My blog a few weeks ago on MicroStrategy's Mobile BI launch spurred an offline debate that deserves open consideration and, well, further debate... So what's the distinction between a mobile BI app and browser-based access to BI?
My blog a few weeks ago on MicroStrategy's Mobile BI launch spurred an offline debate that deserves open consideration and, well, further debate.
One reader asked me why I did not mention Pentaho's support of the iPhone since they were one of the first to support it. My distinction is that they didn't have a purpose-built app. What Pentaho provided was extensions that allowed Pentaho's BI Server to be accessed via the iPhone Safari browser. If I were talking about all vendors who have a Web-based mobile-BI strategy, there are others I would add to the list, such as Information Builders, Jaspersoft and perhaps IBM Cognos (but since the latter has an app approach for Blackberry, I suspect an app for iPhone is just a matter of time).
So what's the distinction or the big deal?In the mid '90s, delivering BI via a browser was a major step toward making BI more accessible and scalable. Just as BI vendors had to rethink what capabilities they provide via a browser versus via a desktop app, so too will vendors have to rethink what they deliver via a smartphone app... or not.
Accessing BI content via a smartphone browser may offer some advantages in terms of full Web-BI capabilities and device support. But it poses a number of challenges including sub-optimal screen rendering, slow response time for both functionality and data, inaccessibility when the signal is weak, and so on.
Purpose-built smartphone apps offer a number of advantages over browser-based smartphone access. Some of these include faster response time, device-based caching, optimal rendering for the correct screen size, leveraging of built-in GPS capabilities, barcode reading, and so on. My preference is for the app approach, but note that this is strictly a matter of opinion. A similar architectural debate applies to production- style reporting, with certain vendors advocating browser-based BI authoring for all BI content, whereas others don't. There are pros and cons in either philosophy.
The issue, of course, is what capabilities get put into the iPhone/iPad BI app and what gets left out (and which approach to take for which device!). The ability to design a new report on an iPhone may not be an oft-requested requirement, but users would certainly want view, sort, filter, refresh and answer -prompt capabilities. How about "send to" and "save locally" options? These are the design issues that vendors and customers alike face in deciding which way to deploy mobile BI... and when. I think of some of my colleagues who refuse to use, for example, the e-Trade iPhone app because it's too limiting compared to the Web-based version. Conversely, trying to use a smartphone browser for Facebook is painful compared to the app, on either the BlackBerry or the iPhone. In testing the few BI tools that have an iPad/iphone BI app, there certainly are differences in capabilities among all the vendors.
I welcome vendors and customers alike to share their opinions on what approach they prefer and why: smartphone browser or purpose-built smartphone app? If it's the latter, what features are most important for mobile BI?
Thanks to Lon Amick for challenging my views on this!
Cindi Howson, BI ScorecardMy blog a few weeks ago on MicroStrategy's Mobile BI launch spurred an offline debate that deserves open consideration and, well, further debate... So what's the distinction between a mobile BI app and browser-based access to BI?
How Enterprises Are Attacking the IT Security EnterpriseTo learn more about what organizations are doing to tackle attacks and threats we surveyed a group of 300 IT and infosec professionals to find out what their biggest IT security challenges are and what they're doing to defend against today's threats. Download the report to see what they're saying.
2017 State of IT ReportIn today's technology-driven world, "innovation" has become a basic expectation. IT leaders are tasked with making technical magic, improving customer experience, and boosting the bottom line -- yet often without any increase to the IT budget. How are organizations striking the balance between new initiatives and cost control? Download our report to learn about the biggest challenges and how savvy IT executives are overcoming them.