CIO = Chief Incompetence Officer?

A new survey says IT projects continue to fail at an alarming rate, and that a significant number of business managers and even corporate board members accept IT failure as a given. If true, that's bad news, for a lot of reasons. But how true is it?Tata Consultancy Services published a press release today touting the results of a survey it sponsored (conducted by a company called Dynamic Markets) of 800 middle- and senior-level IT managers in eight countries (France, Germany, India, Japan, Singapore, Sweden, the U.K.,and the United States). The results, according to Tata: "IT project underperformance accepted as the norm."

It's always hard to comment on survey results based on a summary, because you're not seeing or judging the raw data, only the summary's interpretation of that data. For example, here's the first paragraph of Tata's press release:

What are we to make of the first sentence, that "1 in 3 companies' IT projects fail to perform against expectations." In my experience, expectations for a project usually run pretty high, and the end results rarely live up to those expectations. So if 2/3 of surveyed respondents answered yes to the question, "Do your IT projects perform up to expectations?" I'd be tempted to say at least some of those respondents were lying.

Here's another factoid from the survey, not in the press release but on a linked page: " 62% of organizations experienced IT projects that failed to meet their schedules." Once again, my experience with projects and schedules tells me that that number should be higher, perhaps a lot higher.

I'm not trying to cast aspersions on Tata Consultancy's survey; I'm trying to understand the implications of it. One of IT's worst problems is its reputation for incompetence, I certainly agree with that, and if that incompetence isn't being dealt with -- and aggressively -- the CIO in charge should be shown the door. Tata's prescription for that incompetence is this:

My experience tells me that there might be a flaw in this logic, too, along these lines: If incompetence is endemic to an organization, handing off projects to third-parties isn't going to help the problem; it might in the short run, but certainly not in the long run.

But, hey, it's Tata's survey, and they can interpret it however they like.