How To Hire Your Next CIO

Business technology is in transition. Make sure your next CIO can rise to the challenge.
Hiring, Budget Concerns Top Of Mind For IT Leaders In 2016
Hiring, Budget Concerns Top Of Mind For IT Leaders In 2016
(Click image for larger view and slideshow.)

It's time to say goodbye to IT and say hello to something new, perhaps called "digital services." But getting there will take leadership. If you're hiring a new CIO, or are part of a team that's hiring a new CIO, it's a great opportunity to steer the ship in the right direction. 

While the specifics may vary from business to business, if you want a CIO who can pilot the ship through massive change in how we think about IT, I think you're looking for someone who will be able to (a) keep the lights on (but not to the exclusion of all else), (b) execute on a digital vision, and (c) be fiscally literate enough that she or he will gently push when the funding equation is out of whack.

Feel free to chime in below, but here are the top categories that I think you need to dig into during any CIO assessment:

Tech Savvy

Yes, that's right. The pendulum swung too far in the direction of "techie," especially during the 1980s. Now it has swung pretty far in the other direction: "nobody needs to know technology, we can get just an MBA to run IT!" Nope.

Getting the most out of business technology requires someone who understands technology -- an enlightened technologist, someone who has been a technologist and understands technologists. You can't just be "good with people," and expect to succeed. Success with business technology in the past, and success with digital services in the future, requires that the leader-in-charge be able to understand the underlying technology.

[Knowing what drives away your best IT workers offers clues about how to retain them. See 5 Ways To Lose Your Best IT Talent.]

A Strong Marketer and Communicator

Your new CIO will have to be a great communicator. That's nothing new. There will be plenty of vendor management, customer management, and employee management, and that requires precise, timely communication.


More than yesterday's CIO, the new CIO will need to understand and execute on mass communication directly to customers. 

We are in the age of "the new marketing" (inbound, content marketing, call it what you will).

Few understand it, and it's still emerging and evolving. Yet, our organizations will wither and die if your digital leader doesn't both understand it and execute on it.

In the same way that your CIO must be at least partially a technologist, your new CIO must be comfortable with marketing and communication. She or he will be more and more frequently directing communications on behalf of the organization and making sure that old-school, throw-everything-against-the-wall-and-see-if-it-sticks marketers don't screw everything up. Your new CIO will help your organization understand what digital services are all about, but more importantly, will help your organization benefit.

Security Aware

It's not enough to have tech and marketing expertise. It would be foolish and naive to think that your organization can possibly succeed in creating digital services without a healthy dose of security policy and execution. The threat landscape gets worse every year.

Look for someone who isn't paralyzed by fear over security, but someone who isn't laissez-faire about it, either. It's not a must to hire an ex-CISO, but it will be helpful to hire someone who has had practical security expertise, particularly in risk management and in seeking funding to mitigate problems. Digital services can only succeed when they're secure.

Collaborative and Big Picture

Your new CIO can't be stuck in the weeds. He or she can't be married to marketing, can't be in love with the bits and the bytes, and can't be focused on security above everything else. Your new CIO must be flexible and have the big picture in mind.

Yes, expertise is needed in tech and marketing. But, above all else, your new CIO must be mission focused and business driven. 

Look for proof of competency. Jenn Taylor, COO of 501 Partners, a business technology consultancy, says that talking about the way that a CIO would manage is one thing. But he or she would also want people that the candidate had worked with to say, "This person actually listened to us and collaborated."

It's a great point. Look for someone with multiple references that prove expertise in all of the factors you want. Above all else, look for someone who was collaborative enough in previous roles to allow business partners to bring their expertise to the table.

That collaboration factor is the core of the new digital services model, and it's a must in your next CIO.

Elite 100 2016: DEADLINE EXTENDED TO JAN. 15, 2016 There's still time to be a part of the prestigious InformationWeek Elite 100! Submit your company's application by Jan. 15, 2016. You'll find instructions and a submission form here: InformationWeek's Elite 100 2016.

Editor's Choice
Cynthia Harvey, Freelance Journalist, InformationWeek
John Edwards, Technology Journalist & Author
Jessica Davis, Senior Editor