HIEs that have received ONC grants.

"Ideally, we're hoping to provide an open source tool that we can publicly make available for anyone to download and use in their environment," Marchesini said. "We realize that each HIE is unique, and there are some special local and state laws that may vary, and some nuances of wording may have to be worked through. But we hope that the materials we piloted can be leveraged by HIEs across the country."

ONC has issued an official guidance to the statewide HIE grantees about how to obtain "meaningful" consent, which can be done through either the opt-in or opt-out models. To be meaningful, the document says, the choice must be:

--Made with advance knowledge/time

--Not used for discriminatory purposes or as a condition for receiving medical treatment

--Made with full transparency and education

--Commensurate with circumstances for why IIHI is exchanged

--Consistent with patient expectations

--Revocable at any time.

Marchesini emphasized that having patients sign a "boilerplate form" or relying on them going to a website is not meaningful choice. "We're focusing on engaging the patient in an interactive manner so they understand the options they have."

She added that using paper forms is not an efficient way to obtain patient consent in the context of electronic information exchange.

The issue of meaningful consent in HIEs has become a front-burner issue for many healthcare organizations. John Halamka, the CIO of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, recently told InformationWeek Healthcare that BIDMC had decided to have its 1,800 ambulatory care providers ask their patients to opt in for data sharing among the clinicians coordinating their care.

InformationWeek Healthcare brought together eight top IT execs to discuss BYOD, Meaningful Use, accountable care, and other contentious issues. Also in the new, all-digital CIO Roundtable issue: Why use IT systems to help cut medical costs if physicians ignore the cost of the care they provide? (Free with registration.)

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Ken Terry
Ken Terry,
User Rank: Apprentice
11/7/2012 | 4:21:06 PM
re: Feds Test Patient E-Consent For HIEs
In response to Deborah Peel's comment, John Halamka is not associated with Partners Healthcare. He is CIO of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center.

Re: Partners' policy, I'm not sure what their reasoning is. If technically possible, it would be preferable to allow patients to segment sensitive and non-sensitive data for purposes of health information exchange. But I think your point about patients being "coerced" to give consent for exchange of future data is off base for two reasons: First, meaningful consent, under ONC guidelines, would allow patients to revoke their permission in the future. Second, if you don't allow future exchanges, the value of health IT for care coordination would be destroyed.
dpeel, md787
dpeel, md787,
User Rank: Apprentice
11/1/2012 | 7:37:59 PM
re: Feds Test Patient E-Consent For HIEs
How bizzare that John Halamka, CIO is pressing for opt-in consent to protect patients---at the same time that Partners Healthcare System has eliminated patients' strong rights under MA law to give specific consent before mental health records can be disclosed to anyone--including other doctors.

Broad, opt-in 'consent' for future disclosures of PHI is not only coerced---but is blatantly unethical and illegal because no one can 'meaningfully' consent to future disclosures of ANY data that does not yet exist. It's impossible.

The Partners' system written policy is that all mental health records will be merged with general medical records, destroying the privacy of that information forever.

See "Julie" a lawyer treated for years in the Partners' System talk about Partners Healthcare system, has not allowed her to exercise her federal, Constitutional, and state rights to control who can see her sensitive records of abuse as a child.

Julie spoke at the 2nd International Summit on the Future of Health Privacy last June, see her 11 minute video at: http://tiny.cc/5n03mw

Deborah C. Peel, MD
Founder and Chair, Patient Privacy Rights
User Rank: Apprentice
10/30/2012 | 2:18:07 AM
re: Feds Test Patient E-Consent For HIEs
It's nice to see the Feds providing opensource tools to be used for HIEs to help ease the cost burden of development for organizations. I agree that in the age of electronic communications and EHRs that we must move off of paper consent forms and into an era of e-consent forms. The real question is whether or not the patients are ready to move to a platform like that.

Jay Simmons
InformationWeek Contributor
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
To learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Digital Transformation Myths & Truths
Transformation is on every IT organization's to-do list, but effectively transforming IT means a major shift in technology as well as business models and culture. In this IT Trend Report, we examine some of the misconceptions of digital transformation and look at steps you can take to succeed technically and culturally.
Twitter Feed
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll