iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

About Us

Advertise

Oldest First | Newest First | Threaded View

[close this box]

50%

TerryB,
User Rank: Ninja
7/12/2012 | 5:56:57 PM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

Chris, this is one of those stories where more detail would have been very helpful. For example, where did the app in Apple Store to access Proficy come from? Did GE write it? What non GE software did they use? Were the engineering drawings AutoCAD stuff or simple PDF documents? How does the iPad authenticate to their server where these drawings are stored? What is their server security, Microsoft AD or something else?

Those are kind of things which matter, at least here. That is why we don't use Mac's here for desktops because MS is on the servers and you want the domain security out of the box. I'm sure there are ways Mac's can work with AD but what is the point (business payoff) of adding that level of support just so you can use a Mac? Does Apple let you enter or retrieve server data any faster than Windows PC's?

The real test is coming when Windows tablets come out. Then you would think they would participate in AD and behave like a mobile Windows desktop, assuming you have Windows servers holding your documents and data. But I have not seen any detail that Win Tablets will be AD domain computers, all the early stuff I've read aimed at consumers who don't care.

Also curious whether cheaper Android tablets would have worked just as well as iPads for GE. What can't Android do that GE needed? Is there only Proficy app for iPad? If so, why?

But you are right on, many of us involved in shop floor IT support are watching very closely how we can apply these highly mobile tablets and phones. Hopefully you can follow up on this GE project at later time and see if all worked out for them.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

GAProgrammer,
User Rank: Ninja
7/12/2012 | 6:54:16 PM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

I agree more detail would have been nice, but GE may not have been forthcoming about the details. Currently there is no way to integrate iPads with AD - that's why IT is all abuzz about the Surface Pro.

To me, the interesting part is that all of these things could have been done before with laptops but they didn't do that. Also, they could probably do the same things on Android tablets, assuming there is an app that does the interfacing. However, the industry would likely write apps for iDevices as they are the primary tablet market at this point and let's face it - no one wants to monitor industrial equipment on a smartphone.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

ChrisMurphy,
User Rank: Author
7/12/2012 | 7:40:14 PM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

Fair point, TerryB, more would be better. I do know it is GE's iPad app, not a third party. I don't know the other answers, those were passing references to the other software platforms and I didn't dig in on those in limited interview time. I'll post if I learn more.

Re iPad v. Android tablets -- i didn't ask about why not Android. But remember, this is not only for GE's internal factory use, GE is in the software business. GE is developing an Android app. But by choosing to do an iPad app first, it's making a call -- tells me GE thinks iPads are what's most likely to get used on the factory floor right now. That in itself is pretty interesting.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

ChrisMurphy,
User Rank: Author
7/12/2012 | 9:37:37 PM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

Here's what Prasad Pai, product manager for GE's HMI/SCADA products, says in response to the comments earlier. (Pai was going to post directly but hit a glitch, so just emailed to me). From Pai:

"Yes, we built the ProficySCADA iPad app using some third-party technologies and made it tightly wrapped around GE Intelligent PlatformsG�� SCADA products. Unless content like AutoCAD drawings or PDF documents are accessed via these products, the app does not allow for independent software access. The iPad app is an extension of our web-based SCADA offerings G�� WebSpace and GlobalView so the authentication is taken care by the servers that host the various client connections. Users can have a free mix of Web and iPad clients going through the same server so if they want to use AD (Active Directory) for authentication, they are free to configure that on their servers and the iPad app will honor that authentication.

"Regarding the comment on Gǣno one wants to monitor industrial equipment on a smart phone,Gǥ I think the definition of monitoring has changed over the years. Monitoring does not mean constantly supervising equipment anymore. With reducing workforce and increasing workload, getting a quick status update of critical equipment is getting to be the norm. So, I agree that no one would want to operate equipment through smartphones all the time, but there is an increasing trend of Gǣstaying withGǥ their operations wherever they go."

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

stahmasebi9211,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/13/2012 | 8:38:28 PM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

A company can create their own in-house iOS app and have it distributed only to employees wirelessly also.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

AS71,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/16/2012 | 2:01:50 AM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

I doubt GE uses AD. People will be, should be, moving towards a standards based LDAP server which can work outside of Windows. I would think GE is a large enough org where AD was never practical for their scale, heterogeneity, and security standards. Generally the major companies use IBM Tivoli Identity and Access Manager or Sun/Oracle.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

50%

AS71,
User Rank: Apprentice
7/16/2012 | 2:26:33 AM

re: iPads In Factories: Early Lessons From GE

Yes, AD is a Microsoft proprietary product. It is used to sell Windows. If companies are running an LDAP server which can only integrate with one OS, they should look at changing their LDAP server (as the whole idea is to have a common access and identity standard across platforms) instead of limiting themselves to one platform forever.

Reply | Post Message | Messages List | Start a Board

Reports

The State of Cloud Computing - Fall 2020

Download this report to compare how cloud usage and spending patterns have changed in 2020, and how respondents think they'll evolve over the next two years.

Download Now!

More Reports