It's way too early to declare Windows and Surface failures in the market, although it would be foolish to expect it to obviate Windows 7 any time soon, especially in business and double-especially on desktops. In the meantime, its job is to recover market share for Microsoft that has been lost to Apple iPads and Android tablets, and there's reason to believe it's doing that.
Is Windows 8 a disappointment already?
It's hardly surprising that people would claim that, but is there anything to it? I have to think it's too soon to tell.
But there are reasons to believe that consumers are buying, or at least interested in, Windows 8 and Surface. Consider the graph below, which cites StatCounter data to show that Windows 8 is already being used more as a Web client than Android:
Now to me the striking part of this chart is that both products are less than 1% of overall traffic, and StatCounter doesn't get everything on the Web, but it's a plausibly accurate measure.
And there's no way to claim that people are unaware of Windows 8 and Surface, although they might be confused about the distinctions between them. Both have gotten extensive press attention and -- especially Surface -- advertising.
It's just one example but, for what it's worth, here are the "top searched [electronics] products on PriceGrabber.com and click-thrus to merchant sites" for November 16-22, 2012, starting with the most popular:
Surface 10.6" 64 GB Wi-Fi Black Tablet w/ Black Touch Cover
iPad with Retina Display 4th Generation 9.7" 16 GB Wi-Fi White Tablet
iPad 2 9.7" 16 GB Wi-Fi White Tablet
iPhone 4 8 GB White Smartphone AT&T
UN46EH6030F 46" 3D 1080p LED-LCD TV - 16:9 - HDTV 1080p
Wow, Surface is number one? In fact, it was number one on StatCounter's overall list, not just electronics. Instinctively I found this surprising, but maybe I shouldn't be. Like I said, Surface has been heavily publicized. That Dell Latitude ST tablet is a Windows 7 device, although it's probably upgradable.
At least as interesting as the Surface placement is where the Apple products are. True, the iPads are still on the top-searched list, but near the bottom, below several Android devices. And where's the iPad Mini?
Sales figures can be complicated and misleading. Very often when you see sales figures they are only through certain channels, such as retail only.
I haven't seen any sales numbers yet that I would trust. But I will make one observation: I expect Windows 7 sales to remain very strong, especially with businesses. It's been widely claimed already that Windows 8 is a poor match for a conventional desktop computer. I don't totally agree with this, but clearly there's a lot to it.
It's true of almost every Windows version that businesses take a long time to upgrade. The best example to the contrary is Windows 7, a highly-regarded version that replaced a long-incumbent version, Windows XP. Businesses are still deep into their plans for replacing Windows XP with Windows 7, so don't expect them to jump on the opportunity to make a change to something radically different when Windows 7 is available. So you can expect Windows 8 to be a mostly a consumer market phenomenon, although obviously many tablets with Windows 8 will be bought for business.
And I'll make a prediction: Expect a Windows 8.5 (or something like that) that has a desktop mode more like the Windows 7 desktop. Only then will business sales take off.
But in the meantime, If Microsoft loses Windows 8 sales to Windows 7, well, things could be a whole lot worse.
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security EnterpriseTo learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
2017 State of IT ReportIn today's technology-driven world, "innovation" has become a basic expectation. IT leaders are tasked with making technical magic, improving customer experience, and boosting the bottom line -- yet often without any increase to the IT budget. How are organizations striking the balance between new initiatives and cost control? Download our report to learn about the biggest challenges and how savvy IT executives are overcoming them.