Higher education CIOs are doing fine, thank you. Let's dispel some falsehoods.
In the spirit of the numbered list popular this time of year, I thought I would add something from the world of higher education CIOs.
There has always been a wealth of negative assumptions about higher education CIOs found in the higher education press and technology trade publications. These anecdotes are usually based on a sample size of three or four CIOs or an isolated conversation. The data I'll be using to confirm or rebut these assumptions is based on research conducted by the Center for Higher Education Chief Information Officer Studies since 2003. Hundreds of CIOs, technology leaders, and institution management team (IMT) members (the other school presidents and vice presidents) respond to the CHECS survey every year.
Here are my top 10 assumptions about higher education CIOs gathered up over the past decade, along with the survey data that disputes them.
No. 10 – Higher education CIOs change jobs frequently. In fact, CIOs spent more time in their current position than other members of the IMT. In 2013, higher education CIOs had been in their position for an average of seven years and six months versus IMT members, who had spent an average of six years and eight months in their positions.
No. 9 – CIOs must have a technical degree major. There are a few different ways of looking at this assumption. The first is by looking at which degree higher education CIOs actually believe a CIO should possess. The single largest answer, 37%, was from higher education CIOs who did not believe a technical degree major was important for the CIO. However, 51% of IMT members indicated the CIO should possess a technology major. So there's a disconnect between what CIOs and the IMT view as the major needed for the job. But because CIOs actually do the job, I presume they know better.
No. 8 – Higher education CIOs must report to the institution president in order to be effective. As someone who served as a CIO for a number of years, I think it is important for the CIO to report to the president. However, the results of my own survey research over a 10-year period have not revealed a statistically significant difference in effectiveness – measured through a series of survey questions -- between those CIOs who report to the president and those who do not. In 2013, 32% of the CIOs reported to the president, according to the CHECS survey.
No. 7 – Higher education CIOs must serve on the IMT in order to be effective. Over the 10 years that the CHECS research has been conducted, there have been three years when there was a statistically significant difference in effectiveness between those CIOs who served on the IMT and those who did not. In 2013, 55% of the CIOs served on the IMT.
No. 6 – Higher education CIOs are being hired from the faculty ranks. While this may have been true when the profession was much younger, it is no longer true. In 2013, only 6% of higher education CIOs had been faculty members in their last position.
. We've got a management crisis right now, and we've also got an engagement crisis. Could the two be linked? Tune in for the next installment of IT Life Radio, Wednesday May 20th at 3PM ET to find out.