The two offerings demonstrate how small BI vendors are trying to show their innovation stripes in a rapidly consolidating industry, while larger vendors seem to treat the combo of Web 2.0 and BI as a cautious experiment. As mashup technology becomes easier to use, businesses face a big challenge in "how to allow end users access to the power of these tools without compromising the trust and integrity they have worked so hard to get into their data infrastructures," says Donald MacCormick, chief transformation officer with SAP's Business Objects, in an e-mail. As a result, mashups tend to be created by IT on the server-side data access layer of the Business Objects BI platform, instead of with SAP's Crystal Reports or Xcelsius data visualization tool, SAP says.
The ability for business users to create BI apps is new to most IT organizations, which are used to building OLAP cubes of data against which users can run queries and generate reports. But it's hard to imagine Web 2.0 approaches eliminating the need for such work. The new mashup technologies are mainly ways for presenting information in new, appealing forms while bringing in helpful external information. Data still has to be captured and organized in a way that it can easily be linked into mashups.
Still, emerging Web 2.0 approaches could take away some of IT's control over BI. "There's a trend around enabling end users and those who are not developers to get more control over how they analyze information," says Roger Oberg, Spotfire's VP of product strategy.
As Web 2.0 meets BI for the masses, businesses will need to reconsider how BI is managed and controlled throughout an organization. Managers from both business and IT should think about whether there are users who can benefit from these novel approaches to BI, and how they'll go about creating them.