Health Information Exchange Needs A Simpler Model

The CEOs of four cloud-based healthcare IT firms express skepticism about HIEs, seeing them as a bureaucracy rather than a workable architecture.

David F Carr, Editor, InformationWeek Government/Healthcare

November 8, 2013

3 Min Read

Download the entire November 2013 issue of InformationWeek Healthcare, distributed in an all-digital format (registration required).

To the cloud generation of healthcare technologists, state-based health information exchanges look like a throwback.

The federal government has encouraged the creation of these state and regional data exchanges as part of the evolution toward an infrastructure that allows secure sharing of patient data among healthcare providers. These HIEs are supposed to connect to providers and to other exchanges -- though there's a good argument to be made that HIEs are failing to provide that connectivity.

The Direct Project is one alternative promoted by the Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT. The idea is to enable secure email between known, trusted participants, each of which has a special email address only available to healthcare providers. Email sent this way can include free-form messages but also patient data in XML --- structured data that an electronic health records system on the receiving end can parse and import.

As our cover story notes, the drawback to Direct is that it's push rather than pull. There's no centralized repository or index to query -- something HIEs are at least working toward. Direct is more of a replacement for faxing records, though at least they're machine readable.

When I spoke recently with the CEOs of four cloud-based healthcare IT firms, they greeted state HIEs with unanimous skepticism, seeing them as a bureaucracy rather than a workable architecture. Here are their quick takes:

Practice Fusion CEO Ryan Howard: Howard points out that EHRs seeking Meaningful Use Stage 2 certification have to be able to demonstrate support for sending and receiving messages over the Direct Protocol, which means they have to demonstrate basic interoperability. "That eliminates a lot of the need for an exchange," he says.

Athenahealth CEO Jonathan Bush: "Health information exchange should be a verb and not a noun. Exchange activity will iterate dramatically over time," Bush says, and he is skeptical that the right structure can be dictated by "some federally sponsored entity." Athenahealth does participate in HIEs anyway because the company wants to be easy to do business with no matter what model wins out.

CareCloud CEO Albert Santalo: "What I am a proponent of is that it should be a national infrastructure," Santalo says. "I don't think it makes any sense for every state to be building something." The Direct approach is "a little better" than navigating the maze of HIEs, but it's "just email," he says.

Girish Navani, CEO of eClinicalWorks: The HIE centralized approach makes it too easy to spend time and money trying to build a perfectly secure system. Meanwhile, nothing happens. "The Direct Project is one practical way of sharing data because it's peer-to-peer," simplifying the security challenge, Navani says. But he thinks the better alternative will be for patients to provide access to their own data -- using a phone or a QR code to unlock a health record in the cloud, much as they access their money with an ATM card.

One way or the other, health information exchange cries out for simplification.

About the Author(s)

David F Carr

Editor, InformationWeek Government/Healthcare

David F. Carr oversees InformationWeek's coverage of government and healthcare IT. He previously led coverage of social business and education technologies and continues to contribute in those areas. He is the editor of Social Collaboration for Dummies (Wiley, Oct. 2013) and was the social business track chair for UBM's E2 conference in 2012 and 2013. He is a frequent speaker and panel moderator at industry events. David is a former Technology Editor of Baseline Magazine and Internet World magazine and has freelanced for publications including CIO Magazine, CIO Insight, and Defense Systems. He has also worked as a web consultant and is the author of several WordPress plugins, including Facebook Tab Manager and RSVPMaker. David works from a home office in Coral Springs, Florida. Contact him at [email protected]and follow him at @davidfcarr.

Never Miss a Beat: Get a snapshot of the issues affecting the IT industry straight to your inbox.

You May Also Like

More Insights