Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems - InformationWeek
Government // Mobile & Wireless
05:55 PM
Connect Directly

Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems

As companies push virtualization to more--and more essential--systems, things are getting complicated.

At Fair Isaac, the company that generates the FICO scores that decide many consumers' creditworthiness, virtualization has brought a lot of good--and some unexpected problems.

Fair Isaac has virtualized 70% of its servers, taking 5,000 boxes down to 1,500, reducing capital and power expenses. Furthermore, it used to employ one system administrator for every 30 to 50 servers; now it's one for every 150. "We'll be able to push that number as far as 250," says Tom Grahek, VP of IT. Fair Isaac has been able to run an average of 30 virtual machines per server and still consume only half of its available CPU cycles, Grahek says. His team can now provision a new Web server, database server, and application server in 30 minutes--"a process that used to be measured in weeks," he says--and decommission them just as fast.

Therein is part of the problem. That ease of provisioning has "created the perception that virtual servers are free," Grahek says. It used to be IT's decision whether to grant the request for server capacity, since those weeks of lead time provided a natural gatekeeper. Now Fair Isaac's IT team has put server templates in a catalog from which business unit end users can commission capacity themselves. The IT organization measures server use and charges that back to the business unit, so the line-of-business manager sees the cost and who's using the capacity.

"You're taking the power of IT and handing it over" to people in the best position to decide how to allocate it, Grahek says. Having overcome the "virtual servers are free" mentality, Grahek has a new goal for server virtualization: "We're pushing toward 100%."

Some 51% of companies have virtualized half or more of their workloads, our recent InformationWeek VMware vSphere 5 Survey of 410 business technology professionals finds. But that's also increasing the complexity--in how IT operates, but also in interactions with business managers, as Fair Isaac learned.

Virtualization keeps expanding: 63% of companies plan to have half or more of their servers virtualized by the end of 2012, according to InformationWeek's 2011 Virtualization Management Survey of 396 business technology pros. Production systems, once off limits, are now routinely virtualized to allow for more flexible management--to improve availability, load balance to meet peak demands, and provide easier disaster recovery. Virtualizing database systems is still rare, especially for transaction processing, but some shops are pushing ahead. "There's no technical reason not to," says Jay Corn, Accenture's North American lead for infrastructure and consolidation. "We have successfully virtualized Oracle database servers. There's never been data issues associated with it."

But as virtualization gets more intense, it ripples change throughout the data center. Virtual machines stacked 10 to 20 deep on a host server can generate a lot of I/O traffic. When those VMs include databases, the network has to accommodate many calls to disk, along with the normal SAN data storage and Ethernet communications traffic. That's uncovering what may be the data center's next big bottleneck. Whereas IT organizations used to be constrained by CPU cycles and even memory, now restraint has moved out to the edge of the server, to the I/O ports and nearby network devices.

"Heavily virtualized servers, still using legacy networks and storage, are choking on I/O," Corn says. That means 1-Gbps Ethernet switching is proving inadequate with the denser concentrations of virtual machines; time to upgrade to 10-Gbps devices. The network is lagging as a virtualized resource, and it likely will continue to lag until a new generation of switches materializes, possibly based on the OpenFlow protocol, that can treat the network as a pooled and configurable resource. (See for more.)

Despite the complexity virtualization can cause, IT leaders can't afford a wait-and-see approach to expanding it. Yes, management software and standards are likely to improve, especially for cross-platform virtualization, which is a dicey move today (see "Private Clouds: Tough To Build With Today's Tech"). But IT teams are showing how they can push past technical and organizational problems now.

Diversity Breeds Complexity

Our full report on virtualization management is free with registration.

This report includes 41 pages of action-oriented analysis packed with 21 charts. What you'll find:
  • Data on virtualization use, from VMs per servers to what drives adoption
  • Data on plans for virtualization
Get This And All Our Reports

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
1 of 3
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Strategist
11/2/2011 | 6:21:48 PM
re: Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems
There's no question that virtualization is causing changes in the data center. My suggestion is read the story carefully and see what it says about those changes. If you don't like the headline, the headline is not the whole story.
Jon Toor
Jon Toor,
User Rank: Apprentice
11/2/2011 | 1:46:39 AM
re: Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems
The problems the author identifies are 100% real in highly virtualized data centers.

Virtualized servers need more I/O connections, more bandwidth, and more flexibility. Hooking them up with traditional I/O is like driving an Indy car on city streets. Sure the old technology will work, but you're not going to get optimal performance.

Rparker905 seems to take offense at the suggestion of a problem with virtualization itself, but this is actually quite the opposite. Virtualization is a game changer. It's already changed how we deploy and manage servers. It's re-defining the concept of the fixed 3-tier data center. So it's only logical that it would drive a fresh look at the infrastructure.

Vendors are responding to a growing market need: How do we make the rest of the data center as fast and flexible as the servers themselves? Not everyone has that need yet. But if you're virtualizing, you will.
User Rank: Apprentice
10/31/2011 | 6:16:26 PM
re: Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems
Next wave of problems? What to do with all the money and time saved....
User Rank: Apprentice
10/31/2011 | 3:46:18 PM
re: Virtualization's Next Wave Of Problems
I think its really starting to hurt Information Week's credibility when it continues to write sensationalized National Enquirer style misleading marketing driven headlines and articles
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Top IT Trends for 2018
As we enter a new year of technology planning, find out about the hot technologies organizations are using to advance their businesses and where the experts say IT is heading.
Twitter Feed
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll