Virtualization's Promise And Problems - InformationWeek
04:15 PM
Connect Directly

Virtualization's Promise And Problems

The virtual desktop and data center are here, but for this technology to continue taking over the enterprise, I/O and security issues need to be addressed.

Virtualization is all over the data center and is rapidly moving onto users' desktops. As it spreads out, it's cutting hardware upgrade costs, simplifying administration from central servers, and giving users the desktops they prefer.

To continue its sweep through the enterprise, the technology needs to overcome I/O performance problems caused by running a lot of virtual machines on one server. Once the I/O issues are solved, virtualization will be more useful for both production server and end-user applications. However, in order to function well in both these areas, virtualization security must be improved as well.

Despite looming I/O and security issues, server virtualization is well established. According to Forrester Research, it has reached a "tipping point," with 23% of businesses having at least two years experience implementing the technology, and by 2009, more than half (51%) are expected to have that level of experience. Today, 24% of servers have been virtualized, says Forrester analyst Frank Gillett, and by 2009, 45% are expected to be.

InformationWeek Reports

There are several approaches to desktop virtualization, with no one emerging as the best. But with this technology, once you commit to an approach, it's hard to reverse course, so companies are moving cautiously. One thing that's spurring them on is the potential savings, which can match or exceed that in the data center, says Sumit Dhawan, senior manager for Citrix Systems' desktop product marketing group.

Experienced desktop virtualization vendors such as Citrix, VMware, Virtual Iron, and Hewlett-Packard offer a range of options. They can generate virtual desktops on central servers and let thousands of end users access them there or stream them to end-user machines, though this is more resource intensive. They also can generate virtualized applications and offer them as software as a service or stream just what's needed to users on demand.

Arnett has tested the virtual desktop waters but isn't ready to let his entire company jump in

Arnett has tested the virtual desktop waters but isn't ready to let his entire company jump in

Photo by Erica Berger
Sun Microsystems joins the vendor lineup, with the ability to interpret Microsoft's RDP networking protocol into user presentations on top of VMware, providing users with Solaris, Linux, and thin-client options.

But the trick to successful implementation of virtual desktops isn't which technology you pick, say two early adopters, but rather starting out with small, well-defined groups of users and developing a plan as you go.

Tony Arnett, senior systems engineer at Pentair Water Pool and Spa, has been testing virtual desktops with various groups of users for more than a year. For each target group, he builds a customized desktop, or "golden image," of a virtual machine suited to that group's needs. A golden image for accounting will have different applications and perhaps a different version of Windows than one for sales or manufacturing, though, he says, for testing purposes, he's made the images "very vanilla."

Arnett has implemented the virtual desktops on a set of three high-availability servers running VMware's ESX hypervisor and Virtual Desktop Infrastructure 3, with its tools for generating and managing VMs. Users get a Wyse V10L thin-client machine, a diskless presentation device that links to VMware's Connection Server. They self-install the thin client, connecting it to the virtual desktop using Connection Server, which manages users' access to VMs through the company's identity management system, Microsoft Active Directory.

Arnett figures if he can successfully automate the provisioning process for the first 10 users, then a hundred can easily follow.

Think there's no rush to consider desktop virtualization? Just take a look at Merrill Lynch's plans.
Initially, he built a desktop for 10 IT staffers, tested it for a few weeks, and then tore it down, saving the golden image. Then he built one for 10 technical support workers, tested it, and tore it down, likewise saving the core image. He's gone through the same process with manufacturing as well as shipping and receiving, but he's not yet ready to roll out virtual desktops to the company as a whole.

Arnett has limited the test groups to 10 so he doesn't get flooded with 50 users needing information and connections at the same time. So far, the tests have been "controlled and methodical, and the desktops have worked well," he says.

Arnett is still figuring out exactly which end users and how many of them will make the switch permanently. "Quite a few departments would be perfect candidates," he says of the 1,400-employee company.

We welcome your comments on this topic on our social media channels, or [contact us directly] with questions about the site.
1 of 5
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
10/20/2011 | 8:05:15 AM
re: Virtualization's Promise And Problems
mostly problems of virtualization are security and management complications but according to this article i read there are some problems solvers available.
So with time new and modern technology as well standards are coming in to sort out such issues related to virtualization, but one thing that companies need to be aware of is that the benefits in one sector should not become a source of problem in another.
Why Your Company's AI Strategy May Not Be Its Own
Lisa Morgan, Freelance Writer,  3/18/2019
Q&A: Deloitte's Lisa Noon on Inclusivity and Cloud Evolution
Joao-Pierre S. Ruth, Senior Writer,  3/15/2019
Empowering Women in the Workplace 365 Days a Year
Guest Commentary, Guest Commentary,  3/19/2019
White Papers
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
2018 State of the Cloud
2018 State of the Cloud
Cloud adoption is growing, but how are organizations taking advantage of it? Interop ITX and InformationWeek surveyed technology decision-makers to find out, read this report to discover what they had to say!
Current Issue
Security and Privacy vs. Innovation: The Great Balancing Act
This InformationWeek IT Trend Report will help you better understand and address the growing challenge of balancing the need for innovation with the real-world threats and regulations.
Flash Poll