informa
/
News

How To Remotely Monitor Memory Usage

Adding extra RAM when your machine doesn't really need it is pointless. Here's how to tell when it's time.
Monitoring memory on UNIX-based systems with Cacti is easy; just add Net-SNMP to your systems. Windows systems are much more complicated.

This is because Windows only provides a handful of default readings through SNMP. The rest of the data is available only through WMI, the platform-specific management interface for Windows. Although Cacti on Windows is able to read WMI data directly, Cacti on UNIX only has access to SNMP and scripts. In other words, the memory readings that we need for Windows are not published to XP’s SNMP agent, but are only published to WMI.

So, reading WMI data requires that you either put a WMI agent on your Cacti box, expose the WMI data through SNMP on the managed system itself, or use some kind of middleware gateway.

In my case, I chose to convert the WMI data to SNMP by using Informant Systems' SNMP Informant Advanced. Informant Systems has a variety of SNMP extension sub-agents that can expose a large amount of WMI data through SNMP. This includes not just the operating system details, but also Microsoft Exchange data, hardware data, and more.

Informant also has a free extension agent that will expose basic system information, and another one that exposes Motherboard Monitor hardware readings. (You can read more about this subject here).

Using this WMI data gathered by Informant, my Windows-specific Cacti script is able to read the same kind of data as it gets from Net-SNMP on UNIX, and is able to calculate the same basic output. My Cacti template and PHP script for Windows can be found here.

Here is what the memory usage on my VMware GSX server looks like, with four VMs running:

Rhino

(click image for larger view)

The 4 GB of system RAM is almost entirely used by VMware and the operating system, with very little memory being wasted on disk cache, and almost no swap space being consumed. This is a good thing. However, given how the memory is being consumed by these four VMs, I probably need to add another couple of gigabytes to give myself some more headroom.

By comparison, here is what the memory usage on an old P3 server looks like:

Omega

(click image for larger view)

That system provides some basic network services like printing and backup, and also runs a Squid proxy server under Microsoft’s Services for UNIX (the POSIX translation subsystem). Although it appears that there is lots of leftover RAM available, the relatively large amount of allocated swap space shows that the system is struggling mightily and more memory is drastically needed. Unfortunately, that motherboard can’t hold any more RAM, so it looks like I’ll finally donate the thing to the local school system instead.

Obviously, being able to monitor and visualize actual memory consumption can yield a tremendous amount of insight into the actual utilization of your different systems. This leads to more informed conclusions about how to get the most bang for your memory dollars. While RAM may be cheap, it's not always needed, and adding more memory when it won’t actually do anything is simply wasted time, money, and effort.