Get news 
- May 23, 2012 14:00 PM Join us for a conversation between Carla Wolfe, one of the main characters in this story, and Chris ...
- May 23, 2012 14:00 PM Jon Arnold’s presentation will review the trends and drivers that have brought us to the present s ...
- May 23, 2012 14:00 PM Join Bank Systems & Technology, Netop, and Forrester Research for a free one-hour webcast that explo ...
Loading Carousel Data, Please wait ..
BYTE Technologists
BYTE Categories
BYTE Newsletter
Keep up with all the BYTE News and Reviews
Apple Receives Multitasking Phone Patent
Category: Tablets, Smartphones
Apple has received US patent #8,082,523 for a mobile phone with a touch screen and GUI which allows the user to invoke other apps while a phone call continues. Here's the abstract:
More Insights
Webcasts
- Thriving in a Multi-Platform World: Integrating Mobile Device Management into Your Overall Security Strategy
- CTO to CTO: Scott Davies, VMware, and Jim Davies, Mitel, Give Voice to the Virtual Desktop
White Papers
- Gartner Research Picking the Right Server Type to Solve Your Data Center Space, Power and Heat Problems
- Forrester TAP: Blades paper
Reports
More >>
A portable electronic device displays, on a touch screen display, a user interface for a phone application during a phone call. In response to detecting activation of a menu icon or menu button, the UI for the phone application is replaced with a menu of application icons, while maintaining the phone call. In response to detecting a finger gesture on a non-telephone service application icon, displaying a user interface for the non-telephone service application while continuing to maintain the phone call, the UI for the non-telephone service application including a switch application icon that is not displayed in the UI when there is no ongoing phone call. In response to detecting a finger gesture on the switch application icon, replacing display of the UI for the non-telephone service application with a respective UI for the phone application while continuing to maintain the phone call.
At first this would seem to be a big problem for other players in the smart phone market, as they all now allow users to run other apps while a phone call is in progress. Experts believe there might be prior art, depending on how precisely the patent is to be construed.
There are many examples of earlier smartphones, including BlackBerry and Palm Treo phones, that allowed this function. But these were not touch screen phones. In the abstract above and in the more detailed list of Claims, the patent speaks largely of user interface and finger gestures. The patent only claims certain methods of invoking an application while a phone call is in progress. Apple filed the patent application on Jan. 6, 2008.
Other smart phones would seem to violate the Apple patent, narrow as it might be. But Apple has many user interface patents related to various gestures.
The Apple patent in flowchart form.
So it's not clear whether a prior art argument would work. "The other big question is whether this patent is obvious. When something is 'obvious,' it is not patentable, but it is difficult to make a clear-cut definition of obvious," Deborah Sweeney, CEO of MyCorporation.com, told BYTE in an email interview.
How did we get to a situation where such things are patentable? The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has been issuing a flood of such patents for years, making it difficult for software developers to know what is and isn't off limits. Says Sweeney, "...this patent may be considered by many to be weak and calls into question whether the USPTO is monetarily motivated to issue patents."
Larry Seltzer is the Editorial Director of Byte.
Related Reading
 |
To upload an avatar photo, first complete your Disqus profile. | View the list of supported HTML tags you can use to style comments. | Please read our commenting policy. |
COMMENTS
Tune In to BYTE
Related Webcasts
- Thriving in a Multi-Platform World: Integrating Mobile Device Management into Your Overall Security Strategy
- CTO to CTO: Scott Davies, VMware, and Jim Davies, Mitel, Give Voice to the Virtual Desktop
- What Impact Will Windows 8 Have on the Tablet Market?
- Cloud or Premise Based Contact Center – Which is Right [for YOU]?
- Enhance Business Performance with Process Oriented Data Stewardship
Whitepapers
In this paper you will learn the five trends shaping
the future of enterprise mobility. Learn how the rise of social media as
a business application, the lurring between work and home, the emergence
of new mobile devices, the demand for tech savvy employees and changing
expectations of corporate IT will fundamentally change the workplace.
In a survey of more than 1,700 information workers
(iWorkers) in North America, notebooks, desktops, and smartphones were
found to be “must-have” devices, while tablets, slates, and netbooks
were relegated to “nice-to-have” status, according to a commissioned
study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Dell and Intel.
Upcoming Events
Oct 20: Becoming a Security Detective - Gathering and Analyzing Security Intelligence in the Enterprise
In this all-day virtual event, experts will offer detailed insight in how to collect security intelligence in the enterprise, and how to analyze and study it in order to efficiently identify new threats as well as low-and-slow attacks such as advanced persistent threats. Register today!
Platinum Sponsors: ArcSight, NetIQ, Proofpoint, Thawte
Gold Sponsor: Q1 Labs
October 6: InformationWeek 500 Virtual Event: The Need for Speed
At the 2011 InformationWeek 500 Virtual Conference, C-level executives from leading global companies will gather to discuss how their organizations are turbo-charging business execution and growth.
Platinum Sponsor: ArcSight, Workday
Gold Sponsor: IBM
Aug 25: InformationWeek & Dark Reading present: How Security Breaches Happen and What Your Organization Can Do About Them
Attendees will get insights on how to prevent breaches from happening, how to research and identify the source of a breach, and how to remediate a compromise as quickly and efficiently as possible.
Platinum Sponsor: ArcSight, NetIQ, Thawte
Gold Sponsors: Lumension, NetGear, GFI
Silver Sponsor: Motorola
July 28: InformationWeek & Symantec present: Infrastructure at Risk -- Taking Decisive Action to Secure Your Critical Data Assets
Join the editors of InformationWeek and leading security experts from Symantec for an in-depth look at the current threats faced by large and small organizations, and the implications for your business, your customers, and even your country. You'll hear how today's threat landscape is changing drastically, and learn the latest countermeasures and best practices to keep your company's precious data assets out of the hands of determined cybercriminals.
July 27: Electronic Health Records -- Moving from Concept to Reality
At this InformationWeek Healthcare Virtual Event, we will talk with healthcare practitioners, IT professionals and other industry experts about issues surrounding EHR selection, deployment and use.
Platinum Sponsor: HP, Intel, GBS, Geotrust, NextGen
Silver Sponsor: Proofpoint
On-Demand: InformationWeek & Interop present: Business Mobility Unleashed
In this virtual event, the leaders behind InformationWeek Business Technology Network and Interop zero in on the top mobile technologies and techniques you'll need to understand and master to ensure your organization thrives in the wireless world.
Platinum Sponsors: Alcatel-Lucent, APC
Gold Sponsor: HP
Silver Sponsor: Emerson Network Power
Bronze Sponsor: Skybot
On-Demand: Cybersecurity Best Practices
In this half-day virtual event, experts assess the state of cybersecurity in government and present the latest strategies for creating a more secure, attack-proof IT infrastructure. This event will help CISOs and other information assurance professionals in federal, state, and local government stay on top of the latest developments in the field.
Platinum Sponsor: GeoTrust
Gold Sponsor: Bit9
On-Demand: Data Center Transformation
Data centers are undergoing incredible transformations that create
both opportunities and challenges for IT professionals. Server virtualization enables rapid provisioning,
more efficient use of resources, and improved disaster recovery. That trend will continue with storage and network virtualization,
allowing IT pros to further abstract -- and optimize -- data center resources.In this virtual event, you will learn how prepare your organization for a data center transformation.
Platinum Sponsors: AMD, APC, Cisco, Eaton, SunGard
Gold Sponsor: Emerson Network Power
On-Demand: Cloud Computing Roadmap: Controlling the Cloud - Managing, Optimizing and Integrating Cloud Services with Your Existing IT Infrastructure
In this virtual event, you'll learn how to craft your own strategy for successfully embracing and integrating new cloud computing capabilities without derailing or destroying your current IT roadmap.
Platinum Sponsors: ArcSight, GoToAssist, SunGard, thawte
Gold Sponsor: Symform
Silver Sponsor: Skybot
On-Demand: Plugging the Leaks -- Finding and Fixing the IT Security Holes in your Enterprise
In this virtual event presented by Dark Reading and InformationWeek, you'll find out how criminals target the flaws in your IT environment, and you'll get some insight on the best methods for finding and fixing your vulnerabilities -- before you're hit by malware or unauthorized access.
Platinum Sponsors: NetIQ, Novell, thawte, Webroot
Gold Sponsors: ArcSight, Bit9, OpenText
Silver Sponsor: Application Security, Core Security, Lumension
The 2011 Informationweek 500 Conference will be held at the beautiful St. Regis Monarch Beach Resort, Dana Point, CA. Mark your calendars for September 11-13, 2011.
InformationWeek Healthcare IT Leadership Forum
Related Reports
Related Whitepapers
- Forrester Research study How Blade Servers Impact Datacenter Management and Agility
- ESG whitepaper: Defining Tier One Storage in the Modern Data Center
- Forrester: Virtualization Expands As An Option For Mission Critical Applications
- The Hidden Truth About Virtualizing Business-Critical Applications
- Meeting the Challenges of Endpoint Security
Comments:
2011-12-24T06:02:27
Actually, my Treo 650 was, in fact, a touch-screen phone that could do just this... I think Jobs brought one of these into Appke in 2005 and said,"Why don't we improve this??"
Icons in rows and columns? Check. Touch screen? Check. Switch from call to app? Check... commercial on youtube similar to Appke? Check. Search for palm treo650 and bluetooth video.
Permalink