Follow IW:
Comments
Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
Re: Yawn...
I think you're bringing up a noteworthy distinction, UberGoober. There are a ton of iPads in the enterprise, but a lot of them are used as secondary devices for information access, as you say. One of the big research firms (Forrester, if I remember) even did a study that drew that conclusion-- that iPads are often used alongside, rather than in place of, traditional PCs.
That said, I'm astonished how often I see people typing on their iPads. At every event I attend, I see journalists and analysts typing away on glass screens. Not just shorthand notes—full paragraphs, often punched out at a surprisingly quick rate. Personally, I still want a physical keyboard in situations like that-- and indeed, conventional laptops (albeit with a higher-than-average MacBook representation) are still far more ubiquitous at those events. But it's clear that people are increasingly using tablets for content creation. I don't think there will be a tipping point where touchscreens takes over for "real work," or that physical keyboards are going away, or anything like that—but I've heard analysts say that more words will be typed this year on glass than on actual keys. I'm not sure if I believe that, but the fact that it's even close tells you that tablets are being used for more than watching videos. (Though I concede a lot of those words will be dedicated to vapid text messages and Facebook status updates on smartphones.)
For productivity tasks that require quick exchanges or that involve moving or slightly modifying information, tablets can actually be preferable to traditional form factors. I'm not going to get rid of my computers any time soon; I need them for substantive writing, spreadsheets, video and photo editing, and other tasks that don't tablets very well. But I think the "content consumption vs. productivity" debate involves a lot of rigid definitions about what constitutes "real work" and what doesn't. There are shades of gray, and tablets occupy lots of them.
That said, I'm astonished how often I see people typing on their iPads. At every event I attend, I see journalists and analysts typing away on glass screens. Not just shorthand notes—full paragraphs, often punched out at a surprisingly quick rate. Personally, I still want a physical keyboard in situations like that-- and indeed, conventional laptops (albeit with a higher-than-average MacBook representation) are still far more ubiquitous at those events. But it's clear that people are increasingly using tablets for content creation. I don't think there will be a tipping point where touchscreens takes over for "real work," or that physical keyboards are going away, or anything like that—but I've heard analysts say that more words will be typed this year on glass than on actual keys. I'm not sure if I believe that, but the fact that it's even close tells you that tablets are being used for more than watching videos. (Though I concede a lot of those words will be dedicated to vapid text messages and Facebook status updates on smartphones.)
For productivity tasks that require quick exchanges or that involve moving or slightly modifying information, tablets can actually be preferable to traditional form factors. I'm not going to get rid of my computers any time soon; I need them for substantive writing, spreadsheets, video and photo editing, and other tasks that don't tablets very well. But I think the "content consumption vs. productivity" debate involves a lot of rigid definitions about what constitutes "real work" and what doesn't. There are shades of gray, and tablets occupy lots of them.
Re: Yawn...
I guess we will have to agree to disagree. Bluetooth keyboards and cases like Zagg with built in keyboard (have you tried? really great) mean you do not have to type on tablet screen. I know lots and lots of sales people who do almost all work on a tablet. Not just sales, either. Varies by industry but even in insurance...lots of tablets. core apps running on tablets. Talk to these CIOs: It is not optional.
Re: Yawn...
Interesting point, UberGoober. Some of the same people who leaked accurate Update 1 rumors claim that windowed Modern apps will arrive in Windows 9 next year. But by then, too little too late? It seems like a feature that might have been included from the start-- what's the delay? And are there any Modern apps that users are hankering to run in a window on the desktop?
Re: Yawn...
I don't suppose you would care to make a small wager on how most tablets are used, would you?
Yes, many are used essentially as big-screen smart-phones in business, but even then, the vast majority are used for information consumption; very few are used for much besides reading or looking stuff up. For consuming information they are unquestionabley handy, but for most uses, tablets are terrible for creating it; typing on glass and pointing with a half-inch-wide finger makes for terrible ergonomics.
You can trot out the old bromide about salespeople all you want (people have been doing it for well over a decade), but you can't say with straight face that 20% of tablets are used primarily for business; I'd bet the number is much less than 10%.
For the C-level meetings, c'mon. Nobody is more style-obsessed than a high-level corporate guy. Actual business use is not guaranteed by having an iPad in your hand.
Yes, many are used essentially as big-screen smart-phones in business, but even then, the vast majority are used for information consumption; very few are used for much besides reading or looking stuff up. For consuming information they are unquestionabley handy, but for most uses, tablets are terrible for creating it; typing on glass and pointing with a half-inch-wide finger makes for terrible ergonomics.
You can trot out the old bromide about salespeople all you want (people have been doing it for well over a decade), but you can't say with straight face that 20% of tablets are used primarily for business; I'd bet the number is much less than 10%.
For the C-level meetings, c'mon. Nobody is more style-obsessed than a high-level corporate guy. Actual business use is not guaranteed by having an iPad in your hand.
Re: Yawn...
Agreed, Laurie. I find tablets limiting for certain kinds of productivity, but I think it's inaccurate and myopic to whitewash tablets as consumption devices. We explored various workplace tablet use cases in a magazine article last spring, and just today, Eric Zeman stated most knowledge workers could probably get by with Samsung's new 12-inch tablet.
Re: all ui and no internal changes?
Oh, PowerShell... There's an industry of Microsoft partners who exist just to make PowerShell less difficult to deal with.
Anyhow, you bring up an interesting point. Microsoft brought a bunch of enterprise capabilities online with Windows 8.1, but some are still missing. But is that really what's keeping enterprises from adopting?
Anyhow, you bring up an interesting point. Microsoft brought a bunch of enterprise capabilities online with Windows 8.1, but some are still missing. But is that really what's keeping enterprises from adopting?
Re: Yawn...
I would disagree that tablets are primarily "entertainment-consuming platforms." In all manner of industries, salespeople are using tablets as primary device now -- at home office and in the field. Many knowledge workers can do what they need to on a tablet. Tablets may have started out as "nice to have" but they have become must-have at many enterprises. Also, go to any C-level gathering (board meeting, conference, etc.) and you will see all tablets.
Re: Yawn...
There is no way anything that can be called a 'tweak' will fix Win8. If M$ wants to keep the 'Modern' UI for real computers (as opposed to tablets, which are primarily entertainment-consuming platforms), it should be in a window inside the traditional desktop.
Re: Yawn...
Thanks for weighing in. Desktop user frustration coming through loud and clear here. Perhaps the tweaks did not go far enough?
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security Enterprise
To learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
White Papers
Current Issue
Digital Transformation Myths & TruthsTransformation is on every IT organization's to-do list, but effectively transforming IT means a major shift in technology as well as business models and culture. In this IT Trend Report, we examine some of the misconceptions of digital transformation and look at steps you can take to succeed technically and culturally.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong 
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll
- Terms of Service
- Privacy Statement
- Legal Entities
- Copyright © 2017 UBM, All rights reserved
Tweet This
User Rank: Strategist
3/7/2014 | 5:21:06 PM