Stanford Law Professor Raps Patents As Barrier To Innovation - InformationWeek
IoT
IoT
Software // Enterprise Applications
News
4/7/2005
02:55 PM
Connect Directly
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

Stanford Law Professor Raps Patents As Barrier To Innovation

The government shouldn't regulate software development through patent enforcement, Lawrence Lessig says.

Lawrence Lessig, Stanford University law professor, author, and member of the board of the Free Software Foundation, urged open-source developers Wednesday to actively oppose the use of patents to tie up software functionality.

After years of case law, "there's no clear showing of benefits over harm" in software patents, he argued in an address to attendees at the Open Source Business Conference in San Francisco. Patents exist to protect a particular company's development effort, but they end up serving as a means for early innovators in a field to tie up subsequent innovation years later through legal means, he said.

Being challenged on a patent or copyright violation will immobilize a young, innovative company's resources in the courts, or worse, put it out of business. SonicBlue, owner of the ReplayTV digital video recorder, was sued in 2001 by Disney ABC network and the Viacom Paramount movie studio for violation of copyright. The plaintiffs did not have to prove their case to get SonicBlue out of the market. It went bankrupt 18 months later, having spent $3 million a quarter defending itself, Lessig said.

Lessig said it didn't matter how often he and other free-software advocates spoke out against overuse of patents and copyright. "I'm a puny Stanford law professor. If you're depending on me, you're lost," he warned. Large companies that frequently file for patents represent an established lobby for the laws that keep the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in business. "That huge sucking sound is Microsoft filling its arsenal with lawyers," he said.

Microsoft chief software architect Bill Gates said in a July 29 meeting with financial analysts that Microsoft planned to apply for more than 3,000 software patents in 2005.

Although not mentioned by Lessig, IBM also frequently seeks patents on its software. In 2001, it filed applications for 3,411 patents and was the largest filer for nine years in a row before that, according to a company biography on the Gurteen Knowledge Web site. Small companies also frequently patent their developments as well.

IBM has pledged not to use its patents to restrain open-source code developers. But Lessig said any company building up libraries of patents might be unable to resist the temptation to claim ownership of software and sue future innovators who are invading what the established company considers its turf.

"The government should stay out of regulating software innovation," said Lessig, claiming he was only invoking a time-honored stand of adherents of the Republican Party. He shouldn't be called a Communist for doing so, he added. "The biggest problem is, this debate is dominated by lawyers and lobbyists. You have to fight," he concluded.

Open-source-code software developers can actively support political candidates that oppose the excessive granting of patents, he said. They can invest in companies that foreswear the use of patent-based legal action against other software developers. "To what extent do you support free organizations? Do you spend as much there as you spend with companies that have monopolies?" he asked.

The debate is miscast as the United States with its patent laws versus China and other places that don't enforce U.S. patents, he said. Instead, it should be viewed as a contest of the interests of big, established companies versus small companies and the innovators yet to come.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
[Interop ITX 2017] State Of DevOps Report
[Interop ITX 2017] State Of DevOps Report
The DevOps movement brings application development and infrastructure operations together to increase efficiency and deploy applications more quickly. But embracing DevOps means making significant cultural, organizational, and technological changes. This research report will examine how and why IT organizations are adopting DevOps methodologies, the effects on their staff and processes, and the tools they are utilizing for the best results.
Register for InformationWeek Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Digital Transformation Myths & Truths
Transformation is on every IT organization's to-do list, but effectively transforming IT means a major shift in technology as well as business models and culture. In this IT Trend Report, we examine some of the misconceptions of digital transformation and look at steps you can take to succeed technically and culturally.
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
Sponsored Live Streaming Video
Everything You've Been Told About Mobility Is Wrong
Attend this video symposium with Sean Wisdom, Global Director of Mobility Solutions, and learn about how you can harness powerful new products to mobilize your business potential.
Flash Poll